giving scott the benefit of the doubt...
I was at first shocked at the cold ratings of
some of the gear that the winter arctic expedition brought. I am from the colder climates (49 degrees north born in Chewelah, WA and it gets a lot colder in the arctic than where I am from)
Then I started thinking about where these guys are from, the desert. It seems to me that they made the same sort of assumptions / mistakes about arctic travel that I would make about desert travel. It certainly is hard to trust to others' advice on what to bring. I would just say to be more critical of the advice and plan for worst case scenario, if you will be travelling solo especially, as your life literally depends on it.
Someone made a good point earlier that gear is usually overrated by the manufacturers. It is important to 'over pack', and come prepared for the worst, that way you know that no matter what you will sleep warm.
I have to commend their courage for braving those cold nights in naught but a safari tent. I might have brought something with better insulation, but I have slept in a tent in the snow before, and I tell you what: next time I'll make a snow cave instead and stay warm and snug! (if snow conditions allow, or I'llj ust get the cold weather insulation for my Hennesy hammock tent)
I use a North Face snowshoe bag(my second actually , 0 degrees farenheit rated), slept in up to -10 degrees farenheit and was very warm. A few years later my bag was cold at 32 degrees, as it lost it's effectiveness with age, and having been compressed too long on a couple of trips. My new snowshoe bag is just as warm as the first. I would never have thought it would keep me warm anywhere near -50, though (I probably would have gone for the north face 'Darkstar(?)' which I believe is rated to -50 farenheit, or another comparably rated bag....)
Having said that, I don't know how many of you have tried to pack a bag like that around... they are mammoth, and take up some serious real estate in a cramped cabin.
The boots are a tough choice, don't know what I would have done there. I have worn Sorels forever, but again I have never been in these kind of extreme low temps. I know that for me having a pair of boots large enough to wear with extra socks ( i suggest blends of silk/wool, or polypro type for warmth)... I find that a boot that is too tight will constrict bloodflow and won't allow for the extra socks that I need to keep warm.
I appreciated the tips you guys shared about winter travel that you got from the locals, such as staying bundled up in the cab, with cooler cabin temps, and having a dry bag for safety, etc.
I also felt like you were very well prepared in the vehicle department, I would like to think my 83 landcruiser fj60 would be able to do the same, but I would need to sink a lot of cash into old 'Savage Henry' first...
Anyways, much ado about nothing, you all came home safe, have all your toes and fingers, and you were transparent about your mistakes. Maybe if you take the antartctic trip you will be more prepared...
