Do you use first gear?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Well I guess I could spend more time over in the 25 section but being lazy and an opportunist I’ll just ping herein. And it is about the topic sort of anyway...

@Splangy the 25’s don’t have hi/lo gearing in 4wd? Just a single gear?
 
Well I guess I could spend more time over in the 25 section but being lazy and an opportunist I’ll just ping herein. And it is about the topic sort of anyway...

@Splangy the 25’s don’t have hi/lo gearing in 4wd? Just a single gear?

Correct. Just 2wd/4wd. No low range. First gear is something silly like 7:1 so that helps.
 
View attachment 1975114

Never use 1st on street. Typically 2nd even on upslope ..... 3rd if downslope. 350 with sm465 running 35s and 3.70s. Drives easy!
I assume your referring to Lo as 1st? I have the same equipment. Every time my wife pulls a tight corner in 3rd(1:1), I have to fight the urge to explain why that isn’t remotely ok. Transmissions are cheaper than lawyers.
 
Even with a synchronized 4 speed - my truck generally decides when it does or doesn’t want to be in first gear. I’d say 20-30% of the time from a stop, I have to hit the clutch a couple times for the shifter to drop into first. Sometime I have to shift to second, then first. If it’s being stubborn sometimes I have no choice but to start in 2nd, but when I DO have a choice - I start in 1st

If you do not plan on repairing or replacing your transmission I would learn how to double clutch.


Correct. Just 2wd/4wd. No low range. First gear is something silly like 7:1 so that helps.

It's only about 5.40:1. SM420 is much lower.
 
1st for me every time unless I am pointed downhill on a good slope. Hate to spend money and time on new clutch, engine, etc.
 
If you do not plan on repairing or replacing your transmission I would learn how to double clutch

It is on the list of things to fix - Just debating if I want to pony up for a 5-speed/split case conversion or just find another 4 speed to rebuild in advance of pulling my current one to minimize down-time.
 
When I ran the stk 40 trans with a SBC, it really depended on the situation I was in, but most of the time I started in 2nd. I think trying to compare starting in 1st with the stk 40 trans and starting in 1st gear with sm465/420, are really pointless.
 
It all depends on the situation of course, but generally my FJ60 with the stock 3.7 diffs, and stock tire size with the H42, I always start in first, it will go in 2nd, but it lugs it some. I find the 1st gear ratio in the H42 just a tad high even in low range at times, but it makes for a really nice street transmission. My 40, with 4.11 and stock tires with the original J30 3speed was annoyingly high geared in first, but from a rolling start it would pull 2nd. I have since put in an H41 with the lower 1st and it is a tad low, 2nd gear starts are very possible with it, but I still prefer to get rolling in 1st to save clutch wear. My T100 with the 5 speed also prefers a 1st gear start, it falls just a tad lower than an H42. In all cases if there is a grade involved, seems 1st is pretty much necessary.

Ford truck of the 80's had a granny low, I learned to start in 2nd with those. Of course my dads truck had the 460, so it would start in about any gear with that monster. I was surprised and embarrassed when I got in a female friends 75 FJ40 as a teenager and could not get going easily in 2nd, I just thought all 4 speeds had a granny low like the Fords I was used to. Here I thought I knew alot about Cruisers, she told it had to be in 1st.

The GM 4 speeds are granny 1st monsters too, but I have been really happy on the trails with the H41 and the 1F, gives a great crawl ratio with the factory 3 speed transfer. Not as happy on the highway, with 1st being lower, 2 and 3 are also a tad lower and it runs out of revs in 3rd while climbing hills on the highway, put it back in 4th and the 1F falls on its face, the FJ60 will pull to a higher speed in 3rd and will sometimes maintain better in 4th too, just better power from the late 2F engines.
 
Roll starts in 2nd to avoid the bucking from roll starts in 1st. Otherwise

H42-start in 1st
H41-start in 2nd

4:11s and 33s

BTW, maybe I’m just getting forgetful, but I don’t think anyone has asked this question before.

That’s refreshing.
 
So this is semi related back to my original post on this thread - how difficult is it supposed to be to get a synchronized 4-speed into first gear? I occasionally have a lack of “mesh” and a lock out even on my 2009 Mazda, but it seems quite a bit more frequent in the H42. I also feel like spooling up the synchros to mesh on almost any downshift is a particularly slow and noisy affair. I’ve never been certain if this was a normal phenomenon of an “old slow truck transmission” or if my transmission is worn/tired.

I saw this post and thought maybe it was considered “normal” but it seems like the jury is split.
 
Last edited:
So this is semi related back to my original post on this thread - how difficult is it supposed to be to get a synchronized 4-speed into first gear? I occasionally have a lack of “mesh” and a lock out even on my 2009 Mazda, but it seems quite a bit more frequent in the H42. I also feel like spooling up the synchros to mesh on almost any downshift is a particularly slow and noisy affair. I’ve never been certain if this was a normal phenomenon of an “old slow truck transmission” or if my transmission is worn/tired.

I saw this post and thought maybe it was considered “normal” but it seems like the jury is split.

Rick

If an H42 doesn’t want to make a clean downshift into first, something is wrong. In my experience, it is one of four things. One: binding of the pilot bearing/ bushing which does not let the input shaft ‘spool down’ when the disc is disengaged from the flywheel. Two: inadequate disengagement of the disc because of inadequate movement of the throwout bearing. Three: improper clearance between the input and output shafts not fully releasing the 3rd or 4th gear synchros. Four: failing 1st/2nd synchros.

Because it is a synchronization symptom, people are quick to diagnose the 1st/2ndsynchro. Too quick IMO.
 
Rick

If an H42 doesn’t want to make a clean downshift into first, something is wrong. In my experience, it is one of four things. One: binding of the pilot bearing/ bushing which does not let the input shaft ‘spool down’ when the disc is disengaged from the flywheel. Two: inadequate disengagement of the disc because of inadequate movement of the throwout bearing. Three: improper clearance between the input and output shafts not fully releasing the 3rd or 4th gear synchros. Four: failing 1st/2nd synchros.

Because it is a synchronization symptom, people are quick to diagnose the 1st/2ndsynchro. Too quick IMO.

Good to know - clutch is brand new, as is the pilot bearing, but I have some input bearing noise in neutral so maybe some clearances are off. I had the transmission open last year and I didn’t see anything obviously wrong with the synchros but I am also not a particularly well-trained eye.

Does the fact it routinely doesn’t want to shift into first gear at a stop without rocking or pumping the clutch point to any of these? Perhaps the “not enough clutch movement” issue? I guess I could try inching the throw-out bearing a bit closer to the pressure plate but it’s already pretty darn close (maybe 1/8” or less).
 
What sliders are those?
Gr8Pmkn, they are custom built sliders. I will send detail pic tomorrow. The foot steps are bolt on for my wife. She’s to small to easily climb in. Ran step on her side only until I became tired of being asked did I know that my side had fallen off.
 
I find starting in first with my H41, 1F and 235/85R16 tires (32") to be easier on the clutch at 6500 feet. It will do it, but it takes some flare, and risks a stall in a quick get up and go scenario. Rolling starts, no problem though. My favorite part over the 3speed is the synchronized first, I never did get the feel of double clutching 1st on that tranny, maybe 1 out of 10 would be successful.

On the clutch and grinding shift issue, not only check the throwout bearing clearance and arm, but get the clutch pedal and master rod clearance just right.

I was having trouble with my T100, it has always been kind of a short throw on the pedal. The clutch pedal bracket was prone to failure on those trucks and mine had been replaced prior to purchase 10 years ago. Finally it was getting really bad lately, so I looked into the pedal adjustment. Turns out the pedal was over an inch too low when measured from the floor board, thus making clutch operation incorrect. Throw in 150K miles of additional clutch wear and things just weren't disengaging properly. Re-set pedal height and freeplay and it is like a new truck, who would have thought the tech messed that up so long ago, as I know it was done at a dealer. I feared my tranny was dyeing a slow death at 262K miles. I had similar issues with my 40 a few years ago, both with the clutch pedal and brakes, dialed in the pedal movements and both improved drastically.
 
Back
Top Bottom