Been discussed but FWIW, the foam "gasket" IMHO was a mistake, not thought through very well (it was a port or dealer installed option, not done at the factory in Japan).
It's only purpose IMO was to fill the air gap caused by the upper lip of the nutserts ie: the wing/deflector mount sits on the top of the nutserts, not the hatch.
The problem is that it's an open cell foam which holds water like a sponge. So every time it rains or there's dew on the vehicle, that sponge soaks it up. And that is what causes the rust along with the holes that were punched through the sheet metal to install the nutserts.
Or to put it another way, it's not the lower nutsert that causes the problem, its the sponge that holds water which stays wet (more) at the lower
edge of that foam filler. The foam gasket at the upper nutserts dries out quicker so less rust, IMHO.
FWIW when I fixed the rust under those mounts (13 years ago) I left the foam sheet out entirely, no replacement, so there's a 1/16" air gap that will not hold water.
This is after the repair (removing rust, applying RustMort, JB Weld, priming and painting). The mount appears to be sitting on top of the repair but it's actually sitting on the top of the nutserts (as before). I just left the gasket out so that area would not hold water. You don't notice that gap with the dust deflector in place. This was meant a stop-gap quickie fix but it's still good after 13 years.
Previous thread:
Noticed a few months ago some rust starting to peek out from under the mounting brackets for the rear wind deflector so this evening decided to pull the deflector off and take a look. When removing the deflector I first removed the wing from the mounts, two #2 Phillips screws on each side...
forum.ih8mud.com