re_guderian
SILVER Star
$0.20???? Around here it's at least $0.40 more per gallon, most between $0.40-0.60 more, Chevron up to $0.90 more per gallon. That's 9-18% more expensive. You'd have to get 1-2 mpg CONSISTENTLY better to break even, assuming a baseline of 12 mpg on regular. I have found that difficult to achieve on a consistent basis.For a trip over the continental divide, I'd go with the expensive stuff. Albeit, that's all I ever use, but especially for the high altitude and probably steep grades, I'd feel better with 91 - 95 octane (whichever you can get).
And again, for myself, I just plain seem to get better MPG from the more expensive stuff, which is a little bit of return on the extra $$ in the tank. So in the end I'm not really paying that extra .20¢/gallon, maybe more like .10¢ or .15¢ per gallon.