I bought the Cutthroat 1 the first year Jack put it to market (2000) when I was spending the summer in Lowman ID.
About the boat: Well worth the package price for what you get. I rafted up to class IV in it, although its lack of width made its lateral stability less than desirable..
Ran it the first three summers as is, and after swimming one too many times, I widened the frame, by about 2x... If I had only been running class III- and lower, it would be fine, but I wanted a little more out of it.. Was very easy to widen, there is fencing pipe that ID is the OD of the frame, and I added a real tractor seat on a x-bar, and used the trampoline style seats that came with it as two floor sections for the widened frame...
It is a fantastic 1 person play boat with the increased width-lateral stability, I can surf very small waves... It works on everything from our smaller tech creeks 900 cfs class III-IV's to the Nenana running around 13-14k cfs...
Everytime I meet someone new on the water the comment is "wow, that boat looks like a lot of fun"...
The only thing it is not is a gear hauler, and its a pig w/even 2 people on it (although its doable).. But it is a great safety boat, as I can go places larger cats/rafts cant, its almost on level of a kayak I have so much leverage and control over such a small boat..
One option I wish I had back then was to get bigger tubes... Given the 16" tubes, the frame sits pretty close to the water, would be nice to be just a bit higher. If I could trade I would get the 19" tubes over the current 16"
About JPW: Really great quality, and their welding process makes for really, really solid tubes. Jack is a nice guy who's talked to me personally a few times, not as a salesman, just talking boating and ideas, etc.. Another plus is all of the customization that is avail thru them that you really cant get thru other MFG's...
Yes pvc can degrade in the sun and has its own set of drawbacks, (so does hypalon, and every other material, they ALL have their drawbacks) but a well taken care of boat from any of the major mfg's will last regardless of the material.. Care is more important than anything else if you want your inflatable to last.. PVC is less expensive, an is generally considered easier to repair...
And AFAIK, jack had a policy of doing weld repairs if the customer requested...
My boat has been hammered on, hauled out the side of a canyon (tore a tube), and generally abused in the summer, and preped and properly stored each winter and still has years of use left...
My next set of cat tubes will prob be Jacks... But this spring I'm going to pick up a Star Bug or Superbug, for a dryer ride while still keeping cat like handling..
IMO: Tho if you are really looking for a fishing Cat vs. a more Whitewater type boat, I would look at the Outcast pro series (tubes made by aire)...
http://www.outcastboats.com/outcastboats/pro.shtml They do cost more, but they are also more properly rigged for the occupant to be standing up in front fishing.. The Cutthroat could definitly be rigged like this (and Jacks may even be able to do it for ya) but it will cost more $$$... We rigged a outcast last year here at work for electro-fishing sampling in western AK, and they are well equiped out of the box for fishing.. and could handle class III with ease..
pm me if you have any other questions...
