Ragman's SOA about complete

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

dmaddox said:
Have done the SR in the past. No benefit.

http://www.ih8mud.com/tech/shackle-reason.php

Yes, ride was smoothed out "a little" but in my opinion - no benefit reversing the shackles. I have also tested this and done the math. Look at my shackles - there is no way for my axle to go forward. I have lifted it all the way up, and let it droop all the way down. The difference was about 1/16th of an inch.

I appreciate the comments! Thanks Troll/Bigndn..

ragman


Well, I guess to each his own, right? I, on the other hand, felt like there was a huge difference in ride quality from the SR. If you're only talking about articulation numbers, then you're right, there isn't a significance between the two.
 
dmaddox said:
Have done the SR in the past. No benefit.

http://www.ih8mud.com/tech/shackle-reason.php

Yes, ride was smoothed out "a little" but in my opinion - no benefit reversing the shackles. I have also tested this and done the math. Look at my shackles - there is no way for my axle to go forward. I have lifted it all the way up, and let it droop all the way down. The difference was about 1/16th of an inch.

I appreciate the comments! Thanks Troll/Bigndn..

ragman

Even though I have great respect for Jim C with anything to do with Carbs, I think he is off on this one. I was on the LCML when this post was made. There wasn't a consensus. Many other people (Jack Rice, Mudrak, Danny Warden to name a few) feel that SR is the way to go.

Here's the thing -- If SR is wrong, why did Toyota change to SR on the Mini's? IF toyota thought it was better for the shackle in hte front, why did Toyota move it to the back in 1979 for the Minis?

THE biggest advantage with SR is the big improvement in approach angle. Having the shackles in front is like adding curb feelers. They're just known as rock finders now.

Not sure what your point is about the axle going forward?

Now, if rocks aren't your worry, then it's not a big deal.

Looks good though. Nice work on everything.
 
woooody said:
Even though I have great respect for Jim C with anything to do with Carbs, I think he is off on this one. I was on the LCML when this post was made. There wasn't a consensus. Many other people (Jack Rice, Mudrak, Danny Warden to name a few) feel that SR is the way to go.

Here's the thing -- If SR is wrong, why did Toyota change to SR on the Mini's? IF toyota thought it was better for the shackle in hte front, why did Toyota move it to the back in 1979 for the Minis?

THE biggest advantage with SR is the big improvement in approach angle. Having the shackles in front is like adding curb feelers. They're just known as rock finders now.

Not sure what your point is about the axle going forward?

Now, if rocks aren't your worry, then it's not a big deal.

Looks good though. Nice work on everything.


On the other hand

Why didn't Toyota put the shackles at the back for the FJ60? FJ62?
 
woooody said:
Even though I have great respect for Jim C with anything to do with Carbs, I think he is off on this one. I was on the LCML when this post was made. There wasn't a consensus. Many other people (Jack Rice, Mudrak, Danny Warden to name a few) feel that SR is the way to go.

Here's the thing -- If SR is wrong, why did Toyota change to SR on the Mini's? IF toyota thought it was better for the shackle in hte front, why did Toyota move it to the back in 1979 for the Minis?

THE biggest advantage with SR is the big improvement in approach angle. Having the shackles in front is like adding curb feelers. They're just known as rock finders now.

Not sure what your point is about the axle going forward?

Now, if rocks aren't your worry, then it's not a big deal.

Looks good though. Nice work on everything.

Go back and re-read Jim's post. He specifically was referring to the stock Land Cruiser suspension geometry, with a small, but nominal arch in the springs. Then go look at a 79-85 mini or 84-85 runner with stock suspension. No arch to the springs. Brand new, they were nearly flat on the dealer's lot. Older trucks (okay they're all old) will have inverted springs.

To answer your specific question, "Why did Toyota move to the back in 1979 for the minis?", the answer is, the same reason they went to IFS in 1986, and coils in 1991. On-road comfort and handling. Their approach to S/R for the mini and runner was completely different than ours, because it was for different reasons.

I think we can all agree that the LCAH approach make for even worse rock-finders than a properly done custom S/R. But I think Dallas has done well with the angle on his shackles and should see good ride and handling, as well as good articulation off road. With the shackle angle he has chosen, I doubt he'll be finding many more rocks than if he had done a low-profile S/R, and as Jim pointed out in his post, he'll have the fixed end of the spring at a much beefier part of the frame.

At the end of the day, I believe driver skill trumps minor variances to modification approach in who gets up the trail, who has to be strapped, and who breaks something.

Happy cruisin'!
 
excellent post Jeff. Thanks for the compliments.

You know, I say in regards to SR, to each his own. Hell, I am testing right? If I am bashing rocks and wrecking things, I may do a reversal. But in the same respect, the approach angle thing? That big ass perch thing you have to weld on (which most people put on backwards anyway) is no better than the photo's above.

To each his own, that's part of the hobby. It is a constant R&D lab in my garage.

Now, back to the garage....

Cheers,

Ragman
 
Back
Top Bottom