How Center Diffs Work

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Jun 1, 2005
Threads
42
Messages
1,836
Location
Chicago
At Romer's request to not hijack another thread on the subject, I'll start a separate thread on some of the misunderstandings of how diffs work. It's come to my attention that some of the old terminology is getting more and more accepted regarding torque allocation in various differentials. I have done a lot of writing on this over the years, since my passion is vehicle dynamics of Torsen Center Differential AWD vehicles. I found in other forums and on referenced google quotes, that defining the operation of an open and locked diff was necessary before looking at limited slip and torsen applications.

I will copy a post from another thread to start this off. The biggest issue I see with our accepted definitions of open diffs, is they tend to simplify torque allocation to available traction, which isn't technically correct. In Post 2 copy, I have rewritten a couple of the simplified center diff definitions one finds on the internet, to be more technically correct.

The 80 with HF2AV has 2 center differential modes available: VC LSD or Locked. The HF2A has 2 center differential modes available: Locked and open . It's important to understand how these modes differ in terms of torque allocation. You will also find me very technically prickly about *how* we define torque from a center differential. Specifically, the over-use of "Traction" to define differential operation, when it's more technically correct to refer to supported torque of a given axle. This is especially key when speaking to an open diff with EDL, and/or using braking torque to unstick a wheel in the air, and/or understanding the VC vs Open vs Locked HF2A/V Center diff modes.

HTH

ST
 
Last edited:
Torque Flow From/To center differential

*** qoute deleted by Romer at originators request

That's not a technically correct statement IMO. In my PM to you, I gave the formula for the open diff as
T1 + T2 = Trg
T1 = Torque axle 1 (THE FRONT AXLE COMING OUT OF THE TRANFER CASE)
T2 = Torque axle 2 (THE REAR AXLE COMING OUT OF THE TRANSFER CASE)
Trg = Torque ring gear (THE RING GEAR IN THE TRANSFER CASE THAT SENDS TORQUE TO THE TWO AXLES)

I always use Torque RING GEAR because we have a variety of variables that affect what constitutes T1/T2 and Trg, specifically, engine output, throttle position, gearing, friction, traction, torque converter, and recently "equivelent traction" (ABS and/or Traction control). So a statement that it's 50% of what the *tires* can support isn't correct. You can have an open diff, with two tires in the air, apply the brakes (defines EDL) and increase Trg with the slipping tire supporting the exact same tractive torque force. Conversely, you can stick a open diff 80 in sand and have Trg=Teng, T1=T2 and have 100% 'traction' to each wheel. So 'traction' isn't a good way to speak to supported axle torque in a driveline.

*** qoute deleted by Romer at originators request


Neither is technically correct to an open diff vehicle Heath. I might rephrase #1 to read:

"Remember that the open differential always applies the same engine torque to both driveshafts, and the maximum amount of torque to both axles is limited to 2 times the axle with the lower supported torque"(sic)

In Diffs for dummies:
"An undesireable phenomenon with open diffs is that the drive exerted on both shafts is the same amount of that of the shaft (axle) with the least amount of total supported torque." (sic)

The terminology is off, and those definitions can't account for an EDL open diff or you putting your foot on the brake when a wheel spins. These "google definitions"also can't explain how an 80 stuck in sand has equal torque to both axles with 100% traction at all wheels (Note terminology with a torque converter: see why we need to use Trg instead of Teng?). We could go further and explore over the center axle EDL, but I believe the Torque Ring Gear is correct terminology as that's how SAE defines axle torque values and doesn't stick you with the 'given' Trg = Teng when you have a torque converter in between. And T1 and T2 can include EDL, friction, gearing, traction and all the other variables to TOTAL AXLE SUPPORTED TORQUE.

It is incorrect to claim Tire or traction, as EDL or braking intervention is not a dependent variable to *traction* or *tire*.

*** qoute deleted by Romer at originators request


Lock the center diff. Lift one rear tire, and one front tire. We can see that with 80 series either with the CDL switch, or by putting in low range CDL. Classic ditch crossing, or ramping on RTI ramp in loose ground. It takes 1 ft*lb to spin the rear tire in the air, and opposite rear tire gets 1 ft*lb. It takes 1 ft*lb to spin the front tire in the air, and opposite front tire gets 1 ft*lb. The vehicle doesn't move. [/quote]
Rephrased in the formula for an open center diff and open front and rear diffs....
T1 = (Tright front axle + T left front axle)
T1 = (10lb/ft + 10lb/ft)
T1 = 20lb/ft
T2 = (T right rear axle + T left rear axle)
T2 = (10lb/ft + 10lb/ft)
T2 = 20 lb/ft
T1 + T2 = Trg
20 + 20 = Trg
Trg = 40

Trg is exactly allocated 50% T1 and 50% T2 ALWAYS

*** qoute deleted by Romer at originators request

Not really. The definitions need to be changed, specifically TRACTION is not necessarily a variable to an open diff. Total supported axle torque is.

Heath, if we take an open diff axle and put one axle in the air with available engine torque at 260lb/ft, and you can generate 130lb with brake force, the torque to the other axle is 130lb/ft, even in mixed mu! The tire has the same *traction* and Trg = Teng!

This is how these concepts are presented in SAE papers. IMO, you have not presented an open diff operation technically correct (neither do a lot of other publications IMO/IME). Traction can be a variable to Trg. This concept doesn't require EDL, only putting your foot on the brake when you have a wheel in the air. BTDT many times in my 4R when wheeling.

Edit: I recently had a dyno run on a hub mounted 4 wheel dyno. No wheels or tires attached, and both the front and rear axles are in the air. 350WHP on an audi quattro with open center diff. Heath, using your terminology, that couldn't be done!

HTH


ST
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Add the VC, now what happens

From above, the formula for an open center diff and open front and rear diffs....
T1 = (Tright front axle + T left front axle)
T1 = (10lb/ft + 10lb/ft)
T1 = 20lb/ft
T2 = (T right rear axle + T left rear axle)
T2 = (10lb/ft + 10lb/ft)
T2 = 20 lb/ft
T1 + T2 = Trg
20 + 20 = Trg
Trg = 40

IN AN OPEN DIFF Trg is exactly allocated 50% T1 and 50% T2 ALWAYS
------------------------------
ADD VISCOUS COUPLER Torque Bias Ratio
Let's add the HF2AV Viscous Coupler to the center diff, and see what happens.... From my research the VC is considered a 80% locker (Humping it will go 100%, but that's a short term failure mode we will ignore for now). What this means is that 4 times the amount of torque supported by the axle with the least supported torque can be supported by the axle with the higher supported torque. The driveline boys refer to this as a Torque Bias Ratio (TBR) which is Defined as maximum /minimum supported torque of a given axle (80/20 = 4:1 TBR)

Let's work with the above equation and assume Trg = Teng = 40. If the front axle starts to spin, the VC will start to lock up, transfering up to 4 times the amount of torque supported by the front axle to the back axle, or vice versa

So the total torque available to either axle would be 80F/20R or 20R/80F. Which means that with a VC operating (front starting to spin), we have a maximum torque allocation of:

T1 = 8 lb/ft
T2 = (T1 * 4)= 32 lb/ft
Trg = T1 + T2 = 40
-------------------------------------------------------------------

TBR with an open diff (HF2A) is 1:1, and with a locked diff (HF2AV locked/HF2A locked) is Infinite TBR (= 100* Trg), usng the above formula and inputs front wheel spinning
OPEN DIFF 1:1 TBR we have the maximum torque allocation of:
T1 = 8 lb/ft
T2 = (T1 * 1)= 8 lb/ft
Trg = T1 + T2 = 16 lb/ft

LOCKED DIFF Infinite (100*Trg):1 TBR we have a maximum torque allocation of:
T1 = 0
T2 = "up to" (Trg * 100)
Trg = T1 + T2 = 40


ST
 
Last edited:
The 80 with HF2AV has 3 center differential modes available: Open, Locked, VC LSD.

Actually only two modes are available, open with viscous coupler (acting as a LSD) & locked. You can not have open without Viscous coupler unless you remove it. Feel free to modify your first post and then delete this. Just wanted to make sure people don't go looking for that third mode.
 
I asked Scott to start a new thread to eliminate the hi-jack of the other thread with the back and forth discussion. Discuss and argue your points here, just keep it civil.
 
SPEAK IN ENGLISH :grinpimp:
 
I think I'm in over my head.
 
SPEAK IN ENGLISH :grinpimp:

As this isn't my first foray into this topic, I'll try to dig up some of the information and drawings I did on this topic that 'might' help. For the above "T's" you only have to know that T1 is the front driveshaft coming off the transfer case, and T2 is the rear driveshaft coming off the transfer case. Trg is the Torque at the Ring Gear in the Transfer case.

In plain english, you only have to know that traction is a*A*component variable of axle torque in an open diff, it's not *THE* component variable of axle torque in an open diff.

HTH

ST
 
I am always looking for something to read and this will take up a bit of it. Read, re-read, re-read
 
There is a massive difference between torque and work. This thread does nothing to address that mightly confusing point for people. In fact, I'm getting the feeling it's participants don't fully understand the implications either.

Prove me wrong.
 
What? Me no understandy :frown:
 
There is a massive difference between torque and work. This thread does nothing to address that mightly confusing point for people. In fact, I'm getting the feeling it's participants don't fully understand the implications either.

Prove me wrong.

Excellent point and you are *absolutely* right! My corrections to the definitions of the open diff quotes above is becasue axle torque values in an open center diff can be applied regardless of WORK = TRACTION. IOW, an 80 trapped in sand can have Trg = Teng 'max', T1=T2, and have no wheels spinning (work), and traction to each wheel is 100%. IMO, we define work as either motion or travel = Traction. Work *can be* a component of Trg totals of supported axle torque, it's not required. And the googled definitions of Torque in Post 2 are incorrect because of that. We can have Trg = Teng with no work (traction). Work or no work, doesn't change the allocation of torque to the open center diff, it's always
T1 + T2 = Trg
T1=T2

I remember reading a pretty good summary from RavenTai a couple months back on some of this....

ST
 
Last edited:
Lemme see if I can paraphrase SUMO's tech-talk into practical layman terms for the potential benefit to myself and others...

It seems that one point of conflict that SUMO has is the typical talk of "traction" and torque. I believe that he is trying to say that the torque available to the front or rear drive shafts (in the case of the center diff), or left or right axle shafts (in the case of front or rear diffs) is technically dependent upon the minimum torque supported by the ring gear.

The maximum available total torque is the torque required to rotate the ring gear. This can be affected by wheel traction, but ultimately depends on the torque required to rotate either shaft/axle. This includes forces independent of wheel traction: Forces transmitted through the brakes and other frictional forces such as those transmitted by the viscous coupler. I guess the sheer rotational inertia of the axle/wheel would also count. Wheel traction affects it the same way, but I think SUMO is trying to show that traction should really be considered as a force external to the system(?)

Braking during wheel spin and friction generated by differential motion in the viscous coupler increase the minimum torque required to rotate the ring gear, which increases the total torque delivered to the system (ring gear, then split equally between the shafts/axles).

The viscous coupler acts like a brake on the spinning drive shaft increases the torque required to keep that shaft spinning, increasing the torque to the other shaft by the same amount (up to a limit defined by the characteristics of the viscous coupler).

No?
Yes?

Hayes
 
Lemme see if I can paraphrase SUMO's tech-talk into practical layman terms for the potential benefit to myself and others...

It seems that one point of conflict that SUMO has is the typical talk of "traction" and torque. I believe that he is trying to say that the torque available to the front or rear drive shafts (in the case of the center diff), or left or right axle shafts (in the case of front or rear diffs) is technically dependent upon the minimum torque supported by the ring gear.

The maximum available total torque is the torque required to rotate the ring gear. This can be affected by wheel traction, but ultimately depends on the torque required to rotate either shaft/axle. This includes forces independent of wheel traction: Forces transmitted through the brakes and other frictional forces such as those transmitted by the viscous coupler. I guess the sheer rotational inertia of the axle/wheel would also count. Wheel traction affects it the same way, but I think SUMO is trying to show that traction should really be considered as a force external to the system(?)

Braking during wheel spin and friction generated by differential motion in the viscous coupler increase the minimum torque required to rotate the ring gear, which increases the total torque delivered to the system (ring gear, then split equally between the shafts/axles).

The viscous coupler acts like a brake on the spinning drive shaft increases the torque required to keep that shaft spinning, increasing the torque to the other shaft by the same amount (up to a limit defined by the characteristics of the viscous coupler).

No?
Yes?

Hayes

I say conditional yes. Traction isn't 'external' it's just a work component to the sum total of T1 (total supported axle torque). It's a component of T1 torque value as much as friction, torque converter, gearing, throttle, etc. The main reason we use Torque at the Ring Gear, is that in the real world Torque Ring Gear (Trg) is NEVER equal to Torque Engine (Teng). There are a few torque MULTIPLIERS (gears in transmission) that make that impossible. That's one of the reasons I liked RT's 'potential torque' concept he presented a few months ago. Put simply T1 + T2 <can not ever equal> Teng.
T1 + T2 = Trg - ALWAYS
T1 + T2 <not equal> Teng - ALWAYS
So, technically Teng <not equal> Trg

I have for demonstration purposes of 'supported axle torque' in all the above posts, I used Trg = Teng as a given. We know it never can be. In any 'drive' mode, Trg > Teng

Somewhere I have a very long formula that lists what values are included in T1, T2 and Trg. Remember too, that there is another 4.11 multiplier and a wheel circumference correction factor (effective gear ratio change) before T1 and T2 see "traction" or 4 individual wheel values. Again, I'm trying to come at this more simply at first. I have a couple years of posts on this already in a Torsen AWD forum.

ST
 
Last edited:
Could you post an application statement on the advanteages of a center diff with VC (as opposed to T, Teng, etc.) - I believe this is the layman's package we are looking for.
 
Could you post an application statement on the advanteages of a center diff with VC (as opposed to T, Teng, etc.) - I believe this is the layman's package we are looking for.
I can try. The formulas seem complicated but they really aren't. Let me *way* oversimplify them and try this. Assume the engine generates 300lb/ft of torque (no multipliers or other factors). In an open diff 150lb/ft would go to the front axle, and 150lb/ft would go to the rear. Let's then say the front wheels start to lose traction. so that the front axle can only support 50lb/ft of torque. Let's say for arguments sake the rears are on pavement.

OPEN DIFF 1:1 TBR we have the maximum torque allocation of:
Torque Front Axle = 50 lb/ft
Torque to the Rear Axle = (T1 * 1)= 50 lb/ft
Trg = T1 + T2 = 100lb/ft

With an Open Differential the most power you can put to the ground is 100lb/ft
-----------------------------------------
VC DIFF: Torque can go 80 front/20 rear or 80 rear 20 front
4:1 TBR
Same scenario, front wheels slip so the front axle can only support 50lb/ft of torque

Torque Front Axle = 50 lb/ft
Torque Rear Axle = (T1 * 4)= 200 lb/ft
Trg = T1 + T2 = 250lb/ft

With a VC Differential the most power you can put to the ground is 250lb/ft
-------------------------------------------

LOCKED DIFF Infinite ((100*Trg)-T1):1 TBR we have a maximum torque allocation of:
Torque Front Axle = 50lb/ft
Torque Rear Axle = ((Engine Torque * 100) - 50) = 250lb/ft
Trg = T1 + T2 = 300

With a Locked Differential the most power you can put to the ground is 300lb/ft

A bit oversimplified, but it shows the comparative differences of the 3 differential modes.

HTH

ST
 
Last edited:
SUMO,

Is the 80/20 split idea an accurate way to understand the VC?

I was under the impression that the torque split was 50/50 ALL THE TIME--the torque is split at the differential itself. The viscous coupler merely serves to increase the torque (through friction) supported by the axle that is losing traction, thereby increasing the torque delivered to the other axle.

Torque split is still 50/50.

I think unequal torque split applies to vehicles where the viscous coupler IS the differential between the front and rear axles--like some car AWD systems without actual mechanically geared center differentials.

I'm not sure the 80/20 thing applies to the 80 series. The torque is split 50/50 by the mechanically geared center diff, and the VC limits slip by raising the minimum torque supported by any axle.

Hayes
 
SUMO,
Is the 80/20 split idea an accurate way to understand the VC?

I think so.

I was under the impression that the torque split was 50/50 ALL THE TIME--the torque is split at the differential itself. The viscous coupler merely serves to increase the torque (through friction) supported by the axle that is losing traction, thereby increasing the torque delivered to the other axle.

It's an LSD device, not a coupler. LSD devices use TBR. It doesn't matter what the 'resting' state is. I actually first attempted to use 3 modes for the center diff to help with this. Christo requested 2 (VC with open diff/ Locked diff), but there are 3 states since VC isn't immediate. That said, LSD devices don't have a time limit only a Torque Bias Ratio.

Torque split is still 50/50.

Only during resting state (no VC intervention). During VC intervention front rear axle torque can be split up to 80/20 front rear or 20/80 front rear. That defines a Limited Sllip Device. A Locked diff or Spooler means axle torque can be supported up to 100/0 front rear or 0/100 Front rear.

I think unequal torque split applies to vehicles where the viscous coupler IS the differential between the front and rear axles--like some car AWD systems without actual mechanically geared center differentials.

A viscous coupler is EITHER a Coupler or it's attached as an LSD to a Differential. In the 80 it is attached to the differential so it's a LSD device. Hayes, you could put a 80% clutchpack in there and do the same thing as the VC. LSD devices are defined in terms of TBR or as a % locker. The engineers just consider a "80% locker" to have a 4:1 Torque Bias Ratio. Which means either axle is capable of supporting 80% of the available Ring Gear Torque.

I'm not sure the 80/20 thing applies to the 80 series. The torque is split 50/50 by the mechanically geared center diff, and the VC limits slip by raising the minimum torque supported by any axle.
Hayes

Since the 80 will "hump" (go 100% lockup, I've done it, but it's considered a failure mode), I just presume it to be a standard issue 80% locking VC in Normal Operation.

ST
 
Last edited:
Hey all -

I'm not going to post about this topic, but what I am going to post is what I sent Sumo in a PM.

'I'm glad you've started your own thread to pontificate all you want. I'm not going to post to it. As such, and since you're starting a new thread, I'd appreciate it if you showed me the courtesy of not quoting posts of mine from other threads. It puts them out of context. If you have an opinion on how you think differentials work in the real world, go right ahead and throw it out there. But do it without me, or my quotes please.

Thanks,

Heath"

I figured if he's starting his own thread, he could do it on his own, and not drag me into it. Since he has chosen not to remove his quoting of me. I'll just say this -

All above quotes are taken out of context. The fact that I refuse to continue to discuss this with someone like Sumo, does not mean that I believe any of what he says. It only means I'm tired of having my words twisted, and simple ideas convoluted by someone trying to over technospeak it.

If he'd had the courtesy to respect my simple request (I even said please and thank you). I wouldn't have felt the need to post this.
 
Back
Top Bottom