This discussion brings back memories of when I first got into mountain biking back in the 80's and even skateboarding before that. Having to keep spots secret back then was easier, no internet. Yet, the circumstances are very similar.
The scene is the same where a secret spot is "found out", publicised and abused by those who don't cherish the spot, those who control access shut it down. For the mountain bike trails, other, more powerful lobbies (meaning $$$$) used their influence to exclude mountain bike access despite flawed studies, logic and reasoning, as we know now through hindsight. Yet, at the time, it was because the mountain bikers were unorganized, young, no power (again, meaining $$$$) and thought the "outlaw" image would somehow prevail.
I see the same thing happening here. I had numerous discussions on my trip to CO at the FJCruiser Summit with some "known" entities of the off-road world and see closures increasing for various reasons. One significant factor is that the various users (OHV, motorcycles, "side-by-sides", mountain bike, etc) are all protecting "their" turf and not willing to put their access at risk to support the other. That's where the Blue Ribbon Coalition helps bring all together.
For me, the "light bulb moment" came when I realized a significant factor to the side-by-side growth and increase in popularity...they can access motorcycle trails, we can't. They can be easily towed to a "motorcycle trailhead" by a minivan, don't have to be registered (some state require OHV stickers) or insured, can be parked beside the garage in the trailer and enjoyed just as our "full bodied" rigs can.
Users are jumping on the bandwagon, getting the joy we get being off-road, businesses are jumping on also, making more and more accessories, upgrades and vehicles in this market while "our" market is dying a slow death IMHO.
One would think this is a good thing, yet, the two "factions" don't come together to aid in each other's lobbying together for continued access for all groups. And, these factions divide deeper, Jeeps vs Cruisers, Landcruisers vs FJCruisers vs trucks, buggies vs full-bodied...it goes on and on. I can't imagine how bad it would have been if in the mountain bike fights, we has Specialized vs Trek vs Cannondale vs Klein vs ???, rigid vs front suspension vs full suspension and, we did fight road bikes vs mountain bikes which fractured cyclists as a whole. Just plain stupid.
I'm having a flashback, hope its not just product of growing up in the 70's but it is so similar, I can't help seeing that it will get a lot worse before it gets any better. Sorry for the rant...