So I'm two years in on the Napoleon Prestige. Hmmm.
It's definitely been a mixture of good and not-so-good.
I was coming from a Lynx grill that survived almost 20 years with a couple of rebuilds. But that's a whole different price point. And I didn't want to go there again, knowing that an offset smoker was in the cards.
I grill at least two times per week, year round. In the warm weather it's more like 4 or 5 times with lunches, etc.
Things I like about the Napoleon:
The searing burner is really great. Much better than the one on the Lynx. But the cast grate did completely rot away after about a year and a half. It had a good seasoning on it, but I just think it's going to be a consumable. Napoleon replaced it, but charges a fee for the transaction.
At first I thought the lit knobs were just a gimmick, but it's saved me from leaving the grill running at least once or twice.
The main cooking grates have held up well.
My issues:
Mostly centered around the actual cooking surface. The grill heats up kinda slowly, IMO. But it can get really hot eventually, if that's what you need. There is enough control with the knobs after a learning curve.
The front of the main cooking surface is hotter than the back.
Also, there are rows of hot spots (front to back) where two burners abut one another. Very noticeable with small items like wings or sliders. You have to keep the food in motion or you will get really uneven cooking.
The ignitors struggle in the damp and cold. I can usually get one to fire. But it's a PITA and I keep a lighter handy. I don't think they're high quality parts.
If I get five years out of the grill without any additional cost, then I think it's a winner. Anything after that is gravy. But I still have to wonder if it's worth twice the cost of a box store grill. Especially with the uneven cooking.