Best Cheap Toilet?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

LK1

Joined
Nov 4, 2005
Threads
8
Messages
63
Location
Boston
Need to replace a toilet in a rental unit. The criteria is white and something that I won't be unclogging.

Would like to spend $100 ish.

Figured chat was an appropriate place to post this:flipoff2:
 
you can get a 5gal. bucket from the home despot for abot $6. (yah, i know $6 for a friggin' bucket!)
 
I've installed several of the Glacier Bay chair height elongated bowl toilets. I hate Glacier Bay faucets, but this toilet has Fluidmaster guts, and one of the best rated flushes in the store, according to their propaganda. It's one of the newer high efficiency jobs, uses even less water than usual. I find the flush works fine for piss, but the handle needs to be held down just a second longer for the heavy stuff. Europe has gone to a two-button toilet, with one button sort of a half-flush, so I think these new HE toilets are following that example. The toilet goes for $109 locally at Home Depot and is complete- seat, wax ring, bolts & caps, everything. I toss their s***ty wax ring and get the reinforced bad boy, and I always replace the angle stop (valve) and supply line.

BTW, you would have gotten this same response from me in the correct forum. :D
 
Thank you. Shut-off seems OK but I will go with the better ring.
 
you can get a 5gal. bucket from the home despot for abot $6. (yah, i know $6 for a friggin' bucket!)

Damn. Beat me to it. :D


If you have a local "habitat for humanity re-store" they should have a $25 crapper. Goes to a good cause too.
 
This would be why it's best to post in the correct forum.

Chat is always full of chit; seems only fair to discuss a receptacle here too. :D
 
This would be why it's best to post in the correct forum.


My apologies oh green one!











Will this ruin my post count?:flipoff2:
 
Best toilet I ever used was the Kohler elongated when I had my residential business for 22 years...never one call back. So you say "how strong does he really feel about them"?...I put over 48 to date here at the college and have not had ONE BIT of trouble with any of them to date.


It has a "short flush" but if you hold the handle down for an addtional 8-10 secs you get a "complete" flush...lets just say it'll send the mother load packing.....lol.

The same model I buy from WinnNelson is available at Lowes.
 
Thank you. Shut-off seems OK but I will go with the better ring.

Yep, save yourself twenty bucks and twenty minute's work today. Wait 'till the stupid thing breaks and puts 2 inches of water over your floors while you're on vacation. Been there, seen it, the mildew smell never goes away, even when you replace all the drywall near the floor, all the doors, casings, flooring, baseboard... And that was the valve itself breaking, not the supply line.

Buy the angle stop from a plumbing supply store, The Brasscraft ones at HD suck. Dahl is a great product. Remember, after you replace that toilet, you won't look at it again until it gives you a problem. Don't let that problem be a flooded house.
 
Hey. The toilet is on the third floor. What could possibly go wrong if the valve failed? J/K:flipoff2:

I assume I'll have to turn off the main water supply? Does the valve screw on or do I have to weld it?

Thanks again.
 
You'll have to look at it, but I've never seen one that was soldered on. Most common nowadays is a compression fitting, or it might be a threaded fitting. What kind of pipes do you have- galvanized steel, or copper, CPVC, PEX...? If they're galvy, it's probably a threaded fitting. Anything else is probably a compression fitting, which are the easiest to change out.
 
It may be self evident but what is the best way to change a compression fitting? I have installed a few and it seemed like they were on there pretty tight.
 
You can either re-use the nut and ring, or buy a puller (HD, HF both carry them near me) and go all new. Post up a pic of what you have, if you want.
 
Spike,

I'm heading over there today so I will get a picture of the shut off.

Thanks,

Lee
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom