Here's what happened:
Toyota pulled a Pontiac, and slapped a very important name on a very unimportant and uninspiring vehicle. The GTO would have sold great if it didn't look like a huge Cavalier and it wasn't called GTO. But it did, and it was, so it was a huge disappointment.
The 250 could be a cool economy truck (and it would only ever be an economy truck with that drivetrain), but they called it a Land Cruiser. They could have called it a Prado. They could have called it a successor to the FJC, which would have made so much sense because they're both chick- trucks. But they didn't. They're going after the Bronco and the Wrangler. When in the last 40 years has a Land Cruiser been cross-shoppable with a Wrangler? Who could have every guessed that a Land Cruiser would be cross-shopped with a 4-cylinder Ford SUV?
Toyota f***ed up, and for all the reasons some of you goons think this will tank 200 values, you're exactly wrong and the opposite will happen. People wanting a flagship at a "I don't give a s***" price aren't going to bat an eye at the 250. Maybe they'd buy one for their house cleaners to pick up supplies in. No, instead they are going to go with tried and true and with what checks their boxes. The LC occupies occupied a space that discerning buyers wanted filled. Now it won't. It'll fill a space of JK guys who are tired of their trucks breaking.
Well, I take that back. Even a JK owner isn't going to want to downgrade to a 4 cylinder from their V6s. Especially with the only option being a hybrid power train that will effectively give you an anemic 4-pot to pull the truck in 10 years, with a 300lb cell phone charger where you'd want to keep aux fuel, water, air, spare, etc.
The really, really screwed the pooch.