How are your MTZs in mud? I really like that tire too. I know you have liked it on rocks and in snow.
Too many damn choices.....which is nice.
Smit
MTZ's work real well in mud. We have real sticky clay mud here. Only stucks I've had in mud are not cause of the tires, but because of drag'n the axle on rutts. I have a little more than a year on them, and 17,000 miles, and they've worn really well. A little chunking, but just corners of tread, not like half a lug coming off or anything. I see them going 30,000 no problem, and probably 40,000 before they NEED to be replaced, I just figure around 30,000 on a mud tire and it stops being a mud tire any more cause the lugs aren't big enough. We'll see.
I told my friend that he wouldn't go wrong with any of the choices he was looking at. He ended up going 255/85R16 with Truxus MT's. Choices in that size are somewhat limited, but they fit on a 7" rim. I was pushing the Maxxis Bighorns for him cause they have some siping unlike the BFG MT's, and were cheap and available. Sam's off-road, our local 4by shop was jerk'n him around on the Truxus cause of the size, they wanted to charge him shipping, even though they are a distributor and have a truck coming for Louisiana every two weeks. Whole point of buying local and paying the 9% sales tax is not having to pay shipping. He found a place in Texas that gave him a good price and good price on shipping.
I think the Trepadors are way cool. The design is cool. And there is something to be said for running a tire no-one else is. My MTZ's are pretty unique around here, and I don't remember seeing another 80 on them. Wish of course they were a little taller. I think the Toyo's are taller. But I got a killer deal on mine when I bought them, my brother is still convinced it was a misprint on the price, I haven't seen them near that since.
If price is relatively the same, I'd go Trepadors just to try something no one else has, and it's not like Maxxis builds crap. Next choice would be the Toyo MT's. My brother has them and loves them, and they're a tall 315. Then MTZ's. then ProComp Extreme mud. ...... Though that new Dick Creepe Bruiser with the skulls on the side tread is kinda cool too.....
Certainly a different world than it was 5 years ago. SOOOOO many good MT choices that you can run daily on a truck without going nuts on the hwy.