Need help choosing a tire

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 31, 2014
Threads
94
Messages
928
Location
IL
It's been awhile since I've been on here. I took the 80 to a trail about an hour and a half from me today. It was a complete muddy mess (mainly what we have in the midwest). I currently have 315 General Grabbers and they're awful. Zero traction in mud. I ended up leaving after a couple of hours because I could not do anything but get stuck. Being locked I was surprised how poorly the 80 performed. The grabbers were like sleds. I am not sure if I am going to stick with 35's or jump up to 37's. Either way what do you guys recommend for a good mud tire that will also perform in snow, sand and rock? I really like pitbull rockers or Super Swamper tsl.
 
Either way what do you guys recommend for a good mud tire that will also perform in snow, sand and rock?.

there is no good mud in the snow.
there are some that are better than others, but none are good.
 
I am running the Pro Comp Xtreme MT2s. They perform surprisingly well in the sand and do a great job in the rocks. They are not the most aggressive mud tire out there but do a good job in the little bit of mud I have been in. I wish the sidewalls had a little more bite. I almost pulled the trigger on the Goodyear MTs which have very good reviews in the mud but I saved about $350 for these vs the GY. Tough to pass these up when I have had some good experience with the previous MT1s, and these are a bit more aggressive than those were. I understand the pit bulls are LOUSY on road.

One other thing, these will never be great mud rigs, too heavy and lack power to really spin the bigger tires and help them self clean.

One other item, buy what you like. You are about to get 3 dozen different opinions on tires. There is no ideal or perfect tire, every one of them is a compromise. Find one that you are happiest living with, go with it, and don't look back.

PCT75031_a.jpg
PCT75031_c.jpg
 
@Nay has always wrote highly of the Swamper TruXus tires... did I spell that correctly, well any ways, he said they did awesome in the snow & they have a skinny tread width that helps with bite & have spies for ice. Give him a PM. Just hit this link @Nay it might take a couple day for him to respond...
mn6f1lxdq0stqj_sm.webp
 
@Nay has always wrote highly of the Swamper TruXus tires... did I spell that correctly, well any ways, he said they did awesome in the snow & they have a skinny tread width that helps with bite & have spies for ice. Give him a PM. Just hit this link @Nay it might take a couple day for him to respond...
I had a set of 32" TruXus on an Isuzu Trooper. They were not much quieter on the road than BFG M/T tires. I didn't find anything that they did well. They weren't terrible at anything, but I won't buy them again. I think my next tires will be Goodyear Duratracks, but they aren't a great mud tire, so a poor choice for you. If you ONLY care about mud performance, Super Swamper Boggers are a top pick.
 
Either way what do you guys recommend for a good mud tire that will also perform in snow, sand and rock?

IMO no such thing as a tyre that will perform well in mud AND sand. Mud you need the tyre to bite down, and with sand it is better to 'float' over the surface with as little breaking through as possible. For competitions here they dig holes in fields and fill with water, the mud tyres then get to work, take the same vehicle on the beach (regular weekend occurrence) and unless the sand is very wet the mud tyres just dig holes, AT's are better on sand, you pay's your money and take's your choice IMO.

regards

Dave
 
I just took my Grabbers through mud for the first time last weekend, and didn't have much trouble.

The Jeeps I was with had mud tires and appeared to be having more difficulties than I was.

No idea why that is. The Grabbers "seemed" to just suck mud into the tread and look like they were slicks, but for whatever reason, my rig just kept chugging forward in the bogs.
 
Cooper STT's. I live in Florida, lots of sand(obviously) and mud. At recommended pressure they are very good. Air down and they are damn near unstoppable. Tough as nails, great road manners and they last a really long time.
 
Avoid sharp rocks to the sidewall and the duratracs are a pretty great compromise tire if you need winter capability. I don't think they make larger than 35's though. Other place to look is Cooper... their new MTP tire (available at discount only) should be OK in the winter yet is pretty aggressive, others are the S/T Maxx and STT Pro.
 
Which grabber do you have?

How's your vehicle primarily driven? Tires are a compromise. What do you want it to be good at? If you want it to be good at Mud, it's not gonna excel many other areas.

That said, I think you have like two "tiers" of mud tires. Your normal ones, and then your swampers.

This weekend, I had my KM2s out and they did great even looking like this.

image.webp
 
@Nay has always wrote highly of the Swamper TruXus tires... did I spell that correctly, well any ways, he said they did awesome in the snow & they have a skinny tread width that helps with bite & have spies for ice. Give him a PM. Just hit this link @Nay it might take a couple day for him to respond...
View attachment 1224682
i'll second the trxus. i loved them on the marshmallow and when i went to 315s i would've gone back to them, but that was when they had the whole fire/moving crap going on and you couldn't find tsl tires to save your life, so i went duratrac.
 
Back
Top Bottom