winch or lockers?

What is the superior mod, winch or lockers?

  • winch

    Votes: 61 37.7%
  • lockers

    Votes: 101 62.3%

  • Total voters
    162

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

For your conditions and experience, it works for you. I've used my lockers countless times, but never the winch. I bought it after getting stuck once by a suprise mud hole (driving along on a damp forest road when suddenly 'Suprise! You're in a mudhole!'). I suspect it might be years before I need it again, but the lockers are used nearly every time out. If I'd not been alone that one time, I wouldn't have been stuck for long anyway- I got out via strap and some jack-n-stack work (after calling for a rescue. :D) IMO, winches are necessary if you want to run solo or 4+ rated trails, but merely a convenience if you run moderate to medium trails in a group. I didn't see anything in those pics that couldn't have been solved with a strap.

-Spike
 
I didn't see anything in those pics that couldn't have been solved with a strap.

-Spike

So you expect the FJ from behind me to pull me backwards with a strap, or float over me to get in front and pull me out from the front? Cyber wheeler!! :flipoff2:
 
A)- You didn't mention you were leading (who the hell allowed that to happen? :flipoff2:).

B) Yeah, from the pics it looks like he could have pulled you back, if that was your only option.

C) From the pics, it looks like you could get an H1 by your driver's side to pull you forwards, and

D) I might scratch my truck if I actually took it on a trail, so cyber wheeling seems like the safe way to go. :flipoff2: :flipoff2:

In all the runs I've gone on with Copper State Cruisers in the last few years, we have never- not once- used a winch. Then again, we don't have mud here. The decision on what mods to make in what order is very dependant on the driver, terrain, and credit rating.

-Spike
 
I voted winch: lockers are great -- I recommend them. But once you're stuck, lockers aren't going to get you un-stuck. Ask me how I know. :rolleyes:
 
Winch....Jason's came in handy for turning me around near the bald when I found out how sturdy my wiring harness was.
 
haha, all good points fellas. I still am a winch believer. You are not always going to have someone with you with skillz, a well positioned truck or a cell phone to get you out of trouble. A winch will 99.9999% of the time. THE END
 
my 2 colones
Since the word "budget" came up a lot I think that you could look at it like this:

Start with a hand winch. It is least expensive option and will pull you out of more of the situations in the pictures than a front-mounted winch. The hand winch can be carried in any vehicle, doesn't require extra batteries, and can use as much wire as you choose to carry. Also you can pull backwards or sideways. Which is nice. At some later point, it can be used in conjunction with a vehicle-mounted winch if you decide to do that.

Then get a rear locker, it'll keep you out of some of the situations and help you get unstuck on your own.
A rear selectable locker has no down side other than $. It is a pure improvement. You get a stronger carrier. No change in daily driving. Better traction when needed. Virtually no extra weight. If you get an ARB you are also forced to get a slow, but useable source of air for tires.

Then get a front winch. You can mount it on a winch plate, not a full-on bumper. Winch has the down side of adding a lot of front weight. Especially if you get a bumper and spare battery(ies). So you may need some suspension modification there.

From there you can decide to get a bumper, high-po alt, extra battery(ies), front locker, etc etc

I've put a lot of miles on some pretty bad back-roads, often alone. Most of the time , the rear locker was enough to get me out. Sometimes I'd drag the hilift out to winch out backwards. Whenever I did that, I was really sorry I didn't have the Black Rat hand winch that we used to have (if I ever catch a thief in my gear, he's going to be crippled). I've never had success winching backwards w/ my electric winch. I was usually stuck in a way that prevented passing the winch line back under the axles.

I have rarely winched forward to get unstuck.

I have frequently winched other people out.
 
I voted winch: lockers are great -- I recommend them. But once you're stuck, lockers aren't going to get you un-stuck. Ask me how I know. :rolleyes:

:confused::confused::confused: My lockers have gotten me unstuck dozens of times.:steer:

My winch is still in its box. Someday it will help weigh the front of the truck down.:meh:
 
don't forget the little pleasures of having lockers: I've had several situations where I've parked on soft ground, then come back later to find that the left side of my cruiser was in gooopy mud. With a locker, I just flip the switches and drive out. Sure, a winch would also work, but I'd feel silly winching out of a residential neighborhood.

Same thing applies if you deal with sand at all.... winch isn't very helpful, lockers are.
 
sure, in a desert like Arizona with no mud. :flipoff2:

Bingo. Your answer depends on your conditions.

Generally a good idea to have both, but in the Southwest going winch first just means you're going to use your winch in places where the locked guys cruise through. Might as well drive an FJC while you're at it :flipoff2:
 
:confused::confused::confused: My lockers have gotten me unstuck dozens of times.:steer:

Okay, I'll tell on myself here. :hillbilly: A few months ago I managed, through a little carelessness, to get my 80 mired in a mudhole, up to the axle in the front, and almost that bad in the rear. It was really stupid because I wasn't even "wheeling" but just doing some work on our property. This is in the woods - the ground actually looked solid on the surface but underneath was deep mud. There's a very small spring at that spot that keeps the ground soft, which I forgot. The cruiser wasn't wearing the MTs that day, just the OEM Michelins. I locked up all three diff locks, to no avail. All I did was dig myself deeper into the hole.

You could say that's a bad example because of the tires I was using, or because of the goofball behind the wheel. But it still illustrates the point that if none of your wheels has sufficient traction -- for whatever reason -- there is nothing magical about locking the diffs. It still won't get you out.

Of course, if I had known I was about to plunge into deep mud, I would have locked up prior to entering the hole and that might have allowed me to drive through without losing momentum. (Actually I would have avoided it altogether because I really do H8MUD :D ) I definitely believe in lockers...but I wished I had a winch that day.
 
I have to follow the "where you are" attitude. In high-country Arizona, we rarely see real deep mud. The land is steep and the water runs off. We do see lots of ice in season. Snow falls at night, thaws in the daytime, and turns into a skating rink the next night!
(Note that I have factory lockers and a winch.)
Lockers can be a bit dicey if overused. On ice, I have seen places where they would have caused me to get into trouble. In slippery conditions, the diffs need to work up to where too much traction is lost. If the muck is really slick, (or the ice has water on top like here), lockers will only get you in deeper when you are already in trouble.
The only time that I have been badly stuck was on a sheet of ice at a 30 degree down angle with water running down the hill. Use of even one locker would have sent the truck over the cliff!
My neighbor has a cool set-up. He mounted his winch on a 2" receiver tube. He has a hitch on each end of the truck, with big plugs like on a tow truck. He can mount the winch where it is needed, and stow it in the garage when it's not needed. Wish I had thought of that!
I have used my lockers quite a bit on realitively dry ground. I have never used the winch off road. It is for stretching fences and pulling down buildings. From the pics, it looks like you have a lack of dry ground. The ideal would be a rear locker and a front/rear winch as above. If the budget won't allow this, given your mucky conditions, I would use a winch while saving for a locker. In the dryer climate here, I would say just the opposite.
Tip; Harbor Freight Tools sells a 10,000lb winch for $399 when it's on sale. (Which is often) It's not a Warn, but it pulls great, and the price puts you a lot closer to the locker! They are online.
 
:hhmm: What PSI were you running in your tires when you slid off the rock? I've been on some slick rocks in NC before (god, they are slick :eek:) and the one time I got shot off like this was because my front right wheel broke traction b/c it started slipping and got all the power, never catching again. I'm pretty confident if I'd had my front locked and a few PSI less in my tires I wouldn't have even noticed it unhook in the first place :doh:
 
Back
Top Bottom