winch or lockers?

What is the superior mod, winch or lockers?

  • winch

    Votes: 61 37.7%
  • lockers

    Votes: 101 62.3%

  • Total voters
    162

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

When I bought the FJ40, the places I could go increased with the rear locker. It made difficult hills easy. Wheeling the LX450 on Moab was like butter due to lockers.

The assumption I made is that you would have another rig with you, then Lockers are more important because you could tow or get towed out.

If you are wheeling alone, you need both.
 
Maybe these will help. I have 33's and 2.5 inch lift, no lockers, no winch :o
cullowhee carnage 12_2005 050 (Small).webp
cullowhee carnage 12_2005 051 (Small).webp
cullowhee carnage 12_2005 095 (Small).webp
 
Pic #1 & #2 - tires are too small.

Pic #3 - Need lockers badly.

Those pics don't suggest the need for a winch....they suggest that you are finding the limits of your current setup and you're going to be spending some extra $$$ in the near future if you want to keep hitting those kind of trails.

That looks like 4.88's, lockers, and 315's to me...

Nay
 
Last edited:
lockers. they will make a major difference in your ability to wheel, and you will find that you rarely use a winch..usually strapping to another rig is just as easy and much faster.
 
Get the winch first.

Plenty of folks wheel their rig open. In the case with your diffs hung up, what you really need is a better spotter or to at least start listening to the sounds your truck is making.
 
nuclearlemon said:
lockers. they will make a major difference in your ability to wheel, and you will find that you rarely use a winch..usually strapping to another rig is just as easy and much faster.
My view is he'd learn more about wheeling by keeping it open.
 
Nay said:
Pic #1 & #2 - tires are too small.

Pic #3 - Need lockers badly.

Those pics don't suggest the need for a winch....they suggest that you are finding the limits of your current setup and you're going to be spending some extra $$$ in the near future if you want to keep hitting those kind of trails.

That looks like 4.88's, lockers, and 315's to me...

Nay


And when he reaches the limits of that setup, then what? Stuck again.

Every time he exceeds the limits of the vehicle (regardless of how its equipped), is a time he will wish he had a winch.
 
Junk said:
Get the winch first.

Plenty of folks wheel their rig open. In the case with your diffs hung up, what you really need is a better spotter or to at least start listening to the sounds your truck is making.


I was listening, and she was saying, gas it and go, gas it and go!!!

I'm voting winch because in the case of this weekend, there were two vehicles, but in several cases we almost had both vehicles stuck. Two stuck trucks can't pull the other out. It's not that we didn't know how to drive, it's tough when it's dark and you are on a narrow mountain side trail just wide enough for one rig and several hundred feet drop-off on the side driving around a corner into a huge rutted 50 yard long mud hole. I got halfway in before i got stuck and we almost got the other rig stuck trying to get to me to pull me out.
 
I think junk has a good point about keeping the truck open for now so you can learn how it works a little better. Plus, because you'll need a front bumper in order to do a winch, you'll be protecting that front-end alot more than the stock bumper is going to do in any sort of an accident. Based on the amount of threads in the last few months with guys messing up their 80's, i'd tend to lean back to an ARB and winch.

Then again, I'm aware a single battery can power a winch but there is always a chance that you could kill the battery in a heavy winching situation, isnt there? Which may leave you wanting dual batts, and thats not super cheap.
 
Last edited:
Junk said:
Get the winch first.

Plenty of folks wheel their rig open. In the case with your diffs hung up, what you really need is a better spotter or to at least start listening to the sounds your truck is making.

Oh sure, listen to the guy from Jersey then the two in Colorado:flipoff2:

How high are the mountains in Jersey?

Just kidding - I got the winch first and the locker second. I have not used the winch, it was easier to have a strap on another vehicle. The locker gave me more wheeling ability on my rig. The same trail I had difficulty with the year before, was no issue now.
 
can learn to wheel just as well with a selectable locker as you can with no locker. :flipoff2:

i've had my winch for three years. i've used it once, to tie off to a tree while someone else dragged my 60's butt back onto the trail, and three times to tow dead rigs up my driveway. coulda pushed them, but cruisers aren't light and i'm lazy.

oh yeah, used it to pull a few fence posts once also
 
flintknapper said:
And when he reaches the limits of that setup, then what? Stuck again.

Every time he exceeds the limits of the vehicle (regardless of how its equipped), is a time he will wish he had a winch.

I agree. If you build a more capable rig you will reach the limits and get stuck again. I think that is pretty much the definition of technical fourwheeling.

A winch is a great thing, and I'll add one at some point, but it is in no way a substitute for a properly built rig. Wheeling open is fine, I did it for years, but you have to recognize that differential locking and extraction techniques are not opposite sides of the same coin, which is why the question doesn't make much sense.

Anybody who looks at those pics and answers "winch" has a lot more time to spend on the trail than I do.

Nay
 
Nay said:
I agree. If you build a more capable rig you will reach the limits and get stuck again. Nay


Its a foregone conclusion that at some point you'll get stuck (if you do much "wheeling"). So, the only question is: How do you plan to get out?

Most of us, are slowly building up our rigs to make them more trail worthy, even so....unexpected things happen on the trail. Ideally, he should have both a winch and lockers, and then drive judiciously.

If his main purpose is to wheel his vehicle on moderate trails with other capable rigs in attendance, then perhaps lockers would serve him well. If his chief complaint is that he had a difficult time getting unstuck... then I say winch, because you're going to get stuck at some point, or someone else is going to.

I am not proposing that he take an under built vehicle on the toughest trail he can find, and then use the winch to drag himself through the entire thing. This seems to be a point you are stuck on (pardon the pun).

IMO, for overall usefullness (when things have gone bad), you'll be glad you got the winch.
 
I voted winch. Lockers will get you further but also twice as stuck. If you wheel alone a winch or at least a high lift jack (along with rigging) should be standard equipment! Looking at the pictures it does appear that lockers would have gotten through those situations but the false security of more traction would prompt you into a worse stuck in a situation you wouldn't get into without lockers. Even if you had cell coverage and called or even flagged down another vehicle if they didn't have lockers and you did they probably couldn't get back to you to be of much help anyway.
 
I think it all depends on where you wheel. In your case it seems you hit some mud and stuff where a winch would be more nessesary. A lot of the people on here out west would say lockers because usually they can make there way through or backwards by stacking rocks and using a hi jack lift or something. So if I was in your shoes I say get the winch first. But of course the lockers need to come after that.
 
In your case I would go for a winch. It will save the day when needed. But, I think experience and driving technic will prevent you from needing either.

In the case of the wheel in the ice, lockers would get you out, but a Jackall could have done the same thing. Jack up the wheel and fill the hole with rocks / lumber, set the truck back down, and drive out.

In the mud, it's difficult to say but you need a liberal dosage of momentum, wheel spin, and steering wheel sawing from left to right. Mud is tricky with such a weight pig. Once you're high centred, you're screwed! The momentum will have gotten you stuck farther along then you can back out. So no traction in reverse. You need to ask yourself if you are past the point of no return, because going back may be worse then going forward.

Anywhere with exsesive mud, you need a winch. Even if you have a TireIron setup, you'll just get stuck in deep mud ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom