What Size Come-Along

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Well this advice is too late for the OP, but I'll offer it up for others who are interested in come-alongs. As stated above, the Hi-Lift is a versatile tool, but you only get a few feet of pull before you have to reset your rigging. A quality come-along is the Maasdam Pow'r Puller. They have a 4 ton model for $190. Like the Wyeth Scott (thread #10), it is in a different league than other come-alongs. It has 12' of cable at the 3 ton configuration and 6' at the 4 ton configuration.

http://www.amazon.com/Maasdam-8000SB-C-3-Ton-4-Ton-Puller/dp/B000PWGRT6 (pictured below)

I would avoid cheap come-alongs. They are more likely to fail when you need them most, and can be dangerous if the break.

If you're going to buy a come along spend the money on a quality unit such as the one above or the More Power Puller (http://cspoutdoors.com/morpowpul.html).

I dumped the cheap come alongs years ago for the Power Puller and have been quite pleased. A thread about the hand winch and additional options to the More Power Puller https://forum.ih8mud.com/winching-recovery/76336-more-power-puller.html.
 
The hi lift is a great, versatile tool, but I'd hate for it to be my primary pulling device. I'd use it for that purpose only as a last resort. For pulling type self recovery, the good hand winches mentioned above are much better for the job.
 
If you're going to buy a come along spend the money on a quality unit such as the one above or the More Power Puller (http://cspoutdoors.com/morpowpul.html).

I dumped the cheap come alongs years ago for the Power Puller and have been quite pleased. A thread about the hand winch and additional options to the More Power Puller https://forum.ih8mud.com/winching-recovery/76336-more-power-puller.html.

I have used one of these before. It is in the same league as a hi-lift. They will work in a pinch, but neither are a replacement for a power winch. The plus is the hi-lift has more uses. The come-a-long is easier.

IMO look around for a used winch before you spend another $200 on a come-a-long. I found a steal on Craigslist a couple weeks ago. There have been several m8000s in the $300-400 range.

Be safe.
 
It looks like I get 2 chain,in the kit and have a long snach strap....

The two chains are used with a long piece of chain to do the winching. One attaches to the bar of the jack and the other attaches to the lifting foot. the strap is a tree strap.


The tree strap goes around the anchor point (usually a tree) and attaches to the top of the jack. The long piece of chain attaches to the vehicle and to the hook at the end of the chain attached to the lifting foot.

You then run the jack up all the way, set the hook on the other chain attached to the base of the jack to keep from losing progress, reset the jack and start again.


Like I said, practice before you go and you will know you have everything you need.
 
Go with the genuine Hi-Lift brand jack if you have the time to make a choice. They're the only ones made in the USA (Bloomfield, IN, one of my old hometowns). I have an off-brand imported jack, which works but I just don't trust it like a Hi-Lift.

On the other hand, these jacks can be pretty dangerous, even in the right hands. You've been warned to be cautious. Using them for a winch is tedious, but a little less dangerous. I will note that unless you have straight bumpers like on a FJ40 or FJ55, you'll have a hard time getting a hookup point to use it as a jack. They do make adapters to deal with this, so something to consider. Often you get stuck where there's no nearby anchor to use it as a come-along, so you need to lift and stack rocks, etc underneath to get unstuck, so think about it before you need it.

I keep a good heavy-duty come-along in the truck. Doesn't need to be the fancy stuff if it's not your primary recovery gear IMO, because they're all designed to have the handle fail by bending if overloaded. This is intentional, but some folks take it as a weakness. Better a soft failure, than a sudden one is the idea.

With a winch, it's a last ditch method for that sort of thing for me. I have had cases when doing recoveries where I needed to tie off the vehicle on the uphill side to prevent rollover or body damage when pulling from another direction to get unstuck. Basically, use the come-along to tie it off, then you can take up slack carefully as the stuck vehicle moves.

Around camp, handy to hang a carcass if you a hunter. Normally, you don't want to use them overhead, but if you have a good skyhook, they're all adequate with a little care to pick up most everything you could bag in North America. Sure wish I hadn't left mine at home the last time dad and I got a roadkill deer on the highway down home...:doh:
 
I've used something similar to this:
http://www.harborfreight.com/manual-strap-winch-95541.html

The great thing is that's its really versatile. I had a 3/4" rope around 10 feet long that can go around the lip of the puller and then anywhere you want to tie too. (a tree/another buddies bumper ect...)
A great addition to the others mentioned here.
It's not super heavy rated, but in a pinch where you need just a little help, it works great.

WP
 
I've used something similar to this:
http://www.harborfreight.com/manual-strap-winch-95541.html

The great thing is that's its really versatile. I had a 3/4" rope around 10 feet long that can go around the lip of the puller and then anywhere you want to tie too. (a tree/another buddies bumper ect...)
A great addition to the others mentioned here.
It's not super heavy rated, but in a pinch where you need just a little help, it works great.

WP

Woo...that isn't rated very high...

I did order this as a back up, but don't plan on needing it.

http://www.harborfreight.com/automotive-motorcycle/winches/8000-lb-cable-winch-puller-69855.html

Be safe with that 1200lbs rating....I would be too scared to use that.
 
Good advice here! I too recommend having a Hi-Lift as well as a comealong. I am a fan of AND. Why have a beer or tea if you can have both? In my experience if you don't have the comealong you will need it, but if you have it you won't :) My Hi-Lift has rescued me multiple times, and lots of other folks. The ability to move a few tons of truck even only a foot or two is often all that is needed.

I have a winch now and I still bring everything with me on the trail. I also believe in keeping my gear secured from the weather, I just bungee an old spare tire cover on my Hi-Lift mechanism. I have seen folks have stiction problems with Hi-Lifts that sit in the weather all the time.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom