Catalytic Converter opinion (worst exhaust work I’ve ever seen) (2 Viewers)

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 16, 2025
Threads
1
Messages
7
Location
Baton Rouge, LA
Hi guys, I recently purchased this 2007 LC and are chasing down the few issues it has. One of which is P0420 P0430. Previous owner has this work done at a local exhaust shop. (I think my 3 yr old daughter could have done a better install, but that’s besides the point)

Where would you guys go?
- through my business I could get these for $650 each? Tempted to give them a try MagnaFlow HM Grade Federal / EPA Compliant Direct-Fit Catalytic Conver - https://www.magnaflow.com/products/93142-magnaflow-hm-grade-federal-epa-compliant-direct-fit-catalytic-converter-93142?srsltid=AfmBOopO5wpc33ncCIlMi1aKkZGDu0IawYLLxbhpeSOj162iT6g5RRJ3
-bite the bullet and spend 3k on factory cats?
-or some other recommendation?

I’ve read all the other threads. On what to check first and how factory cats last longer. But starting with this mess just seeing where most of you would go on a 2007?

Thanks!
John Spurlock
Baton Rouge LA

IMG_8966.webp


IMG_8965.webp


IMG_8967.webp


IMG_8968.webp


IMG_8969.webp
 
I'm in almost the same boat. My cats were stolen Memorial Day weekend, and I've been going round and round with my insurance and their "select service" shop they pretty much made me use to get the estimate done. Unfortunately, the shop ignored the estimate phase and just had the shop go ahead and fix it with universal single cats, a bunch of pieces all welded together (poorly), and the wrong screw-in O2 sensors. Total goat rope.

Was looking at the same Magnaflow OEM-ish replacement, and trying to decide if it's worth the fight with the insurance. Current AP Exhaust cats are probably fine at keeping the MIL off and passing Oregon DEQ, but is nowhere near OEM quality. Worth it? Roll over and live to fight another day? Interested to see who responds about this thread. Not trying to hijack.
 
I had one cat stolen from my 99 a few years ago and couldn't get OEM since they were discontinued. My insurance had no problem accepting an estimate from my shop of choice. I did end up going with a Magnaflow "OEM grade" and so far is has been fine, it's been about 3 years. It bolts on in place of the original as long as your front flange is still there.

Edit: If Toyota OEM is still available for an 07, I would go with that and push the insurance to accept it. That's what I would have done if the parts still existed for the older trucks.
 
When mine were stolen the insurance inspector came and saw the CAT gone, but didn't even know it needs 2 of them, they offered $600 settlement, after a call telling them that the OEM is 3 times Each that, part only, they settled me at $1280 or so total.

Even though it's a comprehensive claim considered vandalism, I'm still paying for that settlement by having increased insurance rates, even from other companies I quoted.

Insurance is a license to steal, and I won't issue another claim ever while I'm alive (life insurance can't raise rates after a claim, right?)

Because I couldn't care less about the CAT, wish there was a way to run straight pipe w/o CEL actually, and didn't want to deal with theft again, or protective plates under the rig, I just got the cheapest pos from rockauto.. that was a couple years ago, still running OK. (Walker brand I believe).
 
I ordered the ones from landcruiserparts.net. They are a bolt on replacement. Fit nice. I Installed them yesterday. We’ll see
 
I'm in this same boat. My cats are shot at almost 200K miles and s***ty fuel while living in Mexico. Getting super hot and stinky. I have South Dakota plates, and don't need to SMOG anymore, so I'm between 1) replacing with straight pipe (don't care about codes), 2) the Magnaflow solution, or 3) the OEM wallet-buster. Curious where everyone is at a bit later in the life of this thread.
 
Aftermarket CATs, typically don't last as long. Has to do with cost (amount) of materials they use. But cost & time vs OEM, makes them a viable option.

I like the bolt on'. Since yours are already cut and welded. Best to go aftermarket and use weld on ones.
 
Also worth noting.
The 06-07 have A/F (Air fuel) sensor (not o2) forward of CAT in exhaust manifold. I can't see yours, likely due to angle of your picture.
They have O2 sensor between the two way CAT (Center of CAT). 98-05 have rear of CAT.
98-05 have two O2 sensors.

Also a mod to S.A.I filter, needs done. On 06-07 VVTi 4.7L
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom