winch or lockers?

What is the superior mod, winch or lockers?

  • winch

    Votes: 61 37.7%
  • lockers

    Votes: 101 62.3%

  • Total voters
    162

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Oct 27, 2003
Threads
490
Messages
9,929
Location
North Cadillac
After this past weekends wheelin' expedition https://forum.ih8mud.com/showthread.php?t=73235

i really started to think about the importance of modifications. Now, if you were lucky enough to purchase an 80 with lockers, well, you are ahead of the game and i guess this poll doesn't pertain to you as much. Never-the-less, i got stuck pretty dang well twice over the weekend.

First time it was dark, 10:30 pm, freezing cold, about 5,000 feet elevation, middle of nowhere way up in the mountains. Nearest house was probably a 3 hour hike back down and i'm not really sure it would have been safe to knock on the door and ask for help (think deliverance here). I got stuck in the middle of a muddy trail sitting on my front and rear diffs. My friend was following me and he got his Tacoma stuck right behind me. He wasn't too bad stuck, so we cut some wood up and started stuffing it under his tires. Got him out, and then he tugged me back and out of the mud. Wasn't easy at all. In this case i'm not sure lockers would have done a darn thing. Wheels were not even making contact with the mud, so in this case i was sure that a winch was the more valuable of the two. I feel that i could have easily winched myself forward and out of the mud hole and then tugged or winched my friend through was well and continued the journey. But since we didn't have a winch, we were forced into turning around and finding another route.

Second case was the next day. This time my buddy was leading in his tacoma. still up in the mountains and even farther away from civilization. Came around a turn and noticed a frozen puddle. I could see my friend's tire tracks going towards the inside of the turn where only his outside two tires traversed the ice. I followed the same line, but the weight of the 80 prevailed. A sudden crack and my right front tire plunged below the ice. The ice was 4 inches thick. My left tires were on top of the ice spinning, my right tire buried in the ice was sitting doing nothing. I backed my friend up and attached toe straps to our rigs and had him pull. My rig didn't even budge. The ice was so thick it had a strong hold on my front wheel. We had to take big boulders and crack the ice all the way around the tire, and then get a 5 foot start and jerk my rig out of the ice hole. It took about 10 tugs to get me out. I think in this case lockers would not have helped me either. Only tire touching the "ground" was the buried right front. All other tires were on top of the ice spinning. If i had a winch i could have broken the ice and winched myself out of the hole.

In both cases i was lucky and smart enough not to ride trails this remote without a second vehicle. That's just common sense to me. But, i would have felt much more secure with a winch than with lockers alone.

What would you consider the most important mod, winch or lockers?
 
i think this is a rigged poll. if you have locker you can get further in but can you get out? if you have a winch you can drag yourself in or out. with any good rig beit for mud, rocks or expidition (sp) i think it should have both.
 
Since I do not have lockers on my rig, I voted lockers first then winch later. I don't know but the way you were stuck in that mud, you could have got yourself out if you have fr/rr lockers.
 
Noel, i don't think so. Only two of the tires were barely touching the ground. Lockers may have gotten me in further, but i doubt they would have gotten me out.
 
Mr. Jungle,

I voted lockers but that is a decision based upon geography. Mud is rarely an issue in the desert so gettting stuck isn't that frequent. Lockers are far more useful in a dry high traction environment. However if I lived back east, or in the the south I think the winch may take my vote.
dmc
 
Dave, i was in such awww of your trip in the TT i decided to try and make one of my own here on the east side.
 
IMO, winch first, lockers later!

Stock 80 is a pretty capable rig under most conditions. Winch is useful for more than just self recovery.

As you have already discovered, lockers don't mean anything if you're high centered, side hilled, on ice, etc....

Everyones needs will differ, so you will have to decide what would be most useful for you, most of the time.
 
Concrete-Much depends on who you wheel with. If someone in your group has 1-Good sense, and 2-A winch, then your choice is easy-you need lockers, at least a rear one.

If you wheel with the local poor, winch free, goofballs, then you need to play the role of calm sensible one and get a winch. If you go by yourself much, then a winch as well.

How much $ do you have to spend? Maybe you could afford a rear locker, and a used Warn M8000 and a snatch block.
 
I would do both a detroit or aussie for the rear and a winch. I on the other hand went with ff/rr ARBs and will get the winch eventually.
 
I'm asking either/or, not a combination of both. True, both is the way to go, but if you had a budget to do one or the other, which would it be.

I mean, you can't just mount the damn winch on the front bumper, so that means purchasing a ARB, or slee or something, then mounting the winch to it. So that brings the price of a winch and bar to the cost of almost two ARB lockers.
 
TiredIronGRB said:
Concrete, let me know next time you do this ride I would love to go. I'm about 2 hours from Boone. Is there somewhere safe I could leave my tow rig?


