Finding the right winch

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

FWIW I have found (and bought over the years) good Warn winches on CL with a little patience. Never have paid over $300. 8000-9000k variants. I know there are other brands out there worth looking at. And like mentioned, a good recovery bag to go along with it.
 
Unfortunately I fall into the weekend warrior without a lot of cash. I am in love with my F80 but it is taking everything I can afford to make it into something nice. And figuring out just what is best replaced OEM and what is not as necessary. But no matter what I am having a blast!
i
 
Personally I think of a winch as any other piece of recovery gear. When you need it, it absolutely has to work and it should be well up to the task at hand.
It doesn't matter if you consider yourself a "weekend warrior" because when you need a winch, you're not going to be in your driveway, the sun won't be shining, and the birds won't be singing.
You drive a large, heavy 4WD truck. Just because you go out once in a while, that doesn't mean the truck will weigh less or you will get less stuck.
Warn M12K and don't look back. I wouldn't consider anything with less capacity or reliability. I've had mine for 18 years and has moved to its second truck. I'm on my 4th cable (2 steel and 2 synthetic), second solenoid pack, and it gets serviced regularly like everything else on my truck.
 
How many of you have read your owners manual that came with your winch?

How many of you use the winch in ACCORDANCE with that manual?

The SERVICE factor of the which states how long it can operate pulling a load, then how long it must cool before the next use.

You must also service the winch regularly. Before you go on a trip, you pull out the cable, and test the winch for operation and pull and make sure it has oil in it where and where necessary. Don't overheat the motor or solenoids.

What is your intended use? I have done 4 wheeling for 35 years and finally bought a winch because I thought it would be cool to have and it may be useful because my hitch is tied up most of the time with a wheelchair rack. Any time we got stuck, we used a different vehicle to pull it out. If we were out by ourselves, we wouldn't take stupid risks to get stuck without a backup plan.

If you're pulling logs up a hill, why are you using a winch? Why not a chain and strap hooked to the hitch? You still have to go up/down the hill on foot to attach it.

Admittedly, I'm not doing narrow mountain trails, so it's not as important for me.

It can also come down to cost. I bought a 12K Harbor Freight (Badlands) winch (about $300.) I bought one that was much heavier than my truck so it could pull something out of deep mud and so it had extra service life and not overload it. I know for a fact that it WILL drag my truck across my driveway with it in park, the parking brake set. I have used it to pull the top of a tree over to control a cut to drop a tree in sections next to a power line.

The decision is a personal one and everyone here has their own opinion. When I looked at an equivalent Warn 12K, it was more like $1800 in my area. For me, the decision was easy. Go cheap and buy two if you need a backup.
IMHO
 
If you go wheeling with friends and they have winches, I would say its really not a big deal. You could buy anything from a Badlands all the way up to top of the line.

If you are wheeling by yourself and want to tackle some hardcore stuff then maybe a winch should mean a little more to you.
 
How many of you have read your owners manual that came with your winch?

How many of you use the winch in ACCORDANCE with that manual?

The SERVICE factor of the which states how long it can operate pulling a load, then how long it must cool before the next use.
...

Yes... not really... depends on the situation on hand... :-)

On the receiver hitch-mounted winch on a cradle: The notion that kept me from going in this direction is whether you'll be able to in fact mount that winch cradle to the receiver when you're stuck... e.g. when the front is in a hole and you need to move forward?
Can't recall a need to pull myself backwards in all those years; it's always been forward - your results may vary
 
What I've found with my smitty built9.5 does a good job but is near impossible to pull out in free mode because of the China grease they pack in these things, after repacking with aeroshell22 the winch works perfectly now, have had it submerged and pulled my truck and a friends diesel 80 out of 4 plus feet of snow on straight pulls works great and I got the winch at cost so that's why I went with it. The vr by warn is just China internals with warn outers
 
I have an Engo 10000 in my shed that jammed up on me during its first season and maybe tenth pull when the set screw that penetrates the drum and is involved with the brake backed out and set the brake when I needed it badly. I replaced it with a used Warn HS9500i from 2003. That model is the second fastest they ever made (8274 fastest) and shares many parts with it successor the XD9000. This unit was basically never used but it works great and runs much quieter than the Engo. I agree with the philosophy that you should save more coin and pick up a lightly used or new Warn. I have no experience with ComeUp winches. When you need a winch, you need it to work.
 
Holy crap, does no one know how to use a hilift? Like not to side track here but damn near every actualy "backwoods stuck" situations I have been in (I have been in a lot) could be remedied with a hi lift and being creative. It helps that I literally lived in the woods and have a tendency to drive like an idiot and have to recover myself solo, usually with no winch.

Winches are not the end all tool for every scenario and a 12k is definitely not needed for every single rig hands down. I am not trying to call anyone out on that but damn 12k all the time is overkill for lots of people.


As far as skidding logs, you need a winch for that in the mountains. Hard to pull a log up a hill with a strap if your road is only 1 car width plus a few inches and its at a 90 degree angle to the road and 20 feet down.
 
As far as skidding logs, you need a winch for that in the mountains. Hard to pull a log up a hill with a strap if your road is only 1 car width plus a few inches and its at a 90 degree angle to the road and 20 feet down.

PLUS, it is an easier way to sell it to my wife on WHY I need a winch. 'How else am I going to get those up the hill??' Haha. And it looks cooler. ;-)
 
I use smittybilt these days, had warn in the past. I never travel alone and everyone I ride with has a winch. I have burned them all up too, but it's just a starter motor. you can rebuild them yourself.
 
Just a note.. pulling logs all day sounds like a very good way to exceed the duty cycle of most winches. Yes, the load will be very low compared to pulling out a truck, but it is still entirely possible to heat things up a LOT with that type of use.

IMO this increases the importance of not cheaping out on a winch. Possibly even looking at different technologies.. a hydraulic winch would have no problem with this, for instance. Even among electric winches there are different winding methods that can increase line pull speed, but IIRC they can also increase heat production.

Just some more stuff to consider..
 
After 21 years I find it very easy to justify the higher cost of a WARN.
100% Trouble free for 21years
The confidence it will work when needed
Est cost 21 years ago ~$800
21/$800=$38/year
365/$38=$.10/day
Looks pretty cheap given what you get

I did upgrade to synthetic line but it was free coming from another truck I bought.
 
As far as skidding logs, you need a winch for that in the mountains. Hard to pull a log up a hill with a strap if your road is only 1 car width plus a few inches and its at a 90 degree angle to the road and 20 feet down.

A winch would be way down on my list for skidding logs. A better and faster method would be a cable attached to a recovery point on your vehicle in combination with a snatch block secured higher up in a tree. The log will have less chance of digging in with the higher angle of the pull. Lots of advantages of angles and speed.
 
Back
Top Bottom