From Pirate Land use link County's Closure Recommendations - Pirate4x4.Com Bulletin Board
County's Closure Recommendations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
After all the hard work we put together making comments on the bypasses, we now have a "staff recommendation".
Here is the original list of work we did - Bypass Comment thread - Post your comments!!! - Pirate4x4.Com Bulletin Board to help you put it into context.
There will be a Public Meeting with the Board of Supervisors in Eldorado County on January 26th 2010 at 2PM in the BOS Chambers.
If there is anything on this list you want changed, you need to either let me know or show up and speak, because this is literally IT. Done, finito, irrevocable.
Quote:
VARIANTS NOT RECOMMENDED:
Map Location (M) “Wentworth Springs Campground Bypass”- County staff recommends against further use of the northerly variant through this area. The northerly alignment (designated 1.1 on Map) represents a user-created variant which avoided a low lying area which retained water prior to the Department and Friends of the Rubicon (FOTR) 2006/2007 joint maintenance efforts. It is the Department’s opinion that the 2006/2007 installed standard trail BMPs have improved the conditions of the recommended single alignment (1.0) at this location in accordance with the CAO requirements, eliminating the need for the secondary variant (1.1). Hence, the Department recommends remediating the non-preferred northerly variant using standard BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (C) “14N34B”- A USFS historic trail designated 14N34B, also known as the McKinstry Trail, intersects with the recommended Rubicon Trail alignment just west of Ellis Creek. This trail is on USFS property, and it drains into the recommended Rubicon Trail and into nearby Ellis Creek. This trail is mostly on the USFS property, and is outside the current preferred Rubicon Trail alignment. The Department does not recommend that it become part of the Rubicon Trail. Standard trail BMPs can be used at the intersection to control run-off and sediment, and to discourage future access to/from the Rubicon Trail at this location in order to comply with CAO requirements. All other trail work on 14N34B necessary to comply with the CAO should be completed by the USFS.
Map Location (D) “After Ellis Creek” – The southerly, historic trail section has been a major sediment source and drainage problem. County staff recommends utilizing the most popular variant located just to the north (designated 1.6 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1. Starr recommends remediating and restoring the non-preferred southerly trail section using standard trail BMPs, and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (E) “Soup Bowl” – County staff recommends retaining the most used variant location (designated 1.0 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1, and remediating the northerly variant which is a major sediment source and safety problem. The northerly variant is a more recently developed section of the trail that splits uphill, which is considered more challenging. Vehicles typically get stuck in this area creating a safety hazard and blocking traffic on both routes. Therefore, the Department recommends remediating the northerly variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (F) “West of Winter Camp” – County staff recommends retaining the most used variant location (designated 1.0 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1, and eliminating the northerly variant (designated as 1.7 on Map) which is a major sediment source. The Department recommends remediating the non-preferred variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (G) “Little Sluice Short Bypass” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant route. This variant is located just to the northeast of Little Sluice Box proper, and is mostly used during the summer months to get around the difficult and often-blocked Little Sluice Box. Some maintenance work was done in 2003 by the Department, USFS, and FOTR. However, this variant is very dangerous during the winter and late spring months due to snow and ice on the steep slopes. The Department recommends remediating this non-preferred variant with standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use of it.
Map Location (J) “Thousand Dollar Hill Bypass” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant. It is variant off the Little Sluice Long Bypass, Map location H. This variant is a loose, rocky climb with several off-camber spots which is dangerous and presents sedimentation problems. The Department recommends working with the private landowner to remediate this non-preferred variant with standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (Q) “Alternative Route Near Placer County Line” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant. This user created variant (designated as 1.11 on Map) is southwest of the main Rubicon Trail (1.0) and is not needed. Both the main route and non-preferred variant are located on privately-owned land. The Department recommends working with the private landowner to remediate the non-preferred variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
The paragraphs for map locations C,D,E,G,J and Q are those that go against FOTR's recommendations, the balance are in line with what we asked for.
I'm going to withhold personal comment until I settle down.
__________________
The 4405 MFS Land Use Buggy KOH RACE-A-THON
Click here to make your pledge
Friends of the Rubicon Website
County's Closure Recommendations
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
After all the hard work we put together making comments on the bypasses, we now have a "staff recommendation".
Here is the original list of work we did - Bypass Comment thread - Post your comments!!! - Pirate4x4.Com Bulletin Board to help you put it into context.
There will be a Public Meeting with the Board of Supervisors in Eldorado County on January 26th 2010 at 2PM in the BOS Chambers.
If there is anything on this list you want changed, you need to either let me know or show up and speak, because this is literally IT. Done, finito, irrevocable.
Quote:
VARIANTS NOT RECOMMENDED:
Map Location (M) “Wentworth Springs Campground Bypass”- County staff recommends against further use of the northerly variant through this area. The northerly alignment (designated 1.1 on Map) represents a user-created variant which avoided a low lying area which retained water prior to the Department and Friends of the Rubicon (FOTR) 2006/2007 joint maintenance efforts. It is the Department’s opinion that the 2006/2007 installed standard trail BMPs have improved the conditions of the recommended single alignment (1.0) at this location in accordance with the CAO requirements, eliminating the need for the secondary variant (1.1). Hence, the Department recommends remediating the non-preferred northerly variant using standard BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (C) “14N34B”- A USFS historic trail designated 14N34B, also known as the McKinstry Trail, intersects with the recommended Rubicon Trail alignment just west of Ellis Creek. This trail is on USFS property, and it drains into the recommended Rubicon Trail and into nearby Ellis Creek. This trail is mostly on the USFS property, and is outside the current preferred Rubicon Trail alignment. The Department does not recommend that it become part of the Rubicon Trail. Standard trail BMPs can be used at the intersection to control run-off and sediment, and to discourage future access to/from the Rubicon Trail at this location in order to comply with CAO requirements. All other trail work on 14N34B necessary to comply with the CAO should be completed by the USFS.
Map Location (D) “After Ellis Creek” – The southerly, historic trail section has been a major sediment source and drainage problem. County staff recommends utilizing the most popular variant located just to the north (designated 1.6 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1. Starr recommends remediating and restoring the non-preferred southerly trail section using standard trail BMPs, and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (E) “Soup Bowl” – County staff recommends retaining the most used variant location (designated 1.0 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1, and remediating the northerly variant which is a major sediment source and safety problem. The northerly variant is a more recently developed section of the trail that splits uphill, which is considered more challenging. Vehicles typically get stuck in this area creating a safety hazard and blocking traffic on both routes. Therefore, the Department recommends remediating the northerly variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (F) “West of Winter Camp” – County staff recommends retaining the most used variant location (designated 1.0 on Map) as the preferred single alignment in Option 1, and eliminating the northerly variant (designated as 1.7 on Map) which is a major sediment source. The Department recommends remediating the non-preferred variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (G) “Little Sluice Short Bypass” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant route. This variant is located just to the northeast of Little Sluice Box proper, and is mostly used during the summer months to get around the difficult and often-blocked Little Sluice Box. Some maintenance work was done in 2003 by the Department, USFS, and FOTR. However, this variant is very dangerous during the winter and late spring months due to snow and ice on the steep slopes. The Department recommends remediating this non-preferred variant with standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use of it.
Map Location (J) “Thousand Dollar Hill Bypass” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant. It is variant off the Little Sluice Long Bypass, Map location H. This variant is a loose, rocky climb with several off-camber spots which is dangerous and presents sedimentation problems. The Department recommends working with the private landowner to remediate this non-preferred variant with standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
Map Location (Q) “Alternative Route Near Placer County Line” – County staff recommends eliminating this non-preferred variant. This user created variant (designated as 1.11 on Map) is southwest of the main Rubicon Trail (1.0) and is not needed. Both the main route and non-preferred variant are located on privately-owned land. The Department recommends working with the private landowner to remediate the non-preferred variant using standard trail BMPs and discouraging future use on it.
The paragraphs for map locations C,D,E,G,J and Q are those that go against FOTR's recommendations, the balance are in line with what we asked for.
I'm going to withhold personal comment until I settle down.
__________________
The 4405 MFS Land Use Buggy KOH RACE-A-THON
Click here to make your pledge
Friends of the Rubicon Website
Last edited: