I believe John said it wasn't working in a message. I personally would go the salvage yard route as third generation 4Runners do not seem that hard to find. If I didn't go with a factory power antenna I would go the soft whip style. A fixed antenna takes a beating from brush off road and believe John already had a issue with someone breaking the rear wiper on his last 4Runner doesn't make sense to give them another target. Before I did replace it I would check to see of the antenna is switching voltage when it should be up or should be down. My 3rd gen 4Runner had a aftermarket radio when I bought it and the antenna went up when ever I turned the unit on whether I was listening to the radio or a CD. When I replaced it with a factory head unit and amp it now only goes up with the radio. With a aftermarket radio it could be someone didn't wire the harness adapter right.