With the 255/85/16's the tire width would be a little narrower then 275/70/16 but that doesn't mean you would have less rubber on the road. Wouldn't it just mean that the contact patch would be a different shape since the 255/85/16's are a larger tire? The contact patch would be determined by the tread width as a % of the aspect ratio, since the aspect ratio is so much larger you should have more rubber on the road with the 255/85/16 tire, just a different shape too the contact patch.