SUA v/s SOA

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I don't know if it helps but here is my take on leaf springs for a SOA.. I have towed cars and big heavy trailers, loaded the bejeezus out of it, very much like a SUA 55 with a good spring pack. It took a lot of trial and error to get my pig to finally be as possibly safe and cruiserlike as possible, IMO especially with wagons too many SOAs are too soft and wafty including mine until I finally got my leaf packs right... I also used the stiffest shocks I could find at the time which I think were now a little too stiff, I would use something softer with this spring pack next time. On dirt roads with lots of misc rocks etc it bounced around pretty well so I think maybe Doetchtech 3000s instead of 9000s next time would be better..

http://www.pirate4x4.com/forum/showpost.php?p=4725895&postcount=45

That said the big thing for me is SOAs are big, bigger than 95% of us need for regular cruiser duty. They look pretty good but when I would look at my 55 with 35s I would catch myself sometimes saying jeez thats big for 95% of what it was doing, dder duty.. Of course at Cruise Moab it would feel small too :) My vote for most is SUA and 33s maybe unless you really are building a rig and are planning to and genuinely enjoy 4WDing and use it often.. 35's are cool and you can wheel very well but they are expensive and large... Just my $.02 on it...
 
What he said. An SOA will never be as safe as a SUA when it comes to pavement.

And that statement quoted this one from Isotel:

"Stay Under.. SOA will always be Less "Safe" on road."




These statements are so all encompassing and so vauge that they are meaningless.


There are so many variable that make a rig "safe" or "unsafe" that I couoldn't begin to list them here. And so many subjective calls as to what qualifys for each that even defining what is "safe" or "unsafe" is a big job.


Let's simplify it. Assume that EVERYTHING on the rig is identical. Assume that the driver is knowledgable and responsible. Assume the same height and same tires. EVERYTHING except that one rig has the axles over the springs and the other has them under.

I've just ruled out the things that actually form the basis of copmparision of different rigs in the real world and all of the differences that actually contribute to any change in safety. But that os not what this thread is discussing. The question at hand is SOA or SUA.

So...


Now explain how one is safer than the other. Explain how that applies to all conditions and situations (You guys said "never" and "always"...) Probably better explain "safe" and "Less safe" too.


Mark...
 
That said the big thing for me is SOAs are big, bigger than 95% of us need for regular cruiser duty. They look pretty good but when I would look at my 55 with 35s I would catch myself sometimes saying jeez thats big for 95% of what it was doing, dder duty.. Of course at Cruise Moab it would feel small too :) My vote for most is SUA and 33s maybe unless you really are building a rig and are planning to and genuinely enjoy 4WDing and use it often.. 35's are cool and you can wheel very well but they are expensive and large... Just my $.02 on it...



Maybe we need to divide this thread up between rigs for off road use and rigs for the street.

If you are talking about a street rig, then leave the dang thing stock. If you are just using the rig for daily driving and a three or four time a year jaunt down some fireroads, then stay stock and call it good.

SOA is definitely not the way to go for this use. You don't need the room for larger tires and you don't need to spend the money. But that applies to any type of lift at all and just about every mod that is done to the rigs or is duscussed on this Board.

35s are only large and expensive if you are not going anywhere that calls for them.


Mark...
 
figure out what your going to be doing in your rig then get back to us
 
No offense, but if I lived in Beirut Lebannon the last thing on my mind would be flipping my SOA truck going around a turn.

If you drive a SOA in a sane manner it is very safe and streetable. I feel very safe going around corners and don't have much more sway than stock due to stiff shocks and modified spring packs.

Stay safe over there!
 
I DD my 78 with SOA and 35's for several years before I bought my truck. It is very stable on corners, during freeway driving, city driving, etc. If an SOA is done correctly, then the vehicle will be very stable and safe. That being said, you can flip any 4x4 (trucks, SUV's, off-road rigs, etc.) if you take a corner too quickly. That's just a matter of inertia, not SUA vs. SOA.
 
Difference is down here I think, even in rural areas, you'll find that you DD on pavement 90% of the time almost regardless of who you are. At least this is the case with me. But if I were building my 55, I would probably SOA again would be my guess for those few annual trips to Moab, makes them more enjoyable, and willing to take the slightly increased negative effects which are there but not too bad. I feel like most do SOAs and tires pretty much for cosmetics, hate to say. Nothing wrong with that, but not a reason to do a SOA in my opinion... Also it does change your rig a little bit, makes it "BIG" in my opinion, especially with the wagons. That said, drove my 55 daily during the summer, it would be 2-3 months before I would fire up the other better driving rig. Willing to tolate the higher center of gravity and more general work in driving that the 55 requires. Not too bad but it is there, and can wear you down. I guess those few trips to Moab makes it worth it. At least down there I feel like you can make it up/over anything with 35s and lockers and gearing, no shame at all if you can't and even gives it a little challenge. But that said it is mod that again should be carefully weighed I think for most guys who just DD...
 
Recently, and following a reply i posted bout SUA and benefits, i've been "massacred", "shut down", "bashed" by fellow mates on the site sayin that SOA is smoother than SUA and that it "runs like a cadillac" although we all know no cruiser is smooth ride material.

so i figured, even though this topic has been dried to death that all you people would contribute to this pole and post personal experience about both SUA and SOA ( good and bad ). personally i got a 4" lift and my leaf springs are under axle with a curve to create more height. although i feel a little of stiffness on the road but i'd rather go for safety rather than the dangers of SOA and the chances of my truck flipping on corners.

i would appreciate all objectivity in the replies.

one more thing, for all SUA people if you got some tricks to make it smoother it would be great. still a rookie in the department hehe.




Your mind is obviously made up. Why even ask the question:confused: your opinion is formed with no facts for your argument....
You speak like you are an expert and have seen the dangers of a SOA rig. FWIW a "stock" Cruiser is not safe by you reasoning either. The only time my Cruiser has evere rolled was back around 1974 when it was a couple years old.
I have been running SOA for about 15 years and around 100k miles without rolling. I will NEVER go back to SUA. Thats my opinion..........
 
i'm a city boy. i want my cruiser to have 33s. i want a more flexible suspension but i don't want to be way up in the air. so, i'm minimizing a soa. yay for me! someday i'll post some pictures. you can have it all if you put in some research and effort toward your goal.
word
 
After debating SUA vs. SOA, I'm doing an SOA on my cruiser here's why........

- First, a HUGE percentage of 4 wheel drives are SOA - GM, newer jeep, ford, IH, etc. If all 4x rigs started as SUA then I'd never go SOA. My chevy is factory SOA, does that mean it's unsafe and the engineer's that designed it are stupid?
- Ride quality
- In my opinion long shackles can be just as dangerous as SOA
- A rig with a short wheelbase shouldn't be hot-rodded around corners anyway
- I'll be doing a shackle reversal. My front shackle hanger will be thru the frame reducing lateral stress problems
- Big tires - 37" probably

I'm going SOA because I want to crawl over big things. Articulation and clearance are big priorities for me. If it's not for you, then stay factory IMHO :)
 
SOA because I want to crawl over big things. Articulation and clearance are big priorities for me. If it's not for you, then stay factory IMHO :)

X2. If you drive right and don't hot rod your cruiser it shouldn't be a problem. I'm probably a little too tall to have mine be street legal but I'm sure after I get those 55 springs to settle an inch I won't be having any issues. I have a friend SOA with stockers and helpers...passes with 38.5" tires.
 
:) My '40 with 39.5s, Pig springs and load coils too (5-6 inches of up travel on the front shocks), sits just under the legal frame height of 26 inches. :)


Mark...
 
what do you know bout lebanon?

No offense, but if I lived in Beirut Lebannon the last thing on my mind would be flipping my SOA truck going around a turn.

If you drive a SOA in a sane manner it is very safe and streetable. I feel very safe going around corners and don't have much more sway than stock due to stiff shocks and modified spring packs.

Stay safe over there!
why would it be the last thing on your mind? and thanks for the concern
 
Your mind is obviously made up. Why even ask the question:confused: your opinion is formed with no facts for your argument....
You speak like you are an expert and have seen the dangers of a SOA rig. FWIW a "stock" Cruiser is not safe by you reasoning either. The only time my Cruiser has evere rolled was back around 1974 when it was a couple years old.
I have been running SOA for about 15 years and around 100k miles without rolling. I will NEVER go back to SUA. Thats my opinion..........
im no expert at all, im still a newbie in this business and wanted to know more about personal experiences (that was the point of the thread), i did not attack SOA just asked about it's dangers and im getting feedback with and against SOA. no reason to be this defensive. anyways thanks for your feedback and good job not rolling your rig for the past 15 years.
 
And that statement quoted this one from Isotel:

"Stay Under.. SOA will always be Less "Safe" on road."




These statements are so all encompassing and so vauge that they are meaningless.


There are so many variable that make a rig "safe" or "unsafe" that I couoldn't begin to list them here. And so many subjective calls as to what qualifys for each that even defining what is "safe" or "unsafe" is a big job.


Let's simplify it. Assume that EVERYTHING on the rig is identical. Assume that the driver is knowledgable and responsible. Assume the same height and same tires. EVERYTHING except that one rig has the axles over the springs and the other has them under.

I've just ruled out the things that actually form the basis of copmparision of different rigs in the real world and all of the differences that actually contribute to any change in safety. But that os not what this thread is discussing. The question at hand is SOA or SUA.

So...


Now explain how one is safer than the other. Explain how that applies to all conditions and situations (You guys said "never" and "always"...) Probably better explain "safe" and "Less safe" too.


Mark...


I don't care what kind of cruiser you have, if you SOA a cruiser with stock springs (which is what most people do) from a cruiser that had 4 inch lift with shackles. The cruiser with the SOA is going to go out of control a lot quicker on pavement in an emergancy situation than a SUA with lifted springs. I've had both I currently own a SOA cruiser. It is not the safest vehicle out there. You have to know what you are doing.
 
Your still not stating what exactly you think is different. It goes "out of control" because of..... what?

But so far, I have to say BS. I've owned and driven a lot more than one of each. You simply cannot support a blanket statement that a Cruiser with the springs on top of the axles is less safe or will "go out of control a lot quicker" than one with the springs under the axle.

I'm not going to say that an SOA '40 is the safest ring in the rod. But neither is an SUA '40. Stock, or modified in any of the miriad ways that we do, none of them are the safest rig on the road.


Mark...
 
I agree with Mark, you cannot make blanket statements like "SOA are not as safe as SUA on road". I have a SOA and it is set up properly. It is not really a function of if the springs are located top and bottom but rather how well the work is done and if it is all measured and performed correctly and safely. My SOA is WAY safer than it was when it was SUA, it tracks better, responds better, etc. There are just way to many factors to consider when speaking of this kind of stuff. Overall if you are staying on road, SUA is cheaper and easier. SOA should be considered for off road ability, that is where it will shine. I have an FJ40 that is my trail truck, SOA. I am building an FJ55 now that is a restoration and will see most of it's time on the street, thus no reason for SOA or lockers or big tires, just easier and makes more sense to keep it simple and stock. This is the kind of thought process people should be thinking of when considering SUA vs. SOA.

Noah
 
Your still not stating what exactly you think is different. It goes "out of control" because of..... what?

But so far, I have to say BS. I've owned and driven a lot more than one of each. You simply cannot support a blanket statement that a Cruiser with the springs on top of the axles is less safe or will "go out of control a lot quicker" than one with the springs under the axle.

I'm not going to say that an SOA '40 is the safest ring in the rod. But neither is an SUA '40. Stock, or modified in any of the miriad ways that we do, none of them are the safest rig on the road.


Mark...


Less flex equals less sway. Just because I have only had 2 40's in my life doesn't mean they were always the same throughout their life. I have ridden, driven lots and lots of 40's. In all shapes and sizes. Not one being the same. But I can say I have never been in an SOA vehicle that has handled better on road than any SUA. I didn't become president of one of the bigger clubs in the TLCA because I don't know what I'm talking about. My opinion stays. I honor yours.
 
depends on driving style as well.

sure i could roll mine on a corner, i could probably roll anything on a corner if i wanted too.


i feel just as safe now as i did when i was sua.




no biggie
 
Back
Top Bottom