I don’t think that reading a technical write-up on Torsen diffs and torque bias is necessary to discuss the distribution of torque in a straight-forward open diff backed up with what amounts to be a sort of viscous damper. I think you misunderstand my point. I really think that upon close examination, you can’t treat the VC in the HF2AV analogously to a locked diff with varying degrees of “locked” (as you suggest in post #26). Understanding this will demonstrate my point that the HF2AV should ALWAYS split torque 50/50 between the front and rear drive shafts—never 80/20 or any other ratio. Bear with me and address the following questions/descriptions:
OK
1. By itself, a classic differential gear with ring, pinion, and spider gears splits the incoming torque evenly (50/50) between the two output shafts/axles.
Defines an "open" differential
2. A locked diff isn’t a “diff.” The torque ratio is always ideal, up to 100% to one shaft because the two output shafts are effectively one shaft driven by the pinion.
Ideal only in a straight line. Can be much less than Ideal in a turn. I agree a locked diff and no diff are the same thing.
3. The “viscous coupler” in the HF2AV doesn’t actually couple anything—it just creates friction when there is differential motion between the front and rear drive shafts. “Viscous damper” is a more accurate description.
Actually, it does couple the axles, beyond 50/50, that defines a LSD device, and is also attributed a Torque Bias Ratio. ALL LSD's have a Torque Bias Ratio, it defines the limit of locking, even Quaifes and Torsen gear type LSD's. A plate type LSD is a viscous damper too, so is a electronic plate type. All have TBR's.
Now consider these three scenarios:
1. An open diff with no viscous damper. One output shaft effectively cannot support any torque because there is no traction at the wheels on that shaft (floating in the air or on a surface with zero mu, ignoring torque supported by rotational inertia and any friction inherent in the drive system). The net torque delivered to the two output shafts is effectively zero.
Open Differential
TBR = 1
1 x 0 = 0% of least axle torque to other axle
2. A locked diff under the same circumstances. Saying that the output shaft with zero traction cannot support any torque is not really accurate because that shaft is locked to the—and effectively the same—shaft that has traction and can support 100% of the available torque. The tranny is applying no force to the shaft with no traction. Hence the 100/0 distribution of torque between the two shafts.
Locked or no differential
TBR = infinity or (100% x potential Torque Ring Gear)
100% of least alxe torque to other axle
3. An open diff with a viscous damper (HF2AV) under the same circumstances. The differential wants to behave just like scenario #1. Fortunate for us, the VC provides resistance—a force that will support torque—to the axle with zero traction. Lets say the VC requires z ftlbs of torque to rotate—the axle can now support z ftlbs of torque (as opposed to zero). The other axle could support an infinite amount of torque, but because the available torque is transferred through the open diff, the total torque is limited to 2z...z ftlbs to one axle z ftlbs to the other.
Limited Slip Differential (torsen, Quaife, wet plate, electronic plate, haldex, VC)
TBR = 4:1
4 x least axle torque to other axle
3A. Scenario #3 is not the same as a “partially locked” diff. Assume the VC is “humped” and is effectively supporting infinite torque on that axle—the axle is totally “braked” and will not turn. The tranny HAS to apply force to that axle. It ALSO has to apply force to the axle with traction. It’s not applying zero torque to the “humped” axle and 100% to the other, it’s applying 50% to the humped side and 50% to the other side. Reconsider scenario #1. There is no force resisting rotation on the “tractionless” axle.
Hayes, I think you are hung up on VC heat. Heat only causes the locking effect, it's not the same as TBR. What is inside the HF2A could be wet plate, a torsen or a VC. With a "80%" locker, that LSD will have a 4:1 TBR regardless of LSD type. The torsen article I referenced should help. A VC LSD is no different than any other type of LSD in terms of how it works, and it's ascribed TBR.
The VC merely increases the supportable torque of the axle with the least supportable torque. It’s increasing the total torque that has to be split 50/50 through the diff.
I don't agree with these statements. The VC merely increases the supportable torque of the axle with the *most* supportable torque, which in turn increases Total Supported Torque of both axles. The amount of torque of the higher supported torque axle is defined by the Torque Bias Ratio of the LSD device, which is a torque multiplier of the axle with the least supported torque. The second sentence defines what EDL does and that's a different animal. Let's take a look at the EDL, since that's really what you are speaking to. EDL is an an open diff with a TBR = 1. Let's say the front axle can support 50lb/ft of torque.
OPEN DIFF
TBR = 1
1(TBR) x 50lb/ft Front = 50lb/ft Rear
TOTAL SUPPORTED TORQUE OF BOTH AXLES = 100lb/ft
TORQUE SPLIT = 50lb/ft Front and 50lb/ft Rear
OPEN DIFF (EDL)
TBR = 1
Electronically apply brakes to front axle (EDL) to generate 50lb/ft of braking force so front Axle now supports 100lb/ft (50lb/ft tractive + 50lb/ft Braking torque)
1(TBR) x 100lb/ft Front = 100lb/ft Rear
TOTAL SUPPORTED TORQUE OF BOTH AXLES = 200lb/ft
TORQUE SPLIT = 100lb/ft Front and 100lb/ft Rear
VC or LSD (80% locker)
Front Axle supports 50lb/ft of torque
TBR = 4:1
Rear Axle supports 200lb/ft of torque
TOTAL SUPPORTED TORQUE OF BOTH AXLES = 250lb/ft
TORQUE SPLIT = 50lb/ft Front and 200lb/ft Rear
Hayes, that's how TBR is defined with EDL vs a mechanical LSD device. With EDL torque to the axles is always 50/50 regardless of weight distribution and turning radius. With a 'locker' torque follows axle load or turning radius. With a LSD, torque follows axle load or turning radius up to the TBR.
This is all defined in the torsen white paper. VC, torsen, Clutchpack, electronic clutchpack, Haldex. All better than EDL for total supported torque IMO. The new technology combines EDL with a gear type (torsen/Quaife) LSD device, which I have quite successfully retrofitted (install rear torsen into stock rear EDL) in the Audis for several years now.
ST