How Center Diffs Work

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

I must be masochistic for posting to this thread. ...The 80/20 split comes from the limits of the fluid to transfer, and of course, any transfer is going to have some losses. Does this help? Or make it worse?

I'm almost afraid to say I agree! :o

Coupled axles can transfer torque up to the TBR over the center diff. EDL braked axles cen't transfer torque thru a center diff.

ST
 
OK.
I'm 75% ready to say that I was wrong, but I still have a couple issues.

1. Drawing the diagram for myself got me questioning my position on the VC only raising the supported torque, and I see that some of the torque would be transferred to the other axle--but I can't get my head around the resistance of the VC NOT raising the supported torque on the slipping axle at all.
Also, the torque is still ultimately routed from the tranny through the differential, so I can't see how the diff doesn't have some influence on the allocation--even with the VC active.

2. In my previous post, I pointed out that--as far as I understand it--the VC transfers torque through a speed differential. I can't see how the torque supported at either axle has anything to do with the torque transfer through the VC--only the relative speed difference. In my mind that makes the "80% of the supported torque to the other axle" description wrong. If anything, the VC would transfer a fixed range of torque defined by the viscous character of the VC itself, varying within that fixed range by the relative speed difference.
In other words, the VC could transfer between 0 and x amount of torque--not percentages, period.


I'm not afraid to say I was wrong (and it seems I am), and I'm not going to get pissed and say you're a jerk--which is more or less what has happened in previous "SUMO" posts--but I'm also not content to take your lessons and conclusions at face value and upon your proclaimed expertise. Nobody knows everything and no one is free from misunderstanding.
I'm going to genuinely ask a favor that in the future you make a little more effort to actually explain your statements rather than following with assertions that effectively say "that's the way it is." As a former teacher I will say that in MY experience, a lesson doesn't teach unless you really try to understand your students' misunderstanding. A lecture is seldom appreciated or effective--so I'll end mine here.

I WOULD appreciate it if you could find the time to help me get past my remaining questions, above.

Hayes
 
OK.
I'm 75% ready to say that I was wrong, but I still have a couple issues.

1. Drawing the diagram for myself got me questioning my position on the VC only raising the supported torque, and I see that some of the torque would be transferred to the other axle--but I can't get my head around the resistance of the VC NOT raising the supported torque on the slipping axle at all.

you don't need to get that out of your head. Some amount of torque is spining the driveshaft and tire wildly, some amount is the 20 that is going into the coupler. The coupler has to feed some resistance back to that driveshaft, can't have a force without an opposing one, right?

2. In my previous post, I pointed out that--as far as I understand it--the VC transfers torque through a speed differential. I can't see how the torque supported at either axle has anything to do with the torque transfer through the VC--only the relative speed difference. In my mind that makes the "80% of the supported torque to the other axle" description wrong. If anything, the VC would transfer a fixed range of torque defined by the viscous character of the VC itself, varying within that fixed range by the relative speed difference.
In other words, the VC could transfer between 0 and x amount of torque--not percentages, period.

Well, if you say it transfers between 0 and X, and X is 30, then it works out, I think. 100ft*lbs to the diff. Diff splits it 50/50, 30 ftlbs of what is going to the rear, gets transfered through the VC. So you end up with 50+30 front (80), and 50-30 rear (20). When the both front and rear have traction and no diferentiation (asphault, straight line), the VC is doing nothing. It is transfering 0. The diff. is splitting 50/50. X, or 30, is the limit of what the VC is capable of. Anything from 0-x, would be where you have some traction or supported torque if you want to use that term, but in reality, since we're not stepping on the brakes to make it complicated, and we don't have electronic traction control on 80, all we really care about is traction, that's what's making you go forward, everything else is just paracidic (sp) losses. Anyway, between 0 and x is like you have one end in loose dirt and the other on asphault rather than one end on ice (or in the air) and the other on dirt.

I don't claim to be an expert, but I have managed to read enough to put in these terms that will hopefully help.
 
OK.
I'm 75% ready to say that I was wrong, but I still have a couple issues.

...
I WOULD appreciate it if you could find the time to help me get past my remaining questions, above.

Hayes

I actually think Heath now has a grasp of this completely.

Hayes, where I see you having some difficulty is in how the VC works. Think of it this way, 1 set of plates is attached to one axle, the other set of plates to the other axle. When there is slippage, the axles couple together allowing TRANSFER of torque from the slipping axle to the non slipping one. No speed differential between axles = open diff.

Hayes, for your presentation to be true, one side of the VC is attached to one axle, and the other must be attached to the housing of the transfer case. Now you can have the VC absorb the energy of that axle, raising total supported torque. But the VC isn't attached to the housing; as your drawing shows, it's attached to the other axle. So the VC only needs enough energy to lock up (read: very little, since it is *only* speed differential that locks up the VC), then torque will transfer to the opposing axle.

In EDL, the brake is attached to the chassis of the car (like if a VC was attached to the transfer case housing), it's not TRANSFERING torque, it's absorbing torque of the slipping axle. This raises total supported torque of both axles thru the center diff.

I apologize for presentation, I get that way over what are IMO basics of AWD operation. I normally nerd heavily in the Torsen Center Differential applications and chassis dynamics, where a lot of variables affect torque allocation.

That said, always good to go back to the basics of LSD's and lockers once in a while.

HTH

ST
 
Find exception with his blunt techie-talk if you want, but if you can get past giving grades for presentation you can learn something from him...assuming the goal is to learn.

Someone who truely understands how something works, does not need to hide behind 'techie-talk'. If someone disagrees or misunderstands cause he's over complicating things, his response is to complicate it more. Also, understanding that when I flip a switch a light bulb comes on is a far cry from claiming to be an expert on house wiring. Justifying I'm an expert on house wiring by explaining electron flow, subatomic particles, quarks, and string theory just shows I've read some articles and have memorized some neat words.


The guy has forgotten more about the internal workings of the Audi system and turbo stuff than most folks I have met who work on the stuff for a living know...

Maybe he should have forgot a little less since he claims to work on them for a living.

and knowing what a tech-nerd he is...I am banking on the fact that since he owns and wrenches on LC's, that system is well understood too.


Well, somehow he's managed to put his foot down that if you mount a radius arm 3" lower on the frame, it'll travel the same path relative to the frame as if it's in the stock location, so I'd rethink your banking practices.
 
Thanks.
and
Thanks.

SUMO, you've described exactly the realization I had after I drew the picture. I do see where my original understanding needed the VC anchored to the housing or something external.
I'm still no good on it transferring a percentage of the torque, rather than a fixed range of actual ft*lbs. I'm willing to live with that, though.

Heath, I sort-of follow your explanation, but I still don't get the VC responding to torque as opposed to speed differences.

Funny, that picture of the t-case is a picture of MY t-case. :)



OK.
We can euthanize this thread now.
 
My understanding hasn't changed a bit. All that's changed is your understanding of my understanding.

I believe if we insert your quotes back into post 1, your understanding has changed, and it's to agreement with how I have presented differential operation. You started at Hayes position, and accepted mine. Heath, I'm quite good with that:flipoff2:

I will continue to nit that Supported Axle Torque is more technically accurate than using the term "Traction". Especially when referring to a gear type center diff in a turn. Read: In a torsen, turning radius changes F/R axle torque allocation.

ST
 
I believe if we insert your quotes back into post 1, your understanding has changed, and it's to agreement with how I have presented differential operation. You started at Hayes position, and accepted mine. Heath, I'm quite good with that:flipoff2:

That's quite interesting cause I didn't hardly say a dang thing about differential operation, just a little about VC.


I will continue to nit that Supported Axle Torque is more technically accurate than using the term "Traction". Especially when referring to a gear type center diff in a turn. Read: In a torsen, turning radius changes F/R axle torque allocation.

ST

Thats fine, I'm not arguing it's not more technically accurate, it's just that the traction component is what we're usually worried about.

I also still understand that if you have open axles, and put one front and one rear tire in the air, and do nothing but put your foot on the gas, you have alot of tire spining, and no vehicle going...

:flipoff2:
 
Thats fine, I'm not arguing it's not more technically accurate, it's just that the traction component is what we're usually worried about.

Riddle: If you have a VC locked from spin up, and enter a turn onto dry pavement with the VC at 80%, isn't it possible to stay locked because of the turning radius speed differentiation, read: Not a traction component?

I also still understand that if you have open axles, and put one front and one rear tire in the air, and do nothing but put your foot on the gas, you have alot of tire spining, and no vehicle going...

Never disagreed with *that* statement.

Heath, I thank you for your support in helping Hayes 'get a grip' late in this thread. My best hope is that some of the information find a home as reference material here. Weeding through this thread, there appears to be a lot of misunderstanding of how diffs work.

:cheers:

ST
 
I'm still no good on it transferring a percentage of the torque, rather than a fixed range of actual ft*lbs. I'm willing to live with that, though.

Because the coupled axles aren't *locked*. Locked the axles can transfer 100% of torque to the other axle. Viscous Coupled, neither axle can support 100% of Trg, nor can you transfer 100% of torque to the other axle. Both axles can support a % of the other, ascribed by the SAE boys by TBR.

Heath, I sort-of follow your explanation, but I still don't get the VC responding to torque as opposed to speed differences.

Speed differentiation is what couples the diff. Torque can then be transferred. A VC doesn't respond to TORQUE in ANY WAY, it either transfers it when locked up, or it's not locked up.

The only LSD's that respond to torque is the Torsen, or the Quaife gear type LSD's. In this type LSD, all torque transfer has taken place before a axle (wheel) spins. The VC needs the axle (wheel) spin to accomplish coupling, then it can transfer torque.

HTH

ST
 
I believe if we insert your quotes back into post 1, your understanding has changed, and it's to agreement with how I have presented differential operation. You started at Hayes position, and accepted mine. Heath, I'm quite good with that:flipoff2:

Wow! You even know what other people are thinking?!
 
A VC doesn't respond to TORQUE in ANY WAY, it either transfers it when locked up, or it's not locked up.

OK, you're going to throw people off with that terminology - it's never locked up or not locked up. It's a fluid connection. If you use terms like locked up or not locked up, you're going to get people thinking it's like locking a diff. And don't go into humping the VC, that's also just going to confuse people.

edit: humm....

Because the coupled axles aren't *locked*.

Sumo, you can't say they aren't locked, then talk about it being locked. Being as though this is your passion, I'd think you'd be clearer in your explainations. I agree with the lower quote - since it's only coupled, it's not locked, and it can only transfer a portion of torque through a viscous medium, it's not locked.
 
Last edited:
Riddle: If you have a VC locked from spin up, and enter a turn onto dry pavement with the VC at 80%, isn't it possible to stay locked because of the turning radius speed differentiation, read: Not a traction component?

Well it's a bogus riddle for a few reasons:

1. VC's don't lock, they couple. Locking would indicate a solid connection. It's also why it's called a viscous coupler, not a viscous locker. I know you're a stickler for terminology.

2. I'm on dry pavement, the VC isn't going to be coupled anyway cause I'm in a 80 series and there is no way I have enough horsepower to get one driveshaft to spin faster than the other in a straight line.

3. If you read the part of the SAE paper I linked that is readable, you'll see that the turning radius speed differentiation is not enough to effect the VC.
 
Someone who truely understands how something works, does not need to hide behind 'techie-talk'. If someone disagrees or misunderstands cause he's over complicating things, his response is to complicate it more. Also, understanding that when I flip a switch a light bulb comes on is a far cry from claiming to be an expert on house wiring. Justifying I'm an expert on house wiring by explaining electron flow, subatomic particles, quarks, and string theory just shows I've read some articles and have memorized some neat words.




Maybe he should have forgot a little less since he claims to work on them for a living.




Well, somehow he's managed to put his foot down that if you mount a radius arm 3" lower on the frame, it'll travel the same path relative to the frame as if it's in the stock location, so I'd rethink your banking practices.


Heath, it is clear from this post and the one by LandTank earlier that I walked into the middle of a (probably long-term) pissing match. Imagine that, on the internet. :crybaby:

I am here to learn more about the stuff I own. From you, from Scott, from whomever is willing to share. I made an observation about a guy who has proven himself reliable in the advice he gives on the Audi system...that I am glad to find out now owns and wrenches on the LC too. Like what I say, hate what I say, all the same to me man.
 
Heath, it is clear . . . . that I walked into the middle of a (probably long-term) pissing match. Imagine that, on the internet. :crybaby:

I would say that is an accurate observation.
 
I made an observation about a guy who has proven himself reliable in the advice he gives on the Audi system

He's made it clear that he's awfully proud of his work on them as well. Unfortunately that doesn't carry any weight here when talking 80 series Land Cruisers.

You like his advice, then remove your crank bolt and install it hand tight with some locktite and drive around with the CDL engaged on dry pavement.

Let us know how that all works out.
 
He's made it clear that he's awfully proud of his work on them as well. Unfortunately that doesn't carry any weight here when talking 80 series Land Cruisers.

You like his advice, then remove your crank bolt and install it hand tight with some locktite and drive around with the CDL engaged on dry pavement.

Let us know how that all works out.

What happens if you drive around with the CDL engaged on dry pavement, LandTank? How soon will "it" happen...and will it happen every time?
 
Back
Top Bottom