Upper Pan Gasket Replaced for Free!!!!

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jan 26, 2007
Threads
15
Messages
256
Location
Chandler, AZ
At least that is what a shop tried to do for me today. I am still trying to figure out why, let me explain. (Please help me with this)

Brief History: 1995 FZJ80 174,000

Have had the cruiser about a month now, knew it had an oil leak when I bought, figured rear main (didn't know about pan arch til MUD). The leak has gotten progressively worse. Time to take it in.

I researched MUD for all possibilities, rear main (RM) and pan arch(PA) came up, I gathered that the PA was more common than the RM, is that correct?

Took to Toyota dealership, they said RM was leaking, but that PA might be too, and that RM's sometimes ruin the crank by gouging it, just as an FYI though, not that mine had. RM $700, PA $500

Called another shop with Toyota in their name (to remain nameless at this time, not trying to smear them if everything is legit) but not a dealership, that I found while searching this site. Told him the situation, he said Toyota dealerships just have a bunch of kids working there and all the good techs have opened up their own shops. Stated the RM's rarely go out on these, he's been a tech for 30yrs and it has always been the upper pan gasket leaking on these.

Made sense to me and was congruent with the research I had done.

Took the truck in this morning, he called me a couple hours later, said he did the mirror check and it was definitely the PA leaking and not the RM. I said to go ahead and fix it and he said he would have it done today or tomorrow morning.

He called me about four hours later said, "Just come get your truck, I'm not going to charge you for the work I did today, it still has a little leak, but I'm not going to charge you, just come and get it." This surprised me, I asked him why and he started acting evasive.

When I arrived at the shop he said the RM is leaking, but that he fixed the PA and wasn't going to charge me. (I don't know of ANY mechanics who work for free) I asked for an explanation, he said he fixed one leak and another one started, he wasn't equipped to work on vehicles with such modifications (OME lift and gears only drive train mod) I pointed to the lifted FJ40 with a V-8 just through the window in his shop, no explanation. Just asked to leave and said didn't want to work on my truck again.

Sorry this is so long winded but a lot happened.

He refused to give me any paper work stating he had worked on the truck, only that he had "inspected it for an oil leak" I wanted documentation that he had removed the oil pans and performed that work, in case any problems followed me home. He said the only way he would write a ticket was if I paid for the work. I told him I would rather pay $500 and have proof that he was in my motor than walk out empty handed, this surprised him.

After much debating and not much explaining (and him calling me names, and a PITA with a POS Land Cruiser, [it ain't shiny, but its no POS] I had two shops inspect it before purchase and both gave a clean bill of health sans the oil leak, and I was being very nice for me in a situation like this, not a PITA!) I had to practically demand he take my $500 so that I had documentation/WO. He seemed to be hiding something, does anyone have any idea what I should look for after work like that is performed where there may be damage. He wanted me to walk out of there with no paperwork and therefore no recourse!

Thank you to anyone with ideas and for making it through all that I wrote. I left many details out to keep this shorter.

This BL*WS!! What do you think???
 
:eek: :eek: I'm no expert, but if I was you, I'd be up under my truck taking pictures and inspecting for other damage that looks new. I'd also keep an eye on oil pressure, and levels in case they caused a "major leak". Pan plug stripped? Who knows? Best of luck, and let us know. And also might not be bad to cross post to the Copper State Cruisers section, there's a debate right now on mechanics, both with "Toyo" in their names...

FWIW, I just live with the quarter-sized drip on the driveway every couple of days. Gives the HOA-nazis something to do. :frown:

edit: no worries, looks like from your sig you have plenty of other rigs to drive around in the mean time!
 
Wow, that is the weirdest thing ever. The mechanic sounds just a little shady. I would take the afore-mentioned advice and take a ton of pics and check the level of all fluids including the tranny. Does the gasket look new? Are any of the bolts stripped out or missing? I would just play it safe and really watch your rig for anything out of the ordinary, and take to a real mechanic and have the RM replaced.

TK
 
I would have never driven it off his property until he provided some proof that you brought your truck into him for the work.

Sounds like he f***ed something up and doesn't want to admit it, and now just got away with it.
 
Thanks for the advice so far. I went to the 'TOYO' shop based on readings from CSC section, told him that too, slight attitude adjust after that. I need to hook up with you guys.

Pics and thorough inspection tomorrow morning.

NatorGator, the only reason I drove it off the lot was after I coughed up the 5 bills and he provided me with a ticket and work description on paper. I agree with you, I had to have documentation.
 
I had him crawl underneath the truck with me, I could see the new FIPG on the pans, and USDS motor mount nut had been removed, evident by the clean threads, in order to lift the motor and remove the pans. Will get under there with my creepy tomorrow.

