So what would you do ?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

YoYoHo

BJZ43 for Me !
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Threads
79
Messages
1,020
Location
Mountains
So here is a question for all you 40 guys and gals. I have a 74 FJ40 which is almost rust free and complete apart from the Chevy Engine in place of the Toyota one.

It is a solid car and I was driving it around before I put it in storage and it is mostly origiginal but has enough changes that it is far enough from original to stop me feeling to bad ( Chevy, Cut Guards etc ) .

Now I also have a few others and I think I will look to sell the 74 on as I have picked up a BJ46 which I have always wanted BUT the FJ40 has some nicer parts on it like fenders and hood than the 46.

So the question is should I wreck out the 40 and keep the parts I want of it for the 46 or not kill an otherwise healthy 40 ?

With the prices people are asking for parts I can get enough for the FJ40 parting it just seems like a stupid idea seeing a lot of the projects I see on here start way rougher than the FJ I have. But on the flip side the parts I want off it are in better condition than most I see for sale.
 
asking price and selling price on parts can vary widely.
parting a rig takes lots of time and patience

fenders and a hood are fairly easy to find.$1100 for fenders new OEM and $200? for a hood. why cannibalize a good rig for a few parts?
sell it and use that money to fund the other project.
 
parting out takes a lot of time, and no telling if and when your parts will sell

I agree with the advice to sell as a running truck
 
Shipping every part on a 40 take along time... if you have time to give shipping quotes to hundreds of people and ship half that it’s very profitable but also equates to a part time job.

Sell it whole, do the cruiser justice and sell it to someone who will drive it like it deserves.
 
Thanks for the feedback I will see how it goes I don't disagree about it being a full time job selling off the parts, just like it can be a major PITA To find good parts . That's the exact reason I avoid selling stuff and dealing with some people to buy is just as much of a PITA as selling.

That being said if current prices I see on here and on Craigslist / Ebay are anything to go by I wouldn't have to sell much to cover the cost either way and come out in front. With the price of Hard Tops, Doors, factory interior etc I shouldn't have to nickel and dime.


I will wait for the 46 to arrive and work out what I want to do then. Hopefully I will run into some of these people who have all these awesome quality parts for a good price.
 

IMG_1763.JPG


IMG_1785.JPG


IMG_4329.JPG
 
That being said if current prices I see on here and on Craigslist / Ebay are anything to go by I wouldn't have to sell much to cover the cost either way and come out in front. With the price of Hard Tops, Doors, factory interior etc I shouldn't have to nickel and dime.

until you actually do it, you have no idea the what is involved in parting and selling a rig. list prices do not equal sold prices.

you'll find lots of interest for big items from across the country until the buyer finds out how much the shipping costs. then it also has to be boxed and packaged so there is no damage. if there is damage you'll wait a while to get re-inbursed from the shipping company if at all.

I sell a lot of parts and have shipped overseas also. I still have some parts left from the very first rig I parted 15+ years ago.

looking at the 3 pics above, that would be a shame to piece that rig out, but it is yours and you can do whatever you want with it.
 
Last edited:
Thats a nice 40. If you part it out we will tar and feather you and parade you around town in a pink barbie jeep and post pics all over instagram and facebook. You've been warned. If you sell that green one you should easily be able to afford a lot of nice new or used parts. You could probably get a complete new tub with new fenders for a fair amount less than what the green one would fetch is sold whole. I honestly don't think you will make as much on the green one if you part it out. If the rest of that green one is as nice on the rear as it is of the pic on the front you should get an easy 12k or more for it.
 
$12k , I would let it go for $10 :)
 
I agree with the guys above. If you part that rig out you are not only a fool but an asshat as well. That is a great little rig and needs to go to some one who will take care of it. These 40's are slowly going away from rust, accidents, fires and other disasters. If a person owns one it is more than likely gaining value better than passbook savings accounts.
 
Well now, it maybe could have been said a bit more tactfully...but @Helipilot has some good points.

Your 40 really looks good. Would never want to to 'part out' that nice of a truck. If you keep it, you will NOT lose $$ on it.
 
So now some guy I have never met is gunna tar and feather me and another guy thinks I am an ass hat SWEET I look forward to some day meeting you guys in person and seeing if you are as polite in person.

In regards to the 40 I haven't done anything with it, in fact it is in a storage container just chilling while I work out what the best option is along with several others.

I do not disagree with peoples preference to keep it together and of course on a forum such as MUD I would expect nothing else being it is a collectible. But why would I give up pristine parts that I need for a different project so I can spend endless hours trying to get the same parts again and dealing with people who potentially call me an ass hat ??

If I could buy OEM fenders etc at an affordable price point then my point would be moot but the last set I saw was like $1000 ea and many parts are no longer available.

The 46 is worth way more than the 40 ever will be and is way more collectible so surely in line with the purist argument it is better to keep it as factory and solid as possible
 
Back
Top Bottom