Granted I'm painting with a very wide brush there, but as a general rule of thumb all else being equal a stiffer setup will equal better handling. When I was doing some research on Poly vs Rubber one thing I found was that lots of people with sporty cars ('Vette's, Mustangs, etc) were switching from factory rubber to aftermarket poly because the poly was stiffer, allowed less movement, and overall increased handling or at least "feel."
Not real familiar with Vette’s, but Mustangs are hardly great handling cars, at least compared to my wife’s 350z. Changing from rubber to poly in the suspension mounts doesn’t really effect the spring rate and stiffness though. It allows the suspension pieces to flex less, so the suspension geometry changes less.
While vehicles can certainly be tuned so that good handling does not equal a harsh ride, it's generally true that in order to achieve better handling you will have a harsher ride.
It is generally true that if you take an existing platform, you will likely make it stiffer to make it handle better – but not always. Swaybars do little to make a ride more harsh, but much to achieve better handling. When you’re designing a suspension though, there are ways to not give a harsh ride and still give better handling. Last gen T/A handled great, about as good as a 3 series, maybe even a M3 of the same generation, but one of them was much more comfortable on the long road. Subaru is always an odd duck, long travel suspension (comparatively) on their RS, WRX ect. yet great handling. There is more than one way to skin the suspension cat, and some give more trade offs than others.
The more you limit yourself on what you change, the more tradeoffs and compromises you must make. If you lift a truck, any truck, and demand that it not sway on road, but limit yourself to shocks that mount on the pin to pin, limit yourself to stock mounting points, limit yourself to stock arm design, limit yourself to stock swaybars, or even swaybars that mount the same as stock, and determine that the only thing you are going to do to prevent sway is use stiffer springs – you’re making compromises – and it will ride and perform like you’ve made those compromises.
There is a reason JP’s go to long arm after a certain height. Beyond a certain point, the angle on the arms is just too much for stock mounts to function properly. There is also a reason the anti-rock is so well received. I would venture a guess (and it’d be nothing more than a guess) that part of the reason people are saying they can run without noticing issues with no front swaybar is cause the rest of the suspension is set such that it doesn’t make a difference anymore. If the springs are supper stiff, you probably won’t notice loosing the swaybar. You’ll also suffer the ride and articulation of supper stiff springs.
It is completely possible to get more out of a 80 series suspension at 6” (or even 4”) than what is generally done in the states. Longer arms, Y-radius arms – long ones, flipped arms, 5 link, x-link, SE arms, 3 link, larger swaybars, radius arm drops, torsion bar style swaybars, remote reservoir, coil-overs, progressive springs, air-bags, air-bumpstops, ect. ect. ect. There is more out there than what is currently available of the shelf in a kit, there is also much more out there than was available or known when Action Jackson did his 3 link, or FJBen before him. It’s just a matter of having the time and money and knowledge to do it, again and again, and keep experimenting until it’s done right. Since the market for a $7,000 suspension kit for a $5,000 truck that isn’t made anymore is pretty limited, you’re not likely going to see it from a vendor. Though didn’t cruiser outfitters offer a 3 link or 5 link at one time? Cost so much no one bought it if I recall. Heck, the market for 3 link on a Taco has to be 10 times that of a 80. Plus we’re all a bunch of cheap SOB’s who would just let the other guy do the development work, then do our own version at home
I know for a fact that moving from the soft OME shocks to the much stiffer ProComps greatly increased my truck's handling, turning it from a wallowing pig to something that actually feels like it's holding the road. In exchange for improved handling/feel, the ride is stiffer and I definitely notice more bumps in the road.
I usually don’t put a whole lot of faith in new shocks performing so much better than the model of the old shocks, unless those were also new. I had OME L’s on, and they worked like crap, but they were mostly junk the day I put them on (used). You could also go for some velocity sensitive shocks – which will give a softer ride as long as the bumps are slow, and then stiff’n up as the wheel movement speeds up. I’m think’n Rancho RSX’s are ‘supposed to’ perform this way.
As for the ride of the 80/450, it's not a bad ride by any stretch but--OEM--it's not what most of America would consider a "luxury" ride. The 80 series drives like a truck, not a car/minivan. That's a good thing in my book, but not what most people expect from a luxury SUV. Hence the move away from the solid front axle to IFS. Why else do you think Mr. T made that particular decision?
If you define most of America as everyone but anyone who owns a BMW, Mercedes, Lexus, or Infinity Luxury vehicle, and as an expectation of a floaty boat – sure, the LX450 is a solid European luxury ride, not a floaty caddy luxury ride.
I find it really interesting that there has been so much more done with our trucks down under. They certainly are not affraid to go outside the box.