9000 miles with conventional oil? Rotella is decent oil, but 9000 is way too much. You're outrunning the additive package - the buildup and the failure after to prevent loss at ~ 4000 miles . At best, conventional oil will last 5000 miles. The only other way to fix that, and this is direct...
Pennzoil? whatever oil you're using is pretty crap with that kind of buildup... to be honest, I'll never understand why people use cheap oil - it's a false economy and probably the cause of your issues now...
What weight oil are you running? are you certain the oil is going out the exhaust...