I've said before & my track record between owning a well used, 2 owner M12K & a newer M8K - Warn winches seem to last.
I bought the 12K some 15 yrs ago now - rebuilt it with a new seal kit & took the time to grease the planetary gears. It still runs like a clock, and I wore a new wire rope smooth & round & replacd it with synth line 2.5 yrs ago now.
The M8K came used on the sold LX450, had just enough use when sold the synth rope was fraying despite it getting proper de-spool & washing quite often after outings.
I think it really comes down to how you set up your pulls - I always set up a single compound just to get further into the spool (aside from my winch on the quad, it's a winch that if I burn up a motor I'm out like $200) - so with the basic kit Warn has for free with a Warn purchase right now, you can do the same.
I'd be real interested to see if always setup as a compound pull, how long any of the "cheapie brand" winches might last - I prefer to stay with the Warns (mainly because you can buy rebuild kits, motors, solenoid packs, -parts supports if you choose to fix your broken / worn winch) -but really I bet if a guy didn't just do 1st wrap pulls alot of the lesser priced winches would last longer.
If you don't repair your winch - try doing compound pulls & see what it does for the lifespan of your winch. It would be interesting to hear, because really I don't see why a cheap winch you do your best to keep from straining shouldn't last say 40-50 pulls, and for some that's a decade.