I'd double measure. .
I think you measured incorrectly Chris. I see that you have already went with the 255s though.
For a tire to give you an increase in clearance of 1" the tire needs to be 2" larger in diameter. so you would have to be installing a 35 on there when you had 33s.
My guess is that you lowered the truck and then remeasured without moving the truck around to allow the suspension to settle. With the geometry of an IFS if you just lower the truck down, it will sit a lot higher than its normal ride height. This is mainly due to the wheel traveling in an arc and not straight up and down.