Do we have an award in the Sty for the most egregious instance of stupidity while working on our pigs? If so, I would like to nominate myself for this year's honor. Actually, in the ever so slightest attempt of defense, there was an element of impatience involved; but it was mostly stupidity.
So on with the details. I thought I would throw my brake calipers on one day last week but couldn't get the bolts started. I figured it was just the Mastercoat paint buildup around the first thread or two so I grabbed a tap to chase the first thread or two and proceeded to install the driver's side. All went well. Torque spec is 54 to 76 ft lbs so I tightened them to 65 and called it good. Had the same issue on the passenger side but one of the two bolt holes didn't want to "come clean" after a turn or two......so of course I went about half way through and then installed the bolts. Well that bolt didn't really want to go in but of course I insisted, at least I did until it started turning freely.
I checked the bolt and the threads were buggered up so that really pissed me off and I ordered another bolt on my next parts order. In the meantime, like maybe the next morning it hit me that I grabbed an M12-1.75 tap instead of the M12-1.25. New bolt arrived and would tighten but as soon as I applied much torque it spun.
So there are a few different thread repair methods around and after a bit of research it looks like a helicoil would be a good option. The metal is just over 17mm thick so something around 15 or 16mm would be perfect. I haven't done an exhaustive search but they seem to jump from 1D (12mm) to 1.5D (18mm).
So I guess I have three areas where advice would be most appreciated. 1) is a helicoil the right answer? 2) is 12mm enough thread for say 60 ft-lbs, and 3) given that I don't need to remove hardly any material, do you think I could free hand this hole in place?
The drill bit for an M12-1.25 helicoil kit is 31/64" which is 12.30mm so we're talking very little material that will be removed - especially since I have already managed to remove most of the threads. I have a drill press, and I know that is the "right" answer but it's a bit of a pain to get the knuckle off.
Regarding question number 2, all the information I can find on the internet says an M12-1.25 x 12mm long helicoil is fine for 75 ft-lbs as long as the base material is strong enough (and it obviously is). Edit: it does appear from further reading that I could use an 18mm long helicoil and either live with the 1mm sticking out or grind/trim the excess off after installation. Of course that almost certainly means I have to at least pull the caliper, if not the knuckle.
As much as my own ineptness upsets me, I do take some solace in knowing that this issue should be repairable with no lingering issues.
It's the top caliper bolt hole on the passenger side: