Ridgid is making fast inroads on other brands market share and getting a lot of good reviews from the magazines as well. I am still skeptical of them however - mostly as a one store brand, I don't like that for many reasons. I have both the Makita which is awesome and the Dewalt with is good to excellent.
My little brother uses only Ridgid and Ryobi (same company - also Craftsman) and he is happy with them for homeowner type of stuff. I don't think they'd hold up for the constant abuse that I put them to as I take on a lot more hardcore projects that he does.
Batteries for his tools are much cheaper though although mine can be rebuilt for 32 bucks worth of sub c batteries.
The clip that is built into the Makita is just awesome. That is why I have them.
I also used to be a Dewalt sales rep so I am very biased towards all things yellow and the old Black and Decker INDUSTRIAL and Construction line - bullet proof all aluminum stuff. My brother will tell you it's all a waste of money and just get Ryobi then he goes and spends the money on silencers and full auto guns
It's all what you think is worth it. I'd recommend the Makita. It's the Land Cruiser of power tools.
-Stumbaugh