This was close to my experience. Luckily I rejected the webbing from pictures before they installed it so I got a full refund. It seems to be hit and miss depending on what shipments they get in as to watch color matches they have.
I tried Safety Restore. They could not get anything close to a match for my tan/oak belts at the time. They did try and had pretty good customer service. They ended up sending my belts back but refunded all my money including the shipping costs both ways. Can't speak to their work but I would...