cruiser vs cj

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Mar 8, 2005
Threads
2
Messages
14
Location
Sugar Hill
im new to the land cruiser world...i was wondering what the differences were btw the fj40s and the jeep cj's....

ride on road:
ride off road:
parts/work on:
reliability:
cheapest?:
value:

thanks for any help! :)
 
cjeep said:
im new to the land cruiser world...i was wondering what the differences were btw the fj40s and the jeep cj's....

ride on road:
ride off road:
parts/work on:
reliability:
cheapest?:
value:

thanks for any help! :)

Never driven a CJ, but I once had a Wrangler Sahara, so I will compare to that:

Ride on the road : Wrangler more comfortable with more highway speed.

Ride off the road: Lower torque of 2F (FJ40) provides much more capable vehicle.

Parts/work/on: FJ40 parts area available and its easy to work on. Axles are stronger and are less likely to break.

Reliability: FJ40 wins IMOP. Had a friend who bought a CJ and he worked on it constantly and it barely ran. Wrangler was OK, but that was a 2 year vehicle compared to my 28 year old vehicle. When you buy an FJ40, you will need to do maintentance to bring it up to snuff. Once you do that, you shouldn't have any issues as long as you don't buy one with a dying engine.

Cheapest: You can get a decent FJ40 for about $4000.

Value: My 28 year old FJ40 appraised at $13K (For insurance - not sale). You see ones that are in great shape selling in the $10K and even $20K range in certain markets.

Lots of threads on buying an FJ40, use the search function.

Another great thing about cruisers are the people that drive them :D
 
cjeep said:
im new to the land cruiser world...i was wondering what the differences were btw the fj40s and the jeep cj's....:)

ride on road: About the same both are short wheelbase with fairly stiff springs

ride off road: Comprable, i vote FJ bacause you donh have to worry about braking dana 20 axle shafts or u-joints

parts/work on: AMC sucks to work on Period. FJs are engineered in a way that makes sence which is alot more than you can say for a CJ.

Parts: Parts are just as easy to find eaither way. As long as you know where to look (just ask here) you can find anything that you need.

reliability: FJ. Its made by a company that still exists.

cheapest?: about the same FJ because it is a toyota and they hold there value forever because they are well made and the people that know what they are are willing to pay for what they get. CJs are artificaily expensive bacause they say "JEEP" on the side

value: see above

thanks for any help! :)[/QUOTE]
 
FJ v. CJ

Some Jeep drivetrain parts are usually not as strong. Jeep refuses to put good components together. Like will use a Dana 300 w/ a T5. Kind of stupid. That being said the Jeep straight six engines are just as good and I will say better than the 2F. My old 258 has plenty of torque and runs fine on the road and at angles. Anyone who has to work on a Jeep all the time doesn't know how to fix it. They are as simple as a FJ and are not broken all the time unless you are a dumbass who abuses things beyond belief. The FJ is certainly beefier in most ways. But, to your typical person it usually doesn't matter. I may get my ass kicked for this but I think the FJ40 looks horrible without a top whereas a Jeep looks like it shoud be that way. An FJ40 with a top on it is a great looking rig though. That is of course personal preference. Get either one and learn to fix it. The Jeep is easier. Both are worth more to dumb people than they should be...
 
Jeeps are tin cans on wheels. I had a friend in highschool who had a '86 YJ on 31s, and it was a POS from the factory. He was out playing in a construction site when his stock sheetmetal shackle snapped in two, and when he got out to look at it, he noticed the rear diff was leaking oil from the middle of the cover. A tooth had broken off the ring gear and had wedged itself between the gear and the cover, puncturing the cover. This is in terrain that was the equivilent to driving in a hilly field, and he was very gentle with it (sold it and bought a '86 mini).
Thier driveshafts and u-joints are junk, the axles are weak, they had some decent transfercases (D300) some of the trannys are crap (peugeot) and there are too many engine choices. No consistancy, other than junk. The same goes for ownership over the years.
 
86 Yj.

76-86 were CJ's to my knowledge. I am sure a tin can is a tin can to you no matter if you can remember the years or not. It is important to remember that not everyone lives in a location that requires the FJ axles, etc. A jeep is fine for most people. I struggle with people who have the mine is better than yours mentality. Particularly when they are talking tinker toy CJ's and FJ's. If you need something for serious work rather than play then neither is worth a damn.
 
