winch or lockers?

What is the superior mod, winch or lockers?

  • winch

    Votes: 61 37.7%
  • lockers

    Votes: 101 62.3%

  • Total voters
    162

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

That is a lot of mud. It's making me lean more towards the winch. Lockers do not help much where both wheels have equally bad traction.

If you are short of cash, an M8000 is cheap and it will do the job 99% of the time. Just for reference-I have an M12000, and like Ige, I've used it for real 3 times in 4 years. One of those times was in bottomless low traction snow, where all the locker action in the world made no difference. Without the winch, that day, we would have spent the winter up on the approach to the Rubicon trail. So yes, when you need it, you really need it.
 
Winch....

I might add a rear ARB at some point in time, but for the expedition style wheeling I do, a winch has always been the first mod to a vehicle.

So far, anytime I've been stuck (mostly in the snow)...I'm glad to have the winch, as the lockers wouldn't have done much good but make both tires spin, or crab me further into a ditch....

-H-
 
flintknapper said:
I am not proposing that he take an under built vehicle on the toughest trail he can find, and then use the winch to drag himself through the entire thing. This seems to be a point you are stuck on (pardon the pun)

Please forgive me the bias. I've been stuck more than once on the trail for hours watching just that. It's fun watching a group with all of the bling bling accessories at the bottom of two major, loose, mogul hills in each direction. Can't go forward, can't go back. It's like putting 3 or four gerbils in a mixing bowl.

Now I hope somebody has a winch next time I really get stuck :grinpimp:

Nay
 
i think a winch would be the best thing to get first, a locker will get you further, and maybe further into trouble, a winch will always get you out of trouble.
 
cptmud said:
i think a winch would be the best thing to get first, a locker will get you further, and maybe further into trouble, a winch will always get you out of trouble.


I agree. I have wheeled those trails for 8 years and never had lockers. I have wheeled the same trails with guys with lockers who have had to use their winch to get them out of mud holes. I am not a novice wheeler, i feel i can hold my own. Back me up here cruiser4life!!
 
In my 5 years of wheelin probably 30 weekends a year, I've only needed a winch once, and that's cause I was 'wheelin alone in a precarious spot doing something really stupid for being alone. Other than that, another rig and a tow strap has always worked.

My rig is equipped w/ the factory lockers and I typically wheel open for the added challenge. Wheelin locked is like cheating most of the time I think, at least on most of the trails we run around here. This enables me to use the lockers as a recovery device.

Another thing to consider is to get the lockers and a hi-lift which I'm surprised no one has mentioned yet. Although not the ideal recovery device, for $40 it's hard to beat. In the ruts pictured you could have jacked the truck up and shifted it to the side or shoved logs under the tires or something. It can also be used as a poor-man's winch. Although not ideal, it works and can work very well with some patience.

So yeah, I vote lockers, then winch.

Ary
 
Howdy Concrete, Looks like you were having some fun! I vote, ARB winch bumper and a Warn 12000 lb winch and maybe at least go with a group 31 (I thnk that's the super duper large size) yellow top or equivilant battery or go with duals.

Some friends of mine were up hunting outside of Steamboat Springs Co when they came upon a boggy area and quickly buried their F250 powerstroke Ford 4x4. They called their Dad to come pull them out with his F250 powerstroke Ford 4x4. He pullled up behind them before they were able to tell him to stay back and now he was sitting on his frame as well. They had to call a local guy that has a Unimog and winch to come pull them both out, and it cost them a $1000 for the pull. A winch would have paid for itself that day easily. Now if they had been in Land Cruisers anyway, they probably would haven't gotten stuck seeing how Land Cruisers rule!

You can always throw in a Aussie locker in the rear for about $250 or so. The ARB bumper will pay for itself if you ever hit a deer or small little import cars. Just wash the blood or little car paint off the bumper and your good to go.
 
since i'm from your area and most of these guys aren't you forgot to mention we do not have mud in nc remember

WE HAVE GREASY CLAY THAT LOOKS LIKE MUD

i've wheeled with about anything and everything out here and lockers do help but in our type of "mud" lockers don't mean squat

i've got a blazer with 38's and 450hp locked and it gets stopped plenty because the "mud" clog's the tires therefore you're gettin 000% traction

now multiply 000% x2 (open diffs)= 000%
now multiply 000% x4 (locked)= 000%

get my drift......

winch brotha winch

also another good note you can make millions pullin people out in the ice storms we get, me and my friend about payed for his winch in 4 days pullin people out at $40-50 bucks a pop in ashville 2 years ago (tell them it's 100-150 for the tow truck and it's gonna take the tow truck a while to get there too!!)

sorry so long but i feel i can relate better being close in nc:D
 
k5ryannc said:
also another good note you can make millions pullin people out in the ice storms we get, me and my friend about payed for his winch in 4 days pullin people out at $40-50 bucks a pop in ashville 2 years ago (tell them it's 100-150 for the tow truck and it's gonna take the tow truck a while to get there too!!)

sorry so long but i feel i can relate better being close in nc:D


Thanks. I agree with you.

I have been thinking about that ice storm thing. I know that my old roomy in college had a big K5 blazer and had a winch on it. He made $300 pulling college idiots out of ditches and back up onto the road during ice storms. So you may be onto something there. I figure i could at least pay for the ARB to mount the winch in with recovery money. :idea:
 
how soon are you planning on getting the combo i kinda have a hookup and if we buy together we might be able to work some more with the price?

options, options ,options.........:crybaby:

where are you at i work in charlotte and live in maiden
 
I'd vote winch but hydraulic not electric if it's a backup plan. Slower than electric but no dual batterys to mess with or uprated alternators etc. I've a TJM OX powered from the PS pump on mine and sometimes people laugh at how slow it is but they soon stop laughing when electrical gremlins leave them stranded and mine just goes on and on. Maybe it's the weather over here but about 1 in every 3 times I see someone try to use their once in a blue moon electric winch it's dead for some reason.

If $$$ are an issue get a good hand winch. There have been times I can't rig the power winch for the direction of pull needed and the hand winch pulls any direction there's an anchor point. If I could only have the power winch OR the hand winch as backup I'd take the hand winch for its flexibility.

Maybe you could get a hand winch & lockers :grinpimp:

Jon.
 
I've said it before...a hydralic or PTO winch won't work unless your sitting right side up.

But the hand winch will and more often than not I'm right side up when I need the winch anyway. Hydraulic is much more reliable than electric IMHO based on what I've seen of recreational winch setups.

Jon.
 
wildsmith said:
Hydraulic is much more reliable than electric IMHO based on what I've seen of recreational winch setups.Jon.

Only if you have a good PS pump, PS oil cooler etc .. so if you need to use your Hydro winch and turning your front tires and with traction .. let me see ..
 
concretejungle said:
I agree. I have wheeled those trails for 8 years and never had lockers. I have wheeled the same trails with guys with lockers who have had to use their winch to get them out of mud holes. I am not a novice wheeler, i feel i can hold my own. Back me up here cruiser4life!!

Sorry dude, been gone for a while and still catching up on threads...

Concrete certainly isn't a wheeling noob (read - not some moron scooting up the trail into obvious trouble) - he's got skills on the trails and his rig is def capable. However, being open AND no winch certainly limits anyone in certain situations.

It's a tough question and if finances weren't involved, I am sure most of us would have both!!

Winch for extraction seems more necessary in this particular environment. The whole "lockers are only going to make your rig more capable, get you further and make you more stuck eventually" argument is sound.

Though given your appetite for challenging lines on the trail, it would be more fun to watch your 80 conquer obstacles with at least a part time rear locker...

Go sell some real estate and get both, plus a Slee 6" lift with 5.29's, 35's and you'll be set!! :grinpimp:
 
While new to my 'cruiser and this forum, I'm not new to 4-Wheeling. In the either/or situation this thread was started on, A winch would definitely to be the best choice. I've seen more idiots stuck with lockers than I have seen stuck running open diffs. VERY few idiots stuck with winches. That being said, most of the idiots stuck with winches would have been better served with some driving edumacation. Also, a winch bumper and winch are easier to install by yourself than lockers. Grab a hand winch to suck you back PRN(thats as needed to you non-medical personnel). Another route would be receivers in your bumpers, and a winch mounted on a receiver tongue. The wiring is a little more elaborate, but this route is much more versatile. Also, lockers can take you out on a sidehill, and a winch can save your :censor:. Just my dos centavos, or is that dos cervesas?:cheers:
 
East and west wheeling are two different animals. I've done both.

Lockers in the west. There usually aren't any trees where you wheel anyway.

Winch in the east where you have lots of mud and trees. I've seen some locked rigs slam trees on muddy trails very hard, whereas the unlocked rigs just kept slinging mud and went through clean.

I used to have a locked up 60 and did all kinds of harry stuff. Now that I'm older, an unlocked rig with a winch works just fine.
 
all you die hard locker fans, here is another prime example of why i would choose a winch over lockers. This is the same trail that triggered my post and question a few years ago. Well, it got me again. (Pics in this thread: https://forum.ih8mud.com/nc-olde-north-state-cruisers/238728-whee.html )

Hit that little rock in the middle of the trail with my LF tire. It just shot me off to the right and onto a rotten log, that gave way. Lockers wouldn't have done crap in this case, just spun tires.

Winch saved my butt.

So, my vote still goes to a winch first.
 
Back
Top Bottom