Southeast Overland
Get lost! Go explore!
I haven't been able to examine a SmityBilt lift up close yet so I can't specifically comment on them. The biggest thing I would want hard data on is the metallurgy (if that's the correct word...).
I sell all cast (red) 48" Hi-Lifts for $69 and 60" Hi-Lifts for $79. That is an American made product from a small, locally owned American business. Can't beat that with a stick. (Shipping is a bear on them though.)
A general statement - I'll save $ wherever I can but the one thing I am very careful with quality on are recovery gear - shackles, two ropes/straps, lifts/jacks, etc. If an axle fails you stop moving - if jack fails you might also stop moving, just in a different way.

I sell all cast (red) 48" Hi-Lifts for $69 and 60" Hi-Lifts for $79. That is an American made product from a small, locally owned American business. Can't beat that with a stick. (Shipping is a bear on them though.)
A general statement - I'll save $ wherever I can but the one thing I am very careful with quality on are recovery gear - shackles, two ropes/straps, lifts/jacks, etc. If an axle fails you stop moving - if jack fails you might also stop moving, just in a different way.