Hmmmm..... i would think so, but i can't guarantee it. There are a lot of "good ol' boy" locals that love tow rigs. I think you could find a safe place, just might have to look or perhaps ask a gas station manager. I have seen tow rigs sitting at the entrance to the NF land.
 
I think people get way too excited about winches on stockish rigs. Most good "stucks" on moderate trails are resolved not by going forward, but by coming back out. Given that you should never wheel seriously alone, a group would do well to have one winch in case somebody manages to roll, but everybody should have a strap and front and rear tow points. A good tug is usually all that is needed, and you can generate more force with a tow strap than you can a winch. Where I've seen winches be most useful is on hardcore rigs on hardcore trails where using the winch saves a roll.

Really, there is nothing worse than getting out on the trail and seeing a group driving late model crap with ARB winch bumpers. Because you know they are going to take absolutely forever to run the trail and those winches are going to be working all day long. I've watched groups with winches tie three and four rigs together to try to pull an under-equipped rig up a steep trail, and the only thing that happened was the winch pulled the entire train back down the hill. If you can't go forward on your own, a winch isn't a terribly reliable crutch.

The best solution? Get your lockers, add at least OME and 33" MT tires, and let your friends add 300 lbs of weight with all of the resulting clearance loss. If you get stuck they can pull you back out. If they get stuck? Well, hopefully they can winch forward :flipoff2:

But relying on anything to pull a 5,000 lb+ rig forward off of a high center? Good luck.

Nay
 
1 vote winch here. course my opinion is jaded b/c of how dark,muddy and cold that adventure was. but regardless SE mud and ice says winch first then lockers. and from 1st hand exp w/ this trip i say a winch could have solved each much more successfully than lockers.

oh yeah and the sub 5000 lb rig didnt break through the ice,
only the behuemouth :flipoff2:
 
Nay said:
Most good "stucks" on moderate trails are resolved not by going forward, but by coming back out. . A good tug is usually all that is needed, and you can generate more force with a tow strap than you can a winch. Where I've seen winches be most useful is on hardcore rigs on hardcore trails where using the winch saves a roll.

. If you can't go forward on your own, a winch isn't a terribly reliable crutch.


But relying on anything to pull a 5,000 lb+ rig forward off of a high center? Good luck.

Nay

Straps are an essential tool when off-roading, as is a high lift jack, a shovel, and a spare tire. Straps do not normally allow for the same amount of control as a winch provides, may not be able to be used effectively if there is not room for the other vehicle "to get a run", or if the extraction/help requires a pull from an odd angle...etc,

True, most recoveries can be accomplished best from behind, and if you're willing to "call it a day" and turn around and go home then a strap will do. If you want/need to keep going forward....then you might wish you had a winch. A straps effectiveness is dictated by how much "jerk" another vehicle can impart upon it, and/or how well the other vehicle can gain traction. A winch is limited by anchor points available, line strength, and how many snatch blocks you have.

Dragging 5,000lbs. off of high center is no problem with a snatch block, I've done it many times.

A winch can also be helpful when you venture out by yourself (but must not be thought of as a guarantee) that you will be able to return without help.

Lockers are great, and I have them (front and rear) on two of my vehicles, but it always seems that its the winch that saves the day when I have made a poor driving decision.

Gotta go, my Lab is outside "whining" and dove season has reopened here.
 
Last edited:
I don't have a winch yet on the 80, it does have factory lockers. A winch is on the mod list. I have a built 4runner with lockers and winch. I have an f-250 with just a winch. When I built up a jeep the winch was the first mod.

Lockers will enable you to get stuck a lot further from help, and if you do get stuck it will be a doozy. Having said that, I have only used a winch 3 times to self-extricate a locked up rig.

A winch is good for a lot of peace of mind, especially if you do solo trips. People will jump on you for wheeling alone but if I only wheeled with buddies, my wheeling and exploring would be greatly reduced due to scheduling. Also a winch can be used to greatly reduce the risk of parts carnage. We took a group of 9 rigs through "Outer Limits" in Johnson Valley, the hardest trail I have ever been on (and I have been through the 'Con over 30 times) and did not break anything. Rare for such a large group because we agreed beforehand to put away the egos and use winches if an obstacle proved to be particularly difficult. It only takes one well broken rig in a bad spot to close a trail for hours when 5 minutes with a winch could have prevented the whole clusterfork. Can you tell that I have spent countless hours waiting at the bottom of Cadillac Hill countless times waiting for guys to fix their junk? :mad:

Rant mode off; I obviously vote winch.
 
TiredIronGRB
That will leave a mark.




Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Kingsport, TN
Posts: 208

#11 Concrete, let me know next time you do this ride I would love to go. I'm about 2 hours from Boone. Is there somewhere safe I could leave my tow rig?

Hey Concrete!... Its a toyota not a Jeep, drive the damn thing bud!
 
Back
Top Bottom