What would you do?

Rust issue: do I take off the hard top or not?

  • Quit being a bi*** and do it right the first time

    Votes: 5 83.3%
  • Fix it as best as you can without taking the top off

    Votes: 1 16.7%

  • Total voters
    6

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Nov 30, 2006
Threads
33
Messages
217
Location
UT and CA
I purchased a low mileage ‘82 FJ40 a year ago and the body is incredible shape.. minus the area around windshield. I need to address this rust.. the top of it has never been off, and from experience and reading up, once that too comes off, it’s hard to get it to fit just the same
Way.. that being said, do I take the hard top off, and get underneath the weather stripping, repaint those areas (which hurts my soul because it is all
Original) or do I spot treat and recognize this might last 2-10 years? I’m also going to need to address the area of where the front windshield meets the cowl.
what would you do? Feel free to be specific down to what products/paint you would use..

Thanks for your advice!

355FA26C-F54D-442E-81AB-B8A2CE13B9EA.webp


8324E1E4-6E65-498D-A931-0328C8F769A9.webp


E219D4A3-7866-47B1-90EF-E240A40DA00C.webp


83C83776-5D5A-423D-B226-A45977500824.webp
 
Top‘s coming off if it’s me. Has the whole truck been repainted, cause it does not make sense to me that this is the only rust location.
 
Last edited:
So the hood/cowl is a different color than the body but the tops never been off? Just curious how you know the top has never been off? Pretty sure you can still buy those OEM gaskets new so I wouldn't hesitate to pull the top, if for no other reason than to drive it without the top. :cheers:
 
Can you fold down the windshield to check it without taking the top off?
Top needs to come off to fold down the glass. Plus I'd want to see the condition of the top of the tub that rides up into the side panels along with the insides and bottoms of the panels.

It's not hard to pull off the ambi doors, seat belts and then unbolt and have a couple of friends help lifting it off as a unit. I'm tall and used to hoist if off with the weight on my back but wouldn't recommend that method because its pretty heavy and you have to make sure the B-Pilar posts clear the tub sides and spare as you walk it off. Mark up a couple of zip locks to keep your hardware organized.

If its true that the top has never been off, them you are going to want to replace all the rubber before you reinstall it. I'd say you will want to replace the rubber gasket that sits between the cowl and windshield frame, they rot over time and you will know when it fails because you will get rain water coming into the cab. Having extra hands really helps when reinstalling so you can make sure the top sits down evenly and doesn't pinch or move the seals. Getting the top of windshield seal perfectly straight will ensure you don't have any leaks or wind noise.
 
... the top of it has never been off, and from experience and reading up, once that too comes off, it’s hard to get it to fit just the same
Way.

FWIW, I have taken mine off every spring and put it back on every fall for many years, and don't have any problems getting it to fit the same way.

If it was my truck, I'd probably want to fix it eventually, it's just going to get worse. But if you just bought it, you could drive and enjoy it for a season before digging in to body repair.
 
Kind of to what he mentioned i'm scared of taking mine off too, what I can't see doesn't exist right lol

Hoping in the dry climate it's in now it at least won't get any worse.
 
I would pull the top and have the cowl and WS frame painted professionally with single stage enamel, nicely color matched. Before paint, the rust will need to be sanded, treated with phosphoric acid (rust converter), then primed and sanded. If you have a shop do this, find one that is patient and cool enough to understand that your goal is to have this repainted part look like it never happened.

I have heard this 'the tops never fit the same after they have been taken off' and I think it's mostly folklore. Technically true, but an FJ40 is a blast to drive with the top off, so whatever you do, don't fail to take it for a spin with the roof off. The only thing crazier than NOT removing it would be NOT enjoying a ride with the top removed.

After all this, store it indoors and quickly touch up any chips on the face of the WS frame to keep it from ever doing this again.
 
wash it thoroughly

then use CLR sparingly on the seams and rock chips

re post the pics
I would do this before doing anything or making any decisions. This is the easiest and least intrusive way to start off. Clean it up then you'll have a little more information to decide and no harm done.
Also consider what your future with this 40 is, if it's going to be the one you hang onto forever, then you have time to do this later. If you think you might be passing it along to the next guy, just give full disclosure and keep it unmolested and original.
Just my 2 cents.
 
I found this video very helpful when I was fixing some similar rust spots and had good results. I put a coat of POR 15 on the spots that had pitting to get down in the pits.

Yes, but you should not apply filler directly on this kind of rusty surface. There is always left some even when you are grinded it ”good”. Rust Converter works, POR15 is good stuff too.
 
Back
Top Bottom