Found these Delrin rollers / direct replacement for the warn metal rollers. Delrin Rollers, Fairlead, Warn, 7. 7/8" width, Warn, Set of 4, rollers for synthetic winch lines. or I could order some Delrin off Ebay and make some rollers but I'd rather spend that time smoking a nice cigar
I have had those rollers on a Warn fairlead for about 8 years on another vehicle with synthetic cable. I probably don't have as many pulls on it as some people here, but they have been great. They have faded over time, but I like how it sticks out further on the bumper vs. a Hawse which limits your side angles before it touches the bumper (since it's recessed in an ARB bumper or similar).