Does anyone know if a shop has ever fractured the upper oil pan? Isn't it cast aluminum? Seems that not following a specific torque pattern may not be good for it.
 
LC,

Something is shady for sure. Since this is a Toyota dealer they are under the authority of Toyota (franchise agreement). This includes the service department.

Were you dealing with a service writer, technician, service manager, or what?

You obviously need to go over this guy's head.

I wouldn't fool around here. Go to Toyota, find the service rep over that dealer. Request to have the vehicle inspected under his direct supervision, with you present, at a different dealer.

Once the real problem is found, the issue of what's happening with your truck can be dealt with, fixed, whatever.

Next, deal with the guy who gave you a hard time. Personally, I would be happy to get my truck fixed, and have an apology from the offending tech, or whatever he is.

As far as what actually happened, let me take a guess.

If, as we suspect, he is not real familiar with Land Cruisers, he may not know that there are two oil pans. He may not know they use FIPG, and not a gasket.

Let's say he knows neither of these things, looks at oil leaking down on the bottom steel pan, and attempts to tighten the steel 6mm bolts. The upper pan is aluminum, the bolts are steel, there is no gasket, and they are a tight fit. He may have simply tried to tighten them till he broke one off, into the aluminum pan. He gets freaked out, and you know the rest. Just a guess.

Let us know how it goes.

DTaylor
 
DTaylor - Unfortunately it wasn't a Dealership, the shop just has Toyota in their name, the guy who worked on my truck is the owner, his is the last head I can get to. Sorry if some of the details in my description are fuzzy, I was trying to get everything down.

He did use FIPG, but you have a good point about snapping a bolt and freaking out. I'll check for that.

Thank you.
 
It may be time to name the shop because if your story is true something stinks.
 
OK, I didn't get that it was an independent shop. He still likely has garage liability. Get it looked at by someone who can convince you beyond any doubt that they know all about the 80. Dealer or not.

There is some reason he tried to run you off, and it ain't because of you or your truck.
 
LC/GS, true story, morally then what is the quandry? At the very least he treated you with enormous disrespect and is not the type of person I would ever want to take my landcruiser to regardless of his innocence or guilt in regards to damage of your truck.

It is obviously up to you to decide how to handle the situation, but I don't see why you are withholding the name of the shop if your story really as-is. Sounds like the kind of shop almost anybody would want to avoid.
 
OK, I didn't get that it was an independent shop. He still likely has garage liability. Get it looked at by someone who can convince you beyond any doubt that they know all about the 80. Dealer or not.

There is some reason he tried to run you off, and it ain't because of you or your truck.
I am having a hard time finding someone who knows all about the 80 so far. Thought this guy did. Guess I thought wrong. Time to do more research.

Good suggestions. And I agree with your last statement, he wanted me out of there fast and thought "Free" service would send me packin, it made me question. He wasn't ready for that.
 
LC/GS, true story, morally then what is the quandry? At the very least he treated you with enormous disrespect and is not the type of person I would ever want to take my landcruiser to regardless of his innocence or guilt in regards to damage of your truck.

It is obviously up to you to decide how to handle the situation, but I don't see why you are withholding the name of the shop if your story really as-is. Sounds like the kind of shop almost anybody would want to avoid.
I agree, at this point in time it is a shop to be avoided. If I slam him and he catches wind of it, there is absolutely no chance of an amicable resolution if something is screwed up.

I read the other day about a guy who bought his 80, found out the birfs were incorrectly lubed when last serviced, took to the dealer who performed the work and they still backed it even though the PO had the work done, not him. They could have easily turned him away, but being nice paid off for him. I will be nice until it is no longer possible, then . . .

If something is wrong and he refuses to help, trust you me his name and shop will be known. (And not just here)

Thanks
 
LC/GS, sounds like you are giving him the benefit of the doubt and trying to be amicable in this situation.

At this point I would have already written him off as disrespectful and not worth my time, but kudos to you for trying to salvage the situation. Best of luck with the matter, I hope it works out in your favor.

:cheers:
-----Nate
 
Don't get me wrong, I'm pissed and would like nothing more than to slam this shop, but I realize that won't fix anything.

Maybe nothings messed up, he fixed the PA gasket, and simply doesn't like to do rear mains. Although I doubt that's the case. Won' t know til I get more info.

Thanks and I hope it works out in my favor too, every time ;-)
 
interesting story.

Hope it never happens to me. (Then of course, I never took mine to a shop. Hope that continues...)
 
Odd, very odd.

I wonder the real reason he wanted it out of there so badly?
 
interesting story.

Hope it never happens to me. (Then of course, I never took mine to a shop. Hope that continues...)
I am learning quickly that DIY is the way to go, I am doing everything else, I just don't have the confidence to get into the motor yet. Look slike that will have to change!
 
Back
Top Bottom