LOL after all of this i might just keep my BFG KOs for another season as long as they will balance out OK. The have a ton of tread left after about 40-45,000 miles but do have a vibration at 60mph. Besides, i just finished a cylinder head rebuild that basically killed my budget for a while. We will see.
But i really appreciate this thread. I think the tire choice is really affected by WHERE you wheel and i think this thread has a lot of good info. I spend a lot of time in Georgia in the winters. Down here the mud is different than out west. It is a clay based soil that is just like "clay". Even in the woods wheeling a MT is what really does well. Mud, tree roots, wet leaves and loose rocks. OUt around Moab or in the southeast I would GUESS that the have a lot more large rock that needs traction. But that is a guess since i have only been down there a few times.
The point is i am trying to find a tire that will do all three of these areas form. I am living in WY May-Oct so lots of summer trail time out there. Then I am in GA Nov-April which has some good winter trails, wet and muddy. In between those two look forward to making more trips down to Moab area.
To sum it up. When i do replace what i have i am really considering the Cooper ST Maxx (thanks to you guys) and my original top choise of Toyo MT Open Country.