HELP, I Need A Good GUMBO Recipe......

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 9, 2004
Threads
64
Messages
1,295
Location
KIND
Wife's cousin makes an awesome Shrimp Gumbo with Andouille Sausage and peppers and all kinds of other sh!t. He won't come off the recipe as it is an old family recipe and he only makes it for large gatherings, maybe twice a year. He makes it in a cast iron kettle over an open pit. I'm sure that has a bit to do with the overall awesomeness of the Gumbo, but I think I can get close to it in the kitchen.

I've tried many other recipes from the web and books, but nothing comes close.

Anybody got a good gumbo recipe for Polak to try?
 
This is my wife's grandmother's recipe. She lived in Mobile, AL and made a great gumbo. You need to keep in mind that they made it with whatever was available seafood-wise. You just need to make a roux and add some chopped vegetables. The seafood goes in last.

You're going to need between 3/4 and 1 cup of bacon grease so if you don't save your bacon grease then go buy two or three pounds and fry it up. No point in starting until you have the grease in hand.

Here's the recipe, word for word.

Step 1: Chop and combine: 1 cup celery (3 stalks), 1 cup onion (1 large), and about 1 cup bell pepper (1 1/2 large peppers).

Step 2: Make the roux. Brown until dark 1 cup of flour and 3/4 to 1 cup bacon grease. Stir constantly!

Step 3: When brown add vegetables to the roux and cook about 5 minutes. Then add 1 can beef boullion, 2 quarts water, 1 small can tomato sauce, 2 tablespoons worcestershire sauce, 4 cloves of garlic (minced), and 4 bay leaves. Then add 1 pint of chopped okra and salt and pepper to taste. Add crab and shrimp [amount is unspecified but I would say at least 16 ounces of lump crab meat and 2 pounds of peeled and deveined shrimp].

Simmer this mixture covered for about 1 hour.

My wife normally makes a double recipe when she makes it as it's pretty good left over. I think we would normally use about 5 pounds of shrimp and a couple of pounds of crab meat for a double recipe. Getting the roux correct is the secret to gumbo. It needs to be dark but not burnt.



Edit: We often make gumbo when we are at our condo at the beach and we normally have access to live crabs. We will clean them and throw 3 or 4 cleaned, whole crabs and claws into this recipe. Also, we normally eat gumbo with a bit of tabasco on top and saltines to the side.
 
Last edited:
Change your avy to a Saints avy and I'll give you one.

Oh now come on..... Home team baby!

I will be happy for Brees if they pull it off, being a Purdue Alumni and all.... Does that count?
 
once you master the roux, you can proceed with the gumbo makin'...


how are your roux browning skills?
 
Oh now come on..... Home team baby!

I will be happy for Brees if they pull it off, being a Purdue Alumni and all.... Does that count?

That really doesn't count.

You are on the right track with Andouille but you will need other things like taso to make it like Saints fans do. I'll give you the recipe next week, I am out of town right now, and any good karma I can bring the Saints...........we will need it.
 
once you master the roux, you can proceed with the gumbo makin'...


how are your roux browning skills?

Not bad for a white guy.

When I lived in NC a friend of my grandfather gave me a little paperback book titled "First You Make a Rouxe", and said, "Boy, you learn dat book real good an' yo cookin' be real good now, ya hear."

/\ that's no s***.

That really doesn't count.

You are on the right track with Andouille but you will need other things like taso to make it like Saints fans do. I'll give you the recipe next week, I am out of town right now, and any good karma I can bring the Saints...........we will need it.

Best of luck, I'll look forward to the recipe, no matter how the game turns out.:cheers:
 
One of the guys I work with makes it during mini-season every year but he uses spiny lobster, I know you can substitute crawfish or shrimp though. He uses this big ass pan over an open burner, I live for this stuff. I'll see him today and see if I can get the recipe.

Well, I'm waiting!

This is my wife's grandmother's recipe. She lived in Mobile, AL and made a great gumbo. You need to keep in mind that they made it with whatever was available seafood-wise. You just need to make a roux and add some chopped vegetables. The seafood goes in last.

You're going to need between 3/4 and 1 cup of bacon grease so if you don't save your bacon grease then go buy two or three pounds and fry it up. No point in starting until you have the grease in hand.

Here's the recipe, word for word.

Step 1: Chop and combine: 1 cup celery (3 stalks), 1 cup onion (1 large), and about 1 cup bell pepper (1 1/2 large peppers).

Step 2: Make the roux. Brown until dark 1 cup of flour and 3/4 to 1 cup bacon grease. Stir constantly!

Step 3: When brown add vegetables to the roux and cook about 5 minutes. Then add 1 can beef boullion, 2 quarts water, 1 small can tomato sauce, 2 tablespoons worcestershire sauce, 4 cloves of garlic (minced), and 4 bay leaves. Then add 1 pint of chopped okra and salt and pepper to taste. Add crab and shrimp [amount is unspecified but I would say at least 16 ounces of lump crab meat and 2 pounds of peeled and deveined shrimp].

Simmer this mixture covered for about 1 hour.

My wife normally makes a double recipe when she makes it as it's pretty good left over. I think we would normally use about 5 pounds of shrimp and a couple of pounds of crab meat for a double recipe. Getting the roux correct is the secret to gumbo. It needs to be dark but not burnt.



Edit: We often make gumbo when we are at our condo at the beach and we normally have access to live crabs. We will clean them and throw 3 or 4 cleaned, whole crabs and claws into this recipe. Also, we normally eat gumbo with a bit of tabasco on top and saltines to the side.

Gracias!
 
That really doesn't count.

You are on the right track with Andouille but you will need other things like taso to make it like Saints fans do. I'll give you the recipe next week, I am out of town right now, and any good karma I can bring the Saints...........we will need it.

FWIW, I went to Tulane for my MBA and there were a few of the New Orleans "born and bred" types that I got to know pretty well. None of them would have put andouille sausage in a seafood gumbo. Yes in a duck gumbo but not with seafood. Andouille sausage was generally reserved for Red Beans and Rice and was dutifully eaten every Monday - aka wash day.

Edit: Now those guys did like file powder (pronounced fee-lay) in their gumbo which really wasn't done over in Mobile and you will find that ingredient in most "cajun" gumbo recipes. I like it both ways.
 
FWIW, I went to Tulane for my MBA and there were a few of the New Orleans "born and bred" types that I got to know pretty well. None of them would have put andouille sausage in a seafood gumbo. Yes in a duck gumbo but not with seafood. Andouille sausage was generally reserved for Red Beans and Rice and was dutifully eaten every Monday - aka wash day.

Edit: Now those guys did like file powder (pronounced fee-lay) in their gumbo which really wasn't done over in Mobile and you will find that ingredient in most "cajun" gumbo recipes. I like it both ways.

I was born and raised in New Orleans and lived 7 years of my life in the Cajun heart land (Lafayette). My family has been living in New Orleans since the 1870's and in Lafayette since 1907. I said he was on the right "track" with the andouille sausage because it is used in gumbos throughout Louisiana (chicken\wild game gumbo). It is not in my seafood gumbo. All of this family history is not me saying that our gumbo taste good though. It might taste like s**t.
 
I was born and raised in New Orleans and lived 7 years of my life in the Cajun heart land (Lafayette). My family has been living in New Orleans since the 1870's and in Lafayette since 1907. I said he was on the right "track" with the andouille sausage because it is used in gumbos throughout Louisiana (chicken\wild game gumbo). It is not in my seafood gumbo. All of this family history is not me saying that our gumbo taste good though. It might taste like s**t.

I'm sure your gumbo tastes great. Also glad to see that we agree on the sausage.

:cheers:
 
Must have worked....... now where's my recipe?:hillbilly:

I am waiting for my mother to give me the recipe. I know most of it but don't want to leave anything out. I didn't forget. I won't be able to get it today because I will be at the Saints Super bowl parade.

That was a good game but I was very surprised that Payton showed poor sportsmanship at the end of the game. I don't think that is going to go over well with his hometown folks.
 
Sorry Polak I have not been able to get in touch with my mom. She is out of the state taking care of her dieing brother. She apparently doesn't have her cell phone with her. I am going out of the country for 30 days but I will try and use skype or something like that to call and get that recipe for you. I still have not forgotten.
 
Sorry to hear this.

No biggie, I've waited a while to start trying my hand at gumbo, another month or so ain't gonna kill me.

:cheers:
 
hey fellas, is gumbo the same as jambalaya? just curious the recipes on here sure sound good.:beer:
 
Back
Top Bottom