Radiator Replacement - wait for OEM or purchase aftermarket today???

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 15, 2011
Threads
19
Messages
119
Hey Guys,

New Year's Eve, I notice a small hairline crack on the top of my 1999 LX470's radiator. It's was very small and was only weeping about a 1/2" spot on the top of the radiator after driving all day. So, after checking prices for OEM radiators, I decided to order an OEM replacement from an out of state Lexus dealership. Price was fair at $344 and I felt safe driving with such a small leak. However, yesterday morning I found a large puddle of coolant on the garage floor. After further investigation, it appears the lower tank is now leaking. Not sure if the lower tank is cracked or the lower seal has failed, but this leak is much larger and needs to be repaired before driving. Here's my dilemma; last Thursday I ordered an OEM radiator, both hoses, thermostat and I new fan clutch. I spoke to the dealer on Saturday. They don't expect to deliver the parts to me for 7-10 days. That doesn't work for me, so my options are to purchase the radiator from a local Lexus dealer ($475 plus tax, next day delivery) or purchase an aftermarket radiator locally. I found a Denso brand locally for $320. There is also a NAPA brand available for $350, but I have to wait 3-5 days. There are some other aftermarket brands available, but I didn't recognize any of their names and they are not "in stock". I can purchase the same Denso radiator online for $168 with free shipping and no tax, which is a lower cost option...always a good thing.

So, my question is; does anyone have any experience with the Denso radiator or any other aftermarket radiator brands? If so, do they recommend them or recommend I spend the extra money on OEM?

Also, I wasn't too concerned about the thermostat when I was ordering it from the dealership. But, if I purchase an aftermarket thermostat, which temperature; 170 or 180 should I purchase and which brand? NAPA, Stant and Gates are look similar and are available in both 170 and 180 degree. Kuzeh and NTC, appear to be a totally different design...and cost a little more. That could be a good thing or bad thing???

Thanks again for all your help.

Tom
 
I got the TYC brand on Amazon for all of my Lexi. They are actually KOYO radiators. They have been great. The one for my LX470 was like $140.
 
I wouldn't get in too much of a tizzy debating whether to get an OEM radiator or not. If you keep your cruiser long enough Toyota will discontinue it anyway...& aftermarket will be the only game in town.

All the 60 and earlier guys are replacing their radiators with aftermarket jobs, as OEM is NLA.
When it comes to radiators, you generally get what you pay for.

Toyota replacement radiators are not made like they used to be anyway. I have a friend who had to return two new ones due to leaks.

Don't be installing an aftermarket thermostat though. Get the Toyota part.
 
Hey Guys, Thanks for the quick response. I decided to order the TYC radiator from Amazon. With your recommendation and the reviews on Amazon, it looks like a good value. Hopefully they will package it well to avoid any shipping damage. I found an OEM thermostat on Amazon as well. Thanks again!!!
 
Here's my opinion after a completed radiator replacement. THE TYC RADIATOR IS JUNK!!! Go with Denso. It's about $30 more on Amazon, but a perfect match of the OEM. The TYC was nothing but problems from the beginning. I should have stopped the install right when I had a fit problem with the mounting brackets. But I pushed forward with a little grinding. Then the funky transmission pre warmer connections that are too long and poorly designed, should have stopped then...but again I pushed forward with a work around. Last part to install was the radiator overflow tank. No way it will fit. Either the mounting tab on the radiator is too low or the fan shroud mounting points are way off. As the shroud has alignment pins, it must be the radiator. Out it came, back to Amazon, less shipping. The good news, the extra practice improved my radiator swap speed record. Unfortunately, I'm getting old and may not be able to perform at the same high level in 15 years when it's time to replace it again :o
 
Back
Top Bottom