Expert Engine Help Needed

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

David70FJ40

Older Than Most
Joined
Oct 9, 2014
Threads
172
Messages
2,531
Location
High Point, NC
I picked up my 40 from the body shop Friday and as soon as I left the lot the engine started to sputter and was way down on power. I nursed it back home and started to look into what might be wrong.

I changed the plugs, wires, coil and nothing helped. The distributor cap and rotor look good and it has an electronic pickup instead of points so I assume that is okay. My next door neighbor is a certified mechanic and he guessed it might be the cam.

If it is a cam I found that Man-A-Fre/BTB Products has one available for the F and another for the 2F. Cost is $759 including core.

So when it starts it putt-putts and it just doesn't have any power.

Any guesses. Opinions welcomed!
 
You absolutely sure it’s not fuel delivery issues... pump,filter, carb, crap in tank/lines?
 
It is burning rich.
 
It’s unlikely it’s the cam all of the sudden, but if it is, melting makes a replacement for under $200 the last time I checked. How did he come up with the cam diagnosis? That’s not something you just “guess” at.

If it’s running rich it could just be a bad or sticky float or needle valve causing fuel to overflow into the intake. Or maybe you’re not getting adequate ignition. Could be a lot of things
 
Last edited:
Get a vac gauge and hook it up to the intake manifold. See what it shows. Good vac reading should say 18-21 inches. If vac is good then likely other issues. There are charts online about diagnosing issues using vac readings.
 
The carb is the next thing to look at.
 
Cams don't just go bad. You have a fuel issue of some kind. Maybe something got into your tank at the shop.

Your certified neighbor mechanic doesn't sound too certified to me.
 
My next door neighbor is a certified mechanic and he guessed it might be the cam.

That an interesting thing for a Certified Mechanic to guess at ... did he do any inspection ? Compression Test ? Pull anything off ?

As others have said if it was "At the body shop" they are not a real clean environment and I would be looking at fuel supply before ordering an $800 cam
 
Vacuum leak David... do you know what your vacuum was and what it is now?

Edit:

It’s curious this occurred while your 40 was out of your hands .., I’d see if someone pulled a vacuum line off, or restricted exhaust flow.


My largest vacuum leak was from the dissy vacuum module. It got bad enough that 44 could barely move at 6k’ altitude.

Of course, you could also have bad gas, fouled carb and/or filter.

But, I’d first try to fine where someone was screwing with it.
 
Last edited:
The cam thing was us brainstorming on the phone. He has worked on my 40 before and I trust his judgement. I will pull the carb tomorrow and look it over before doing anything else. I can say it is running rich.
 
Stock F engine with a Holley 350 cfm carb.
 
Timing could be retarded. Not sure about the certified mech either.
Rich could be a stuck float. Do you smell gas and is there signs of gas leaking around the carb?
Had a float that absorbed the gasoline making it "not float".
Consequently the float needle would not close causing the engine to flood and loss of power.
A cam does not go bad all at once unless something breaks and then the engine usually doesn't run at all.
Keep your wallet in your pocket until you have exhausted all other possibilities.
 
I would think that checking the valve adjustment would quickly rule the cam being bad as 'in' or 'out' - and checking the valves is always a good idea anyway, as part of a general diagnosis and troubleshooting.
 
You've gotten a lot of good suggestions that you should pursue before spending a lot of time and money guessing what's wrong. Do you have the stock mechanical fuel pump? Also, depending on how long it's been sitting, you might want to have a peek to make sure mice haven't knitted a giant sweater in your intake housing.
 
My unexpert skills point toward fuel delivery. If it has a strong gasoline smell the float needle and seat is probably gummed up and flooding the engine out. Pull the float bowl on that Holley and inspect for green ethanol gunk around the float mechanism and jets.
If that is the case pull your oil dipstick and check for gasoline in the oil. Running diluted oil will ultimately cause bearing failure. Your neighbors cam evaluation will be accurate at that time.
This is a growing issue with carburated engine small and large with ethanol gas.
 
Back
Top Bottom