Old Stage Rd 1, Battery 0

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jul 1, 2005
Threads
75
Messages
1,343
Location
CO Springs
I know why Luke hates Old Stage Road.... :mad:

The family had a trip planned to do some easy trails today, with a run through Mt Baldy and then on through Cripple Creek to make the Shelf Road/Phantom Canyon loop. We had the cooler packed and everyone was excited.

We went up Old Stage Rd and the first few miles were as smooth as glass. It abruptly turned to washboards and we spent a few miles rattling our teeth out before I pulled over at the Dome overlook to air down some. After I had aired down, I got back in the truck and prepared to continue the trip.

Turned the key and got nothing. The voltmeter was reading about 6 volts, not enough to crank the engine. Connections were all clean and secure.

Luckily, the road was pretty busy today and the first person I asked had some jumper cables. Got it jump started and the alternator was putting out plenty of juice (voltmeter looked fairly normal when running). We headed back to town and stopped at Sears. Turned off the truck, tried to restart, and ... NADA. 6 volts again. My 2.5 year old Toyota-brand battery was officially dead. It had been consistently strong before today.

Put in a new battery and all is well now.

I am suspecting the jarring of the washboard road led to some internal breakage in the battery.

Lessons learned -
1. Air down before the washboards
2. Carry jumper cables, even when it's not cold outside
3. The AGM batteries like Optima or Sears Platinum may be a better choice if doing a lot of washboard roads.

I considered the alternator as the fault, but given the lack of dash lights and the "normal" look of the voltmeter when running, it looked like it was working fine. Double-checked when I got home. My multimeter said the new battery had ~13 volts at rest and ~15 volts running, so the alternator seems to be doing its job.
 
Last edited:
Wow Brad that is something. I wouldn't think wash boards would be enough to damage a battery. I wonder who makes Toyota batteries? Did you try to get a warranty replacement on it? I have heard nothing but good about the Sears platinum, that's how I may go in the future.
 
Previous owner bought the battery and I wasn't even sure I had a receipt. Found the old receipt when I got home, so probably could have warranted it... :whoops:

Looking around the net I found multiple references to washboard roads damaging batteries, so maybe it happens more often than we know.
 
Last edited:
Lol, yup. They need a grader up there bad! I had to do some work up there a the reservoirs on the stickler tunnel last week and got into a situation where I needed to drive my work van up old stage from the springs. Horrible. Especially in a work van.

I can absolutely believe those washboards took out a battery, they're that bad. Too bad you had to cancel the trip, it gets significantly better about a half mile from the overlook. Better luck to you next time, I hear nothing but good about the sears platinum too. I think they're rebadged odessy's.
 
I didn't buy the Platinum because this Sears didn't have one in stock that would fit right. I bought the Gold, which is a regular battery, because I didn't want to spend all afternoon running around looking for an AGM. If I had the convenience of shopping for a battery at my leisure, I would have bought the Platinum.
 
Not the first battery that road has done in ... though not permanently in my case.
 
Back
Top Bottom