Maybe it would help to walk through my thoughts in more detail and why it is a conundrum for me. My truck is neither a trailer queen nor a mall crawler. It isn't a dedicated rock crawler or mud truck, but it sees those conditions far more often than most.
Years ago I ran a set of the original GY MTR tires in 33". They howled a bit on the highway, felt greasy at high speeds and snow traction was abysmal. But - like the older version of TSLs they had no siping and were made out of an insanely hard compound. They were awesome in deep snow and mud.
The GY Duratracs have great snow traction and are relatively quiet. They dropped my gas mileage by 10% (yes, I'm speedometer corrected to size & gearing). They're very soft compound and have been prone to mild chunking. 315 is a really wide tire - and these are 65lbs each. They rubbed a bit on the front under trail compression at moderate speeds - no issue with rubbing while crawling under full compression. From what I've been able to deduce, they rubbed because of tire width, not diameter. I have 4 of these at the end of their service life and a 7 year old spare that hasn't hit the road. With tax & mounting, 3 new ones plus bringing the old spare into use comes out to $860 or just under $290 per tire.
Now, in theory, these TSL SX2 tires supposedly have a bit softer compound than the old TSL and they're moderately well siped - which is something 'new' to the TSL line with the SX2 version. They're 2" narrower than the 315s and stand 35.2" tall - which is the skinniest 35" tire I'm finding. These are 70lbs each - so not dramatically heavier than the Duratrac 315s. With tax & mounting, 5 new ones (full set brand new) comes to $1440 or just under $290 per tire.
Complicating the picture, I live 8 hours from anywhere interesting. The end result must do 80mph on the highway for extended periods - which is a concern I have with the TSL idea from reports on the pre-SX2 version. At the end of that ride, though, are rocks, roots and depending on direction - mud. I also have to take into account the ~60 days a year of snow covered roads - I daily drive this truck in the winter. The old TSL with it's ultra-hard compounds and no siping was not something I would consider for this. The new SX2 though? I can't seem to find any solid reviews from people who actually own them in sub-37" sizes - on any vehicle.
Anything I get has to be a compromise between highway, trail, snow and mileage. Is the SX2 version of the TSL enough of a hybrid to make it workable enough outside of trail use?