I have not been too impressed with my buddie's '82 CJ. True, he did get kind of screwed in his buy, as the seller knew of some problems that he was hiding just long enough to sell it. But the thing is, my buddy has put just as much money as he originally bought it for in new axles, new engine, fuel injection kit, transmission, and various other interior parts. And that's what I don't understand. Whenever something goes wrong with a factory Jeep product (say the Dana 30 rear axle (I think)) you have to upgrade to like a Dana 44 or 60 because it's not worth it to put in another factory AMC axle. Same goes with at least my buddie's transmission (put in a T-19) and he's even considering putting a different engine in it, even though he just got a fuel injection kit because the factory carburetor was no good in the first place. But as far as I can see with the FJs if something breaks there is no problem with replacing it with the same thing. 2F for 2F, axle for axle, transmission for transmission etc. Again I know this might be a limited case, but it sure hasn't impressed me a bit. Drove my FJ40 for 7 hours at highway speed the day I bought it, so just that I could do that it makes mine better than his lol (no flaming please, just playing)
 
75pinz said:
76-86 were CJ's to my knowledge. I am sure a tin can is a tin can to you no matter if you can remember the years or not. It is important to remember that not everyone lives in a location that requires the FJ axles, etc. A jeep is fine for most people. I struggle with people who have the mine is better than yours mentality. Particularly when they are talking tinker toy CJ's and FJ's. If you need something for serious work rather than play then neither is worth a damn.

So you're an Pinzgauer owner and yours is way better than either right :rolleyes:

Bottom line - people who own both will either drive them forever in stock condition on moderate terrain and love them to death - or they will mod them with all the aftermarket parts thier wallets can handle and still love them to death.

As a starting point getting into either vehicle line and using it for its intended purpose of getting outside and getting it dirty is ultimately good for owners of either brand. Being a mall poser in either one is no good - don't be a pussy.
 
I had a '72 CJ5 and a "84 CJ7. They were fun rigs, but required a lot of attention. The life span on components just seems short. There aren't many 25-30 year old, 200K mile Jeeps that haven't had the engine, tranny or both rebuilt.

There are lots of Cruisers that make it well past that.
 
Having owned both i must say fj is much more durable ,had 85 cj7 rebuilt the engine then the t5 trans blew ,not rebuildable new was $1200.00 , then had to rebuild transfer ,then couldnt pass smog ,installed mopar fuel injection $2000,
then rear axle lunched, $700. sold vehicle because fuel injection had way to much torque couldnt give it throttle slow enought not to snap something off road. now own fj 40 has much stronger parts (althow cost twice as much) most 40 parts come apart and are rebuildable with orginal parts, seems heep parts are throw away and for me didnt last, :doh: only thing good about heep was it came with power steering and air :cheers:
 
I sold the Pinz due to me being a pussy about paying for parts...That being said it never broke really. Just the paranoia of having to but a portal or something directly from Austria was too scary. I currently have a M35a2 for serious stuff and a "new" 52 M37 for the rest, plus a CJ7 and a FJ60. I don't know why I have this urge to defend the other brands on a Toyota forum. Sick i guess...but I own many brands and see positives and negatives to each. The FJ60 that I have is worse on fuel than my 14K pound m35 for instance and it would fit int he back. That's just ridiculous.
 
I'd like to see this thread on a j**p forum ;)
 
My family grew up on Jeeps...and before I fully moved to the right side...CJ's are DEFININETLY not = to FJ...I don't care what you say...the only edge they have is aftermarket availability...

#1 Engine while the 258 is a great engine...come on Carter BBD carb is the biggest POS on the planet...find a good working one...they don't run right at all..ever...so you instantly have to fight or upgrade the whole fuel situation....with mine I chose the newer 4.0L and it ran great...but at how much money??? 3,000.00 done by myself...and I have yet to see large claims of 258's runnig past 150K mileage...how many F's and 2F's pass that???

#2 Axles...junk...AMC20 if a pos 2 piece design that mine broke with stock 30" tires and a tired old 258...crap...so you either have to put a single axle kit in $350 or upgrade to a new axle...and the Dana 30 up front...TURD...

#4 Suspension...less than a 1/4 ton rating...rides like crap...unless you change springs to new YJ styles...rides worse than most 40's...

#5 Frame...that frame will twist if you pick it up alone on the ground...CJ's were notorious for cracking frames...bent frames with little to no effort...

#6 Tranny....T-4 T-5 total junk...barely holds up under a tired 258...they did use a T-98 with a granny gear...for what...1 year? 2 years? big deal...

#7 Transfer...in the 80's they got it right dana 300...

#9 body is just chincy as hell...rusts just like the FJ's but it's sooo thin...


Cj's are used becuase they made so damn many of them...every damn farmer has one...dirt cheap...and the aftermarket is so huge and cheap for them...i will never own a cheap ass jeep again...a bunch of cobbled up cheap parts that break and don't work well together....someone needs pics of the two side by side...you'll see exactly what I'm talking about..
 
fuuny to me

how mad people can get over a jeep. funny, sick, whatever. Jeeps cost a bit less than a Cruiser. Also, Toyota decided not to sell anything like a FJ40 quite awhile back. Why don't we compare the new FJ to a TJ? Get a grip. FJ's are cool but there are bigger "toys" out there. I think I would like to get my hands on a nissan patrol if anyone knows where one is in the midwest.
 
