Trouble after deleting Cat

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, Skimlinks, and others.

Joined
Dec 1, 2003
Threads
41
Messages
262
Location
Western North Carolina
1997 FZJ80, 130k, bone stock.

I recently deleted one of my cats after replacing my exhaust system and now the engine is running rich with a CEL.

From what I've read, there have been plenty of people who have done this (or both cats) without affecting engine performance or throwing codes.

I replaced both O2 sensors in an attempt to fix it with Denso 234-4157 (Upstream) and Denso 234-4153 (Downstream) and nothing changed. I will say that the 4153 downstream unit was much smaller than the stock unit. Anyone have success with these O2 sensors?

I'm at a loss as to what my step is. Any suggestions?

Here's what I've used so far...
https://www.amazon.com/MagnaFlow-23120-Catalytic-Converter-compliant/dp/B004SH8CR4/?tag=ihco-20
https://www.amazon.com/Denso-234-4153-Oxygen-Sensor/dp/B000C5WCRC/?tag=ihco-20
https://www.amazon.com/Denso-234-4157-Oxygen-Sensor-Ratio/dp/B000C5WCRW/?tag=ihco-20
 
Last edited:
I chose not to put another replacement cat into the new exhaust system because, in a non-emissions state, it seemed pointless to spend money on and pay someone to install an unnecessary piece of emissions equipment. And in the opinion of many other members who have done the exact same thing, it has had zero negative effect on their cruisers.

Is your suggestion to reintroduce a secondary cat into the system?
 
I chose not to put another replacement cat into the new exhaust system because, in a non-emissions state, it seemed pointless to spend money on and pay someone to install an unnecessary piece of emissions equipment. And in the opinion of many other members who have done the exact same thing, it has had zero negative effect on their cruisers.

Is your suggestion to reintroduce a secondary cat into the system?

My recommendation is that you keep it stock if you don't know what you are doing.
 
Last edited:
I would pull the codes to see what malfunction is triggering it.

Since its OBD2 im not suprised. Its probably a P0420 for poor catalyst efficiency bank 1 since the cat is missing
 
1997 FZJ80, 130k, bone stock.

I recently deleted one of my cats after replacing my exhaust system and now the engine is running rich with a CEL.

Do you have codes? Just curious how you know it is running 'rich'?

From what I've read, there have been plenty of people who have done this (or both cats) without affecting engine performance or throwing codes.

One cat maybe, but not both cats, unless they used a OBD2 O2 sensor simulator.

I replaced both O2 sensors in an attempt to fix it with Denso 234-4157 (Upstream) and Denso 234-4153 (Downstream) and nothing changed. I will say that the 4153 downstream unit was much smaller than the stock unit. Anyone have success with these O2 sensors?

Your upstream O2 sensor helps determine/control the air/fuel mixture, it MUST be in good working condition or you will have issues. The downstream O2 sensor only monitors/confirms that the CATS are working and do not affect the mixture.

I'm at a loss as to what my step is. Any suggestions?

IF you have codes, we need to know what they are.

Here's what I've used so far...
https://www.amazon.com/MagnaFlow-23120-Catalytic-Converter-compliant/dp/B004SH8CR4/?tag=ihco-20
https://www.amazon.com/Denso-234-4153-Oxygen-Sensor/dp/B000C5WCRC/?tag=ihco-20
https://www.amazon.com/Denso-234-4157-Oxygen-Sensor-Ratio/dp/B000C5WCRW/?tag=ihco-20

^^^^^^ expand for reply
 
My cats were rattling so I replaced both of them with one magnaflow cat. I ran one cat so I could go over the frame, by keeping two cats you can't go over the frame. The exhaust shop first put the O2 sensor too far back from the cat which caused it to throw a cell. They repositioned the senor closer to the cat and that fixed the CEL issue.
 
Did you space the rear o2 sensor so it tricks it to think there are cats? I know they do this with ls stuff.
 
Don't know if this will help, but my 2002 Chevy Blazer puked it's cat a number of years back. Rather than pay the high $$$ for a factory cat 'system' (GM wanted $1500+), I opted for installing an aftermarket cat. I kept getting the downstream code (don't recall the code), so I 'Hack'd' in a sparkplug extension to the downstream O2 sensor. I cleared out the code and it never returned. Seems that aftermarket cats will allow more O2 through, and that will toss the code. I ended up replacing the Hack'd extension with a stainless steel one from some place I found online.
 
My Bosal secondary cat had melted, so I gutted it, then the Bosal Y-Pipe started leaking at the flange and after numerous welds, I decided to just replace it with a new Magnaflow Y-pipe.

Before installing the new Y-pipe, I gutted the primary cat as well (yes, I gutted a brand new cat)

It's been about 60,000 miles since then and I have yet to throw a code :)
 
1- Truck ran fine, so I removed a part.

2- Truck now doesn't run fine.

3- What's wrong with my truck?

4- (Hint) Refer to step one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JTU
Umm, ok. I don't know what your problem is but I'm just here to get my truck back in order. If anyone has any helpful advice I'd be very appreciative.

Oh I'm sorry, I hurt your feelings by telling you that you did s*** to your truck based on what the very informed folks on MUD said to do.

And things didn't go as planned and now you are on MUD complaining about what the experts on MUD said to do.

As I have told most of my clients, don't let MUD sway you into making bad decisions.

That said, on the inline 95-97 setup, you basically need to make sure that the upline O2 sensor is reading baseline air-fuel correctly according to the ECM parameters, and that the second O2 is reading correctly for catylst efficiency.

If they are doing both correctly for the ECM needs for engine management then you are good to go.

If you do not understand stoiciometry, then you should not be chopping cats out regardless of what anyone on MUD says.
 
Thank you Beno, 3 years ago I replaced the two original stock cats on mine with magnaflo cats. I know these aftermarket cats will not last 217k miles as the stockers did, nonetheless they do work properly and the cost was not that high ( 375 for the pair installed) as compared with all the headaches that folks seem to experience when modifying intakes or exhausts on stock vehicles. So far, at 278k miles no problems at all.
 
You don't need 2 cats, or any at all for the engine to run correctly. You do however, need to know the basic logic of the fueling system to be able to successfully modify it. Doing this stuff on a 90's vehicle is extremely easy once you do some research.

Why do you think it's running rich? What code did you get?
 
I once had a fat bullfrog i tried to make tiny boxer shorts for. The sewing was just too difficult ,so i gave up ,but i know that frog loved me anyhow. Oh well--
 
... with a CEL. ...

Without the code, can guess all day, but is not likely to be productive.

There are three things that the cat targets, 20yrs ago it wasn't common for cats to have the capability for all three, so the stock front cat does two, the rear one. Now 3-way cats are common, done correctly, a single cat can work, has been successfully done many times.
 
My wife's 95 is running a Mickey Mouse single aftermarket cat and her truck has the same problem.

The correct solution (after determining what the CEL is instead of guessing) is to use OEM cats or quality aftermarket cats that satisfy the TWC (Three Way Catalyst) performance covered by Kevin in the above post.
 
Without the code, can guess all day, but is not likely to be productive.

There are three things that the cat targets, 20yrs ago it wasn't common for cats to have the capability for all three, so the stock front cat does two, the rear one. Now 3-way cats are common, done correctly, a single cat can work, has been successfully done many times.
Without the code, can guess all day, but is not likely to be productive.

There are three things that the cat targets, 20yrs ago it wasn't common for cats to have the capability for all three, so the stock front cat does two, the rear one. Now 3-way cats are common, done correctly, a single cat can work, has been successfully done many times.

My rig is a classic example of making it work well with only one cat. I changed mime over about 4 years ago to a small generic cat. Both Ox sensors are positioned nearly identical positions to OEM cats. Works fine, no codes. Maybe I'm just lucky, but it made it very easy to re-route the exhaust over the frame.
 
Back
Top Bottom