LX totaled or repairable? Lady does her best to fit

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 26, 2009
Threads
46
Messages
860
Location
Bay Area, CA
I have a 2000 LX, in pretty decent shape, ~180k, er, "was" in decent shape. Got t-boned by some idiot a few days ago. Lady does her best to floor it between two +5,000# vehicles moving at 40mph while she is in compact SUV with toddler in backseat. She got the fender, fr door, rr door, and did a bang up job burying my front wheel in towards the middle of the car. I'm insured thru state farm, the responsible party thru Liberty Ins. The responsible party was sighted after the fact by Sheriff away from the scene (yes she swapped info then left the scene) and there is a pending investigation/report available in another week (reporting Deputy told me this is about as slam dunk as there is).

Body shop does est. and says its a month long repair and its around $9k (a little over actually but with my deductible factored in a little less). My ins agent initially gave me an "unofficial" guess that the $9k repair job would be a total. The body shop, inside the insurance co. recommended network, said same thing. Shop mgr. said officially any job at $11k for an LX in my condition would be a no brained and declared totaled. Surprisingly he said State Farms and his shop use similar software tot determine these values and the quick estimated value of the truck is around $16k. (hearing that I thought :popcorn:)

I went back to pull a few items out of my 100 (recovery gear type stuff) and kicked the tires over the 100 with the shop manager. He mentions a scuff on the rear bumper (like a 3-5 inch "scuff") and I tell him "I'm not even sure it's from the accident" (keep in mind there is 0% clear coat on the bumper and most of the remaining paint is peeled, crackled, scratched, or missing completely; and he's talking about a scuff but still :bang::bang::bang:)... Suddenly, as tho he found the smoking gun,, he happily responds that the cruiser will not be totaled:bang::bang::bang:. Tells me he's ordering parts Monday.

Huh? He told me he doesn't know if the frame is straight yet and he's going to go fwd? Also, there's visible damage to the door sills and supports. It's highly possible there may be more than meets the eye, right?

Anyway, aside from the lack of quick wit in regards to trying to milk every imperfection as being due to the accident :bang::bang::bang:... I should hear from the claims department Tues on the decision to move fwd with repair or a status of 'total loss'.

Do any of you have an idea of the value necessary to declare the 100 totaled? Im sure its different in all states, area, etc but anyone have an experience to share or is anyone one aware of the rough formula an ins co. uses? I hear 50-70% of the fair market value. Based on my fair market I'm at 55% already.

I'm alL bugged out that this bumper repair (which mgr tells me he only booked a couple-few hours) was the difference between totaled and repairable. Originally I'm hoping to not get totaled but now I don't know if I want her back if she's 0.01% away from being a totaled vehicle.

Thoughts?
 
Sorry to hear about your troubles Darin. What shop is it at? Also, are the repairs going through your insurance or the other party's?
 
Prestige in Campbell, off of Winchester area (by the RR tracks). Going through my company now; they'll subjugate w/ responsible party later. <--- do I have the right term?
 
Her car ...:ban:

Photo May 15, 3 15 32 PM.webp
 
Admins ... c'mon, this pix apear correct on my laptop, desktop, ipad, iphone, and then on upload?
 
Does the estimate include the repair or replacement of the doors? I'd push for replacement for safety reasons. Maybe that'll be enough to total it.
 
Really sorry to hear about the accident. If it gets totalled, how much do you get? 16K? hmm..... Do you want it gone or do you want it fixed? I would opt for totalled if the check i could get would get me something the same or better.
 
Sorry to hear but glad everyone is OK. You mentioned a deductible, you will not be paying this as its the RPs responsibility. Good luck with this. It sounds like you are in a very similar situation as me with the damage being right near the threshold. Welcome to the club.
 
Last edited:
Something around $15-17k is the number I'm hearing for a total'd car from my ins. That's plenty to get a nicer less miles truck. Of course, I'll have to redo plenty of maintenance items that are already done on my current wrecked 100 but hey, I guess that's the price you pay.

Does anyone have any experience with the where an ins. company draws the line with a total'd car? As in, the value amount compared to repair bill being 50% or 70% etc?
 
Supra -

yes, the estimate is whole new fender, both doors, and new (used from a truck with 40k miles) knuckle and components associated with it.
 
Total'd - $15.8 (of course, I only receive $15.3 as they minus the deductible; my insurance will go after the responsible party's insurance to recover deductible)
 
Sorry to hear about your truck, but at least the other driver had insurance, doesn't sound like anyone was hurt, and you might be able to replace what you had with the insurance money.
 
I would say $15.3 is pretty good for a 2000 with 180k miles!
 
True but I just bought the truck a few years ago and so I had a few more payments left. About 5 or 6. Haven't a 100 paid off and in great shape is worth more than $15k in term of usability. Also getting the $15.3k check is nice but by the time we pay off the lien holder ... $12-13k is so-so...

it's that grey area
 
12-13K will still buy you a nice LC that has a few mods on it. I wouldn't beat yourself up over it. I had mine looked at and the trail damage alone is upwards of 8K. Not to mention the respray (5K). I am driving a totaled LC right now more or less. If you do end up with 12-13K I would think you could get just about any 98-00 100 on the market (LC only).

Sorry to hear about the loss, it's a pain (I have never lost a vehicle in a accident, but could imagine it's quite a tiring process), but stick with it and maybe you will come out on top with a nicer truck than you lost.
 
Total'd - $15.8 (of course, I only receive $15.3 as they minus the deductible; my insurance will go after the responsible party's insurance to recover deductible)

File a small claims court action yourself for the deductible, the filing fee and the service fee. My experience is your insurance company will take too long.
 
Back
Top Bottom