Finding the right winch

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
May 7, 2016
Threads
176
Messages
939
Location
Decatur GA
I have been looking around at all the different winches and wondering what the differences are in price, performance etc. I have already asked about something like this earlier but now I have even more questions. If I were not on a budget, of course the 8274 would be on the top of my list. Otherwise, I cannot see being happy with anything other than a Warn. Other suggestions have been ComeUp which I could appreciate. I keep coming back to the VR8000 by Warn but it is so inexpensive, I have to ask why? Is it made by another company and stamped by Warn, therefore is there another winch out there that is the same thing with a different name? What makes a good winch? When typical failures occur, what are the reasons? And I should preface by saying I am not someone who will be doing some super rock crawling. But I would like to take some decent long adventures and if necessary, get myself out of a quick pinch that I simply cannot drive out of. Since I am not using it enough, I am willing to stay with a steel cable for cost reasons no matter how much I want the synthetic. Waterproof seems important as hell to me and a wireless remote would be a plus. I think I have been talked out of Smittybuilt, only because of one members very bad experience with it. Any info would be appreciated.
 
What makes the best winch, one that works when you need it. My WARN M8000 is 21 years old this month, been on the front and back of several vehicles, and never an issue. Been under water many times, subject to pressure washed over 100 times and get used very little, mostly by others:flipoff2: Buy a good one and it will last you and work when you need it.


rsz_1rsz_img_7554[1].webp
 
From what I understand the warn VR series are their old versions so they dropped the price when the brought out the new line. Some people will say that the 8000 is too light but I have an extra cable set up for long reaches and 2 snatch blocks if needed. I'm running the Warn XD9000 because I got a good deal on it used.
 
Wow, you found a used winch?? So far that has been impossible. But that is great information. I am looking forward to the 8000. Especially for the price.
 
The Warn VR series are essentially "entry level" Warns that are not using their latest tech, materials or construction. I could be wrong, but that's what I was told when I was looking at them.
I've become a real fan of the COMEUP winches. I have the SEAL Gen2 9.5rs on my 80 and it's been fantastic. Quality is better IMO than the Warn VRs and specs are better than a comparable Warn. Excellent IP (waterproof) rating, faster line speed but still with excellent power, synthetic line standard on the Gen2, wireless remote (wired also), and good pricing for a premium winch.
When I was shopping I looked at lots of different options. Fortunately there were a number of people I knew that were running COMEUPs so I could get feedback and do a bit of comparison.
100% happy with my choice to go with COMEUP and I think you would be too if that's what you choose.

As you said, protection from water/moisture is key. Water getting into the motor or contactors is what kills winches. ComeUp is as good as anything on the market for protection from water damage.
 
I used a smittybuilt xrc8k and it preformed well when I had it. You just cannot expect it to preform like a top of the line winch. Its slower and not as sturdy compared to a warn but they work for weekend warrior type deals.

Now i run an 8274, prior I used a 6.5k winch on a loaded FJ60. You really dont need a high load winch if you are smart about how you pull and let them cool off when getting hot

Good luck, i would spend the coin on a Warn if possible but dont discount the smittybuilt imo
 
I like having the big boy M12000. It may be slow and loud but there is never a doubt it wont get you out. I saw in the latest 4wheel parts magazine that there is a new gen of Warn VR series winches coming out. Might be worth looking into. Lots of good choices out there.
 
I used a smittybuilt xrc8k and it preformed well when I had it. You just cannot expect it to preform like a top of the line winch. Its slower and not as sturdy compared to a warn but they work for weekend warrior type deals.

Now i run an 8274, prior I used a 6.5k winch on a loaded FJ60. You really dont need a high load winch if you are smart about how you pull and let them cool off when getting hot

Good luck, i would spend the coin on a Warn if possible but dont discount the smittybuilt imo

Quick note, it was a Warn 6.5k winch. Smittybuilt 8k.
 
Think about how you will actually use the winch when stuck. Many situations I have seen require the stuck rig to be moved to the rear, so front hard mounted winch is not a solution. You may want to consider a cradle mounted or portable unit that can be mounted to either end. A smaller portable setup with a snatch block to double the power may better fit your application.
 
Any of the China built (mile marker, smittybuilt, bulldog, warrior, superwinch, etc, etc) are DECENT winches for the $$$. I have had great luck with a Harbor Freight 12000# $275 winch. However, with that being said, I have also stood in mud over my waist re-wiring a fried solenoid on my Mile Marker winch the 1ST time I used it!!!! (That sucked ass!)
Soooooo..... the thing I learned is- it's better to save your coins for an extra month, if need be, and buy a WARN OR COMEUP! Anything else and sooner or later your going to get burned.(and hopefully nobody gets hurt!) Good luck!
 
Think about how you will actually use the winch when stuck. Many situations I have seen require the stuck rig to be moved to the rear, so front hard mounted winch is not a solution. You may want to consider a cradle mounted or portable unit that can be mounted to either end. A smaller portable setup with a snatch block to double the power may better fit your application.

That makes a lot of sense. I hadn't really thought about it but for what I do I really just need a winch mounted to a receiver hitch....for now. I just need a way to drag logs up a hill until I can get a new bumper.
 
That makes a lot of sense. I hadn't really thought about it but for what I do I really just need a winch mounted to a receiver hitch....for now. I just need a way to drag logs up a hill until I can get a new bumper.

Cradle mounted winches are awesome. Its some coin to run 0 gauge wire all the way down the frame with quick connects so another thing to think about. If you are skidding logs throw down on a solid heavy duty winch.
 
Cradle mounted winches are awesome. Its some coin to run 0 gauge wire all the way down the frame with quick connects so another thing to think about. If you are skidding logs throw down on a solid heavy duty winch.

Not really large logs...maybe 6 feet long and 8-12" at the most...but later on I can use it for other LC stuff. I hadn't thought about the wire....thanks for bringing that up!
 
Not really large logs...maybe 6 feet long and 8-12" at the most...but later on I can use it for other LC stuff. I hadn't thought about the wire....thanks for bringing that up!

Yeah, 0 gauge isnt cheap but its not too pricey either, connects will run you fron $20- $40 per set.

When you said skidding I assumed it was large stuff haha i have daisy chained a 135 footer with an f350 so my caliber of skidding is a bit different haha
 
I'm the 'weekend warrior' type who might use a winch occasionally. I settled on a 10K Smittybilt with synthetic line since I thought I could justify that $ amount and not much more.

If I was a hardcore wheeler who might have an option to use my winch say every other weekend, I'd find myself a Warn.

Regards....
 
I'm the 'weekend warrior' type who might use a winch occasionally. I settled on a 10K Smittybilt with synthetic line since I thought I could justify that $ amount and not much more.

If I was a hardcore wheeler who might have an option to use my winch say every other weekend, I'd find myself a Warn.

Regards....


Your response is probably the smartest, well thought out response. Everyone (including me) love to spend other people's money, so we all say Warn, COMEUP, blah, blah. If you only use it 2-3 times a year, why break the bank? So you can tell everyone you have a Warn?Buy what you need, and for 80% of the people on this site, a china winch is fine! Enjoy!
 
Perfect ideas. I have a lot to think about. But I am re thinking some of the hard set decisions I had made. Thanks for all the help.
 
IMO weekend warrior or hardcore rockcrawler, the priority with a winch should be reliability. I don't ever want to wonder if the winch is going to work when I need it. That's a concern with some of the cheaper winches. Sitting too long can actually be a bad thing especially if they are not sealed as well as they should be.
Spend the money you need to to get one that you know will be reliable.
 
IMO weekend warrior or hardcore rockcrawler, the priority with a winch should be reliability. I don't ever want to wonder if the winch is going to work when I need it. That's a concern with some of the cheaper winches. Sitting too long can actually be a bad thing especially if they are not sealed as well as they should be.
Spend the money you need to to get one that you know will be reliable.

Couldn't agree more Adam.....however, some 'weekend warriors' have a little more disposable $ than others. It's all about what you can justify.....
 
Back
Top Bottom