75pinz said:
how mad people can get over a jeep. funny, sick, whatever. Jeeps cost a bit less than a Cruiser. Also, Toyota decided not to sell anything like a FJ40 quite awhile back. Why don't we compare the new FJ to a TJ? Get a grip. FJ's are cool but there are bigger "toys" out there. I think I would like to get my hands on a nissan patrol if anyone knows where one is in the midwest.

there are a few near my house in utah. ones grey ones blue
 
75pinz said:
76-86 were CJ's to my knowledge. I am sure a tin can is a tin can to you no matter if you can remember the years or not. It is important to remember that not everyone lives in a location that requires the FJ axles, etc. A jeep is fine for most people. I struggle with people who have the mine is better than yours mentality. Particularly when they are talking tinker toy CJ's and FJ's. If you need something for serious work rather than play then neither is worth a damn.

A CJ is worse than a wrangler, I'm sorry that I mixed up a turd with a turd. The only decent jeeps ever produced were the M715 and the original imitation Willys. Even over those I'd take a Mitsubishi J53 before I bought the "real" thing.

As for the better than yours mentaility, I quote David Dearborne:

"I am an elitist; I drive Land Cruisers"

And as for serious work, a Cruiser is a damn fine compromise between dedicated workhorse and driveability.

For Partols, talk to Ian at http://www.rmp-o.com

Edit: this has all be hashed out here: https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=32536
 
Last edited:
75pinz said:
how mad people can get over a jeep. funny, sick, whatever. Jeeps cost a bit less than a Cruiser. Also, Toyota decided not to sell anything like a FJ40 quite awhile back. Why don't we compare the new FJ to a TJ? Get a grip. FJ's are cool but there are bigger "toys" out there. I think I would like to get my hands on a nissan patrol if anyone knows where one is in the midwest.

So what is your point???? You come asking opinions and we give them...but then you try and talk us out of the opinions...feels like I'm married to you :rolleyes:

FJ to TJ...only a 15 plus year time span....did we forget land cruisers were factory locked and coil sprung first??? oh yea...forgot about that one.... :rolleyes:

Jeeps are cheaper to build...you can't throw a dead hooker miss a jeep....they are everywhere...and they have such quality...all those nice Stainless accessories :princess: and if you are talking "building" then you are saying...lets go to the junkyard...swap chevy or 1 ton in so I can run 35's... :rolleyes:


I do applaud jeep for still making a solid axle SWB vehicle...i still will never own one.

bigger toys out there??? what does that mean??? We don't choose LC's because they are the biggest toys...if you think aftermarket sucks for Toyota...good luck with Patrols...
 
75pinz said:
how mad people can get over a jeep. funny, sick, whatever. Jeeps cost a bit less than a Cruiser. Also, Toyota decided not to sell anything like a FJ40 quite awhile back. Why don't we compare the new FJ to a TJ? Get a grip. FJ's are cool but there are bigger "toys" out there. I think I would like to get my hands on a nissan patrol if anyone knows where one is in the midwest.
Get on the Nissan boards, there are a few Patrols out there. They are cool vehicles built with heavy duty parts. However parts are a bit harder to get ahold of compare to FJ40,60 parts.

I have owned a 1953 Jeep, a 1968 Jeep Wagoneer, a 1976 CJ5 Renegade, and a 1986 CJ7. Of the four only the 1953 was worth a crap. (Though I did like the power the 304 V8 in the 76 delivered). I now own a Cruiser and can tell you: The Jeeps rode better but other than that you can have them.

I also have owned Nissan 4x4's for over 12 years, 2 Pathfinders, a 5 sp 1991 XE that my wife totaled with 186,00 on the stock motor and my current 5 sp 1995 XE with 138,000 also stock and a 2000 Xterra SE auto (wife drives it). Nissan builds great vehicles. Change the oil, replace the timing belt when due and they will last just as long as any F or 2F motor. I wheeled the crap out of the Xterra until I did some body damage and the wife said " Fix that green piece of crap under the tarp (My FJ40). You are not damaging my truck anymore. Sure honey.... two years later and I'm still working on it....
 
I didn't ask for anyone's opinion that I can rememer. Someone else did. Anyway, the m715's are where my military truck obsession started. I now think the m715 is an answer to a question that should not have been asked but they are still cooler than a Wrangler. I think everyone is misunderstanding me. I own or have owned many cool 4x4s. (6x6 as well) anyway, I daily drive a 60 that I was going to sell but the guy decided he didn't want it. Don't freak out because the toyota is just a box of nuts and bolts like a Jeep. It isn't like you are going to hurt it's feelings. It's a tool. Like a complicated shovel. There are all different kinds of shovels. As far as bigger toys go I meant like a unimog. By the way, I have had three Cherokees make it over 200k with little issue. Don't see too many CJ's or FJ's with that kind of mileage. Probably cause the suck to ride in. My m37 is 53 years old and only has like 9000 miles. My 60 has 180k with a rebuilt motor.
 
Back
Top Bottom