Dog Opinion Needed!

Family Dog (Pics Welcome!)

  • Lab

    Votes: 34 35.4%
  • Golden Retriever

    Votes: 9 9.4%
  • Chesapeake Bay Retriever

    Votes: 6 6.3%
  • None of the above, my choice is below

    Votes: 47 49.0%

  • Total voters
    96

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

After owning a Boxer I could never have anything else. She was the best dog I ever seen. Beautiful and full of energy, outstanding with children. I left her out in the front yard to get some coffee. When I was on my way back out I heard her yelping. The kid next door had come over and was biting my dogs leg. The little bastard had blood running out of his mouth, all my girl did was yelp and try to pull away. They are are also good watch dogs, very protective of the house at night. But mostly they are just another member of the family.
 
I vote either a Brittany spaniel or Weimerainer...both are awesome dogs... and about the same temperment...both are really hyper...the Brittany is easy to train and a great bird dog..the Weimerainer is a great bird dog but can be hard headed sometimes.... Weimerainers are big though...mine is 115lbs.
 
From the dogs you listed I would like to add another option. Think about a "Flatcoated Retriever" Its a pedigree breed that is used primarily as a hunting dog and makes a great family dog. Imagine a black golden retriever with the spunk of a lab. Our dog bristo is an awesome family dog (lets the 10mo crawl all over him) his loves to frisbee, the water and hiking with us. Full grown about 70lbs. There are not many breeders in the US but check out rockyhillkennels.com that is where we got our dog and the breeder is amazingly devoted to the breed. Aint cheep....pup will cost you 800-1000. In my opinion in the ranks of family dogs the flat coat is the cruiser....everyone else has a golden or lab.

%90 of the dog you have will be in the training and socialization that you give it but with bad blood that %10 can become a very serious PITA or liability depending on the breed. Good luck picking a dog. By the way consider a standard poodle with a butch cut...super smart dogs and great pets if you can get over the poodle aspect. They shed a lot less too.
 
My vote is for the rescue as well. it differs from the pound as with at least the rescue we got our to mutts from, in that they are already staying at someones house. You get a kind of report card from the "foster parent" They will let you know if the dog is good with kids. Crate trained. hous broke. etc. also they are up on their shots, meds, and are fixed.

We have two of the best dogs I could have ever asked for. Ones a terrier / lab something, and the other is a border collie / sheltie something.

Will see if the photos work.

your doing the right thing by asking at least people who know something, not seeing a dog on TV and going to get one. Ever wonder how many dalmations ended up at the pound after Disney relased the movie.
 
Thanks

Great info from all, good discussion, and have given me some good food for thought. Will post up pics in the spring. (or come back with more specific questions :) Clearly, the human breed of landcruiser owners has much more to offer this world than the average bear. :cheers:
 
Mutts are great. They don't have recessive health problems, and you can get them from the pound. That being said, it's nice to know what to expect from a dog, which is why breed characteristics are helpful. I think goldens are the best breed for children, but they're prone to several diseases. How about a golden mix?

I have a shepherd/collie/cocker/afgan mix. (actually no one can tell what she is, but seems about 1/2 german shepherd) She came from a prison rescue program where they take pound puppies to prisons for intensive obedience training, housebreaking, and temperment analysis.

http://www.petfinder.com/shelters/OH211.html

or closer to you:

http://www.wesavepets.org/pages/6/

Looks like they have a lab or two.

Lab Puppies are cute... untill they eat your leather stearing wheel while you run in for coffee.
 
Last edited:
will, my dad has a staffie, my sister has two and we live way up in the freakin north! (besides the alaska guys on here )they are great family dogs, that being said, I have two great danes and couldn't be happier, they are pushovers, but I would have to agree the way to go is to the pound, if my doggies didn't sorta fall into place i would have gladly searched out a good pound mutt.
 
one more vote for the aussie shepherd border collie mixes.
We got my dog from an aussie rescue group in southern Utah 2.5 years ago. she is great. With 4 year old boys I would not recommedn a large dog. get on ethat they will still be bigger than. otherwise you have issues with the two people who spend the most time with the dog (ie your boys) having no respect from the dog.
My son is 6 now and loves his dog to death. loves playing fetch and absolutely amazing with a frisbee. will grab it 6-7 feet in the air at a full run. I never get tired of that.

there is one aussie and BC trait that you will need to be aware of though. They are herd dogs. SO if you have two boys playing tag in the yard the dog will run and GENTLY nip at th seat of their pants and make them head for the middle of the yard. this can scare a lot of kids so be careful. with whatever you decide find out as much as you can about whatever breed you decide and go for it.
Dave
oh and here is shot of the fam.
pyker.webp
 
We have a great dane (great pain) LOL

Her name is Emma, and she s 2 years old. She s a little over 3' at the shoulder, about 120 pounds...

Very active, loves to run and terrorize anything that moves, hates bicycles, baby strollers and lawn mowers.... ABSOLUTELY loves car rides, especially in the land cruiser (its the only vehicle we own that she can stand up in!)

She does not like children-- however, this is not characteristic of the breed. Typically danes are great with kids, however emma is a rescue dane from an abusive household, and we believe it was a child who hit her and abused her as a puppy.

Aggression is a difficult issue, and u get lots of answers... a good rule of thumb-- fawns are the most mellow, halequins are the most aggressive. Oddly, males seem to be better with children than the females....

as far as security goes, nobody comes within about 100 yards of our house. A dog like this, the size speaks volumes, even though she is sweet as molasses and u would literally have to be killing one of us for her to bite u. People literally see u coming and clear the path.... Like having the SUV of dogs.... they make great city dogs, despite their size.. they can run in a small urban yard like ours.... they do get on furniture, as they sit on anything that s at their butt level which pretty much means anything that s at ur butt level. they will rest their butt on the sofa and have front legs on the floor all day long. (While watching TV nonetheless) Emma loves accordian music. Eating off the table or counter is an issue, as the top of most tables are below eye level....

Downsides: have a good food budget-- plan it like u had another person in the house to feed... i d say plan to spend about $2-3 a day once they are adults.... They need lots of toys, and we have yet to find anything this dog cannot destroy within hours. The giant rawhide bones last about 15 minutes....

One thing about danes that many people will tell u is that they do not live long. This is true in many cases when compared to other dog breeds. It is not uncommon for a dog to live only 8 -10 years. However, the more exercise u give the dog, and proper high qulaity diet, and they are known to live up to 14 or 15 years.... For emma, we give her small amounts of dry and canned food, but the bulk of her food is a mixture of cheap ground beef (like the 30% fat stuff that comes in the big plastic tubes at the supermarket) supplemented with other meats, as well as fresh garlic, *ground* veggies like red cabbage, and some olive oil. Organ meat once a week will keep ur dane in top condition. This may sound expensive, but for a dog of this size, we find home made natural food to be only *slightly* more expensive (pennies a day) compared to a higher quality canned/dry mix. Lot of exercise is great too. Even though our emma is an urban dog, we do run and walk her lots and she loves hiking and camping.... and twice a month we load her up in the cruiser and take her to our friends farm when she runs miles and miles and miles and ......

They are very intelligent-- sometimes too intelligent for their own good. I dont reccommend a dane for person who is not strong willed and willing to show their dominance over the dog every day. Their size deceives them and makes them think they are ur equal, or worse, ur superior. U need to make ur dominance known from the start or u will get walked on-figuratively and literally! These dogs have narcissistic tendencies and are legends in their own minds... If u ask emma, she would tell u she owns the house, all of the cars, everything in them, and would insist she is on the title deeds for them all, and she is nice enough to let us sleep here and borrow her cars. It s only by keeping strict rules that we let her know she s not in charge.

Danes are not for everyone, but if u have one, and if they are right for u, u will never want another dog. And yeah, it is great to walk down the street and have people clear the sidewalk and give u a large berth.... and when we had a spate of break ins in our neighborhood, our house was avoided all together. Emma makes her presence known to anyone, she s hard to miss, and lets face it, they can look downright mean when they want, but for the most part they are 120 lb lap dogs. LOL



TR-AmGothic-G-Dane-fawn.jpg
 
-7 outside this morning at 7am....

Stupid Chessie is laying on the deck in the open....not even curled up...waiting for me to leave and say good by (later than usual for me....so he's waiting...)

Love that dog....gonna be hard when he finally goes...but he's over 13 and won't be around forever....
 
more good info! you guys are great, thanks. sometimes I feel like I need a herding dog with those two boys. Woody, friggin -12 before wind chill here. wife last night - "i couldn't get the window up". I go no sweat, common in this rig in the cold. I'll refurb the tracks this spring. I love this group. Thanks all for the input on the pup. :cheers:
 
Whatever you do, don't get a boxer. We have two pairs in the neighborhood, and they are aggressive, stupid dogs. One actually bit me this morning--didn't break skin, more of a nip, but I was tempted to give it an ass-kicking because IT approached ME and nipped me. Bitch. :rolleyes: I'll be talking to the owner tonight.

Yeah, "they can be good dogs," or "how they're raised determines this," yadda yadda. Whatever. Probably didn't help that the owner put those stupid coats on them. ;p Just wanted to rant. :D



















Stupid dogs. :flipoff2:
 
Now theres 2 votes for Weimerainers....lol....nice looking dog MJM....mine is the best dog I have ever had
 
One more Plug for the Weimarainer

Mooker I would agree my Weim is the best dog ever. Not as big as yours she is only 65lbs at 3 years old. You have to love a dog that sleeps in a Hamock on Lazy Sunday afternoons and for those who are wondering that is Lake Erie in the background.
I will say that Weims are not for everyone they do a lot of spunk.
MJM
 
Just getting down to where he likes it.

woody said:
-7 outside this morning at 7am....

Stupid Chessie is laying on the deck in the open....not even curled up...waiting for me to leave and say good by (later than usual for me....so he's waiting...)

Love that dog....gonna be hard when he finally goes...but he's over 13 and won't be around forever....



Hope your Chessie hangs in there for a few more quality years.

My Lab will not go into his dog house unless it is pouring rain or the wind is blowing 40 mph. I often find him sound asleep with frost built up from behind his ears to about the middle of his back on cold mornings.

It just shows you how well insulated they are.

In my opinion Chessies are hardier in the water than most labs but they can be tougher to train because of it. Some Chessie's will swim around bitting at the water and just playing for 1/2 an hour before coming back in.

Alot of people mistake a Chessie for a Chocolate Lab and vice-versa but they are really quite different if you know what to look for.

Glad to see so many on this forum are dog lovers and take good care of them.
 
I LOVE PITS,,, had am argentine DOGO dd113 used to sleep with,,,,,,, my gf and I have 5 mutts and a few pure breds,,, want a Malinois, or a dutch shepard,,, think a good dog is an Irish wolf hound, bassets are GREAT options,,,!!! really, not too houndy, but really fun, and great chick magnets whe the wife is not around,, trust me on this!!!!!!
 
Wow... Lots of opinions on this topic!

I've got a Rescued EX-racing greyhound. One of the most low maintaince animals ever. People tend to think they they are high strung, but the contrary is true. With very little body fat they have no place to store energy. He typically spends 90% of his time laying down or asleep. I would say they need less exercise than the average dog.

Greyhounds were bred to be strong and fast. In turn they do not suffer from ailments that other large dogs do ie hip displacia etc. Their teeth do need more attention for some reason though.

You cannot get a puppy, but that was a plus for me. I did not feel that I had the patience to raise a puppy. Greys are retired between 1.5 and 5 years, whenever they stop winning.

They are not an outdoor dog however. We have 2 jackets for him. One is a fleece sweater for the fall/spring, and one is a serious parka. They have very little fur, and they do not have a lot of the oils in their skin like other dogs do. The absence of these oils make them great for people with allergies as well. This was important when we were looking at dogs due to my wifes allergies. She has never had a problem with him in the house. They also do not shed very much at all. In fact, they tend to clean themselves like a cat. Another benifit of the absence of these oils are that they do not have the typical "dog" smell, and they only need to be bathed a few times a year.

I've done a bunch of volunteer work for the local greyhound organization here in the cities. One good resource for you would be to go to one of the pet shows held at the Mpls convention center, or rivercenter. Lots of good info.

So anyway, that's my suggestion
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom