The Michelin would likely be the top choice if on-road quality and NVH are your utmost priorities. Obviously at the cost of perhaps durability, but they should be more durable than any Highway Treat (HT), P-rated tire. I would stay away from an E-rated tire though, as that will be detrimental to ride quality. Unless you're building heavy, or need the durability off-road. A good balance would be "XL" or extra load tire. Better than a P, but not a D or E-rated stiff sidewall tire either.
Some other choices in the more asphalt focused AT tires would be Nitte Terra Grappler, Bridgestone Dueler A/T Revo 2, or Goodyear SilentArmor. Note that all AT tires will get louder as they